this post was submitted on 04 Apr 2024
222 points (95.5% liked)
Asklemmy
43942 readers
947 users here now
A loosely moderated place to ask open-ended questions
If your post meets the following criteria, it's welcome here!
- Open-ended question
- Not offensive: at this point, we do not have the bandwidth to moderate overtly political discussions. Assume best intent and be excellent to each other.
- Not regarding using or support for Lemmy: context, see the list of support communities and tools for finding communities below
- Not ad nauseam inducing: please make sure it is a question that would be new to most members
- An actual topic of discussion
Looking for support?
Looking for a community?
- Lemmyverse: community search
- sub.rehab: maps old subreddits to fediverse options, marks official as such
- !lemmy411@lemmy.ca: a community for finding communities
~Icon~ ~by~ ~@Double_A@discuss.tchncs.de~
founded 5 years ago
MODERATORS
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
I have never heard anyone say that. Presumably they say it because they don’t know any better.
I was raised Catholic in a deeply Evengelical town. The little girls were saying out of the blue that I wasn't Christian. I was like 8, they were like 6. They were absolutely parroting what their parents said, there's no way the little girls I played with daily came up with that shit on their own, and since then I've noticed that's one of the "protestant culture" things that gets passed around in those circles and occasionally escapes. That Catholics aren't Christian because saints or whatever.
They get all wound up about the "pagan" elements of Catholicism then turn around and worship their dollar bill golden idols. Hypocrites!
But basically, Catholics get crapped on when there's no other minority around and they are tired of talking about Jewish folks.
I don't practice, I'm atheist, but in the USA from a culture perspective Catholics aren't in the WASP good old boy group, even if you are otherwise white. And WASP types are happy to let you know it, although its less common than it was a few decades back.
Biden being Catholic, and JFK before him, is basically a dog whistle to certain rightwing groups to make them lose their shit, it's just less obvious than, say, Obama being black esp if you don't have a family background that would expose you to that stuff.
I’m aware of the history, but didn’t know it still lingered. Maybe it’s a regional thing. I haven’t run into this in the metropolitan Northeast or metropolitan West Coast regions. But also I’ve been atheist my whole life, so the topic has seldom come up.
This is alive and well in west coast evangelical culture.
I've run into it when interacting with folks who grew up in the south. It seems moderately common there. With folks who grew up in the northeast, I haven't seen this be a thing.
I grew up going to various Christian schools as a kid. While it wasn't a common viewpoint, I did hear of it from time to time.
The reason behind it, to my knowledge, was that Catholic practices would often be significantly different from other denominations' practices. The biggest thing I can think of is the veneration of and praying to saints.
Which, ironically, is a core part of Abrahamic religions which was abandoned by Protestantism. I.e. Catholicism didn't add minor gods, Protestantism removed them.
Fun fact: the "-el" at the end of all angel names (except Lucifer and Satan, I guess) means "god". Not as in "from god", but as in "the god of-".
Lucifer's Hebrew name is Helel!
Well spotted
Genuine question (and I don’t know if you’ve gone down this rabbit hole) but does “el” in the context of Hebrew names refer to the concept of any god generically or was “el” the name of the one monotheistic god (before being combined with the monotheistic god with the other name) and the “els” in the names of the angels meant to be an attachment to the court of the one god in a similar way to “isra-el” being not another god but a kingdom/people bearing the name of the god it served (of course talking about biblical Israel and not the modern state).
The early Abrahamic and general Canaanite religions are super interesting, I absolutely recommend reading on them. Now, considering I'm neither a historian nor a linguistics expert, take anything I say with a grain of salt.
From my understanding and memory on the subject, "El" was used as the noun "god", as the name of the Canaanite chief god, who would later be usurped by YHWH, and as a title of sorts, meant to indicate gods and important people supposedly affiliated with the pantheon chieftain. I believe the latter is related to the older Assyrian culture, it certainly follows the same pattern. The first and second cases weren't widely concurrent, however - there is a clear trace telling us the original pantheon leader lost influence over time before being relegated to "just another god" and finally getting absorbed into the figure of YHWH, a bit like how Odinn slowly faded into the background of Nordic religion as Thor became the figure you'd pray to.
In short: both of your scenarios are right, but at different points in history (except they weren't monotheistic at first).
This is true about El.
I don't remember if YHWH is associated with Assyrian culture though.
But if anyone is interested, I recommend reading Mark S. Smith's The Early History of God. It's very dry and dense, but extremely informative.
I didn't mean to imply a relation between YHWH and Assyria, but rather link the Assyrian culture of appending god names to important figures' names and the Canaanite culture of appending "-el" to indicate allegiance.
Me neither. Literally never seen or heard anyone say that.
It sounds super weird.
I'm guessing from the other comments in this thread that it's just a USA thing. Super weird.
I think it has to be. In worldwide terms, Catholocism is the biggest Christian sect/denomination.