What a dickhead.
this post was submitted on 09 Jan 2025
17 points (84.0% liked)
Music
8237 readers
234 users here now
founded 2 years ago
MODERATORS
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
It’s a fair take. I still like listening to The Ramones but they are, by far, the least talented group to come out of that CBGB era.
Their main contribution was showing the disaffected youth of the USA that you didn’t need talent or much money to get on stage a be heard.
Worth noting The Ramones are more influential than the Smiths could hope to be.
Depends on which continent you're taking about. In the US, sure, the music of the Ramones is much more widely known, and while the Smiths are known, their influence is much more along the lines of "your favorite band's favorite band."
In the UK (and I'm guessing in continental Europe as well), those positions are reversed (IME as an American who listens to a fair bit of British post-punk and reads a lot of music journalism/criticism).
No, it doesn't. The Smiths never had the widespread acceptance the Ramones had nor is there a sub-genre of music they are responsible for like TheRamones were.
You have a FUCKLOAD of bands from all over the world that do Ramones inspired punk. There are almost no bands trying to be the Smiths and given what a sack of shit Morrissey has become I doubt he will be remembered for very long once he stops performing.
Morrissey is indeed a problematic guy. But 100 years from now some depressed teen's going to stream "Please Please Please Let Me Get What I Want" and they're going to get tears in their eyes and they're going to say omg somebody gets me. And a couple years later they'll start a band.