Friendly Carnivore
Carnivore
The ultimate, zero carb, elimination diet
Meat Heals.
We are focused on health and lifestyle while trying to eat zero carb bioavailable foods.
Keep being AWESOME
We welcome engaged, polite, and logical debates and questions of any type
Purpose
- lifestyle
- food
- Science
- problems
- Recipes
- Sustainability
- Regenerative lifestyle
Rules
- Be nice
- Stay on topic
- Don't farm rage
- Be respectful of other diets, choices, lifestyles!!!!
- No Blanket down voting - If you only come to this community to downvote its the wrong community for you
- No LLM generated posts . Don't represent machine output as your own, and don't use machines to burn human response time.
Other terms: LCHF Carnivore, Keto Carnivore, Ketogenic Carnivore, Low Carb Carnivore, Zero Carb Carnivore, Animal Based Diet, Animal Sourced Foods
Resource Post!- Papers - Books - Channels
Carnivore Resources
YouTube Carnivore
Science Based, Factual Discussions:
Experience, testimonials:
Nutritionists/Coaches:
Lifestyle/Influencers:
Mini-Series on all aspects of the Meat science, heath, nutrition, and environment
Books Carnivore
Websites Carnivore
Excellent resource with many references on all things carnivore, may have to click around, recommend
Ketogenic Resources
Carnivore is a subset of Ketogenic eating, so all of the benefits for keto also apply here
YouTube Ketogenic
Science Based, Lectures:
Websites Ketogenic
Science, Guides, Recipes , Hard Science, highly recommended
Keto Virtual Health Program - monitoring, medication titration, coaching, excellent
Books Ketogenic
- Ketogenic : The Science of Therapeutic Carbohydrate Restriction in Human Health
- Why We Get Sick: The Hidden Epidemic at the Root of Most Chronic Disease--and How to Fight It
- How Not to Get Sick: A Cookbook and Guide to Prevent and Reverse Insulin Resistance, Lose Weight, and Fight Chronic Disease
Feel free to add any suggestions below.

There are many dietary patterns available and in the zeitgeist.
MacroNutrient
On the macronutrient scale we have 3^3 (27) choices, the most common are:
- HCHFLP - High Carb, High Fat, Low Protein : This is the "standard"/default western diet
- HCLFMP - High Carb, Low Fat, Medium Protein: This is the default "healthy" diet recommended by media
- HCLFHP - High Carb, Low Fat, High Protein: A body builder bulking diet
- MCLFHP - Medium Carb, Low Fat, High Protein: Body builder cutting diet
- LCHFMP - Low Carb, High Fat, Moderate Protein : A diet that maintains the metabolic state of ketosis
MicroNutrients Inside of any macronutrient regime there are essential micronutrients/minerals that are required. Essential means the body does not have the ability to produce them from other sources. There are too many to list here, but using a diet tool like chronometer (free and can use the website) will let you see if your covering your micronutrient targets (Recommend Daily Intakes). One note is that the RDAs are usually minimums (though in some contexts may be more then necessary).
Cronometer example micronutrient display
Importantly, VERY importantly, not all foods are ingested by the human body the same, so the amount on the label is not the same that ends up in the body. This is a good paper discussing the bioavailabilty measurements of food, DIAAS seems to be the best scoring system out there to date.
Whole Foods
Regardless of macro and micro nutrient choices, the evidence, and consensus across medical professionals, and zealots, is that eating whole foods from natural sources that are not industrialized and hyper processed is a good guide to health and better outcomes.
If the ingredients for what you are eating are more complex than the name of the thing, you shouldn't eat it. Don't eat food from a factory out of a box and wrapped in plastic!
I.e. shop the outside edge of the grocery store, not the aisles in the middle.
This might be somewhat controversial, but I would include modern seed oils as a type of processed food to be avoided on a Whole food Diet. No vegetable oils that come from a factory please!
Low Carb High Fat / Ketogenic
The LCHF, ketogenic/keto/atkins, macronutrient profile has many benefits - Increasing insulin sensitivity and reducing the issues insulin resistance causes (obesity, hyper tension, pcos, diabetes 2, etc).
The key schism of LCHF diets is over the dietary necessity (or lack thereof) of carbohydrates, this well referenced document is a must read for those who are incredulous. There is NO SUCH THING AS AN ESSENTIAL CARBOHYDRATE - the human body can do gluconeogenesis and produce all the glucose it needs from fat.
Sometimes this LCHF diet is referred to a fed-fasting diet, since it maintains metabolic ketosis even when eating.
The core mechanism of action here is allowing insulin levels to return, and stay at, normal levels throughout the day which enables the body - an amazing homeostasis machine - to function properly. The body is full of feedback mechanisms, like hunger, thirst, satisfaction, etc - to stay in optimal bounds.
Being on a LCHF diet is easy to maintain, because you're not hungry, you can eat as much as you want - you just let your body self regulate.
NOTE - if you are on some medications, such as high blood pressure, and insulin, changing your diet can change the effectiveness of these medications and should be done under medical supervision. Either with your doctor, a metabolic doctor, or a service such as virta. Watch your biomarkers when you change a diet to make sure your medications are not taking you outside of your targets.
LCHF diets can include Plant based diets (vegetarian/vegan), Animal Based Foods (Carnivore), or any mix in between (just keto, or ketovore)
Insulin Sensitivity
93% of Americans (and probably similar in western countries) have insulin resistance, this can manifest as obesity, or high blood pressure, visceral fat, diabetes, etc. It may not be visible at all - Skinny Fat - Thin Outside Fat Inside (TOFI).
You can use your TG/HDL ratio has a very good approximation for your insulin sensitivity. You want to be <0.9 (mmol/L) or <2 (mg/dL). If your ratio is low, congratulations you are insulin sensitive
Carnivore
Carnivore is a strict subset of a LCHF/Ketogenic diet that restricts itself to only animal sourced foods (ASF). The reasons for doing this can include:
- Better food bioavailability - Need to eat less food
- Inflammation from different plant based foods - oxalate / lectins
- Allergies
- Regenerative and Sustainable farming lifestyle (Local farm can provide biocomplete nutrition without needed to transport rare foods over long distances)
- Ease of adherence (not that many choices, hard to do it wrong, don't have to count carbs)
ASFs are almost entirely digested in the stomach and large intestine, very little makes it to the small intestine - This is why people eating strict carnivore have less frequent bowel movements, and people with gut issues can see impactful quality of life improvements on this intervention
What should you choose?
Ask yourself what you're trying to achieve? What issues are you tackling? The only thing that matters in personal health is your personal outcomes. Focus on what works for you, or is specifically sustainable for you.
Weight Loss - Don't lose weight to get healthy, get healthy to lose weight - A LCHF diet, or even a Whole Food diet, can be used to regain a healthy metabolism
Most of the benefits of Carnivore can be achieved with just LCHF/keto (Even a vegan keto diet). In terms of most effective things you can do, don't worry about carnivore start with LCHF.
If LCHF/Keto isn't enough, such as persistent inflammation, or prolonged gut issues, then Carnivore could be a good option for you.
If you're insulin sensitive, you can keep doing whatever you have been doing - Keep being awesome!
Civility
I'm sure this conversation will touch on people's passions and triggers, I just ask that when you participate you consider the whole human and speak with each other with compassion and empathy for their choices.

TLDW: Fiber is not essential for health.
summerizer
Summary
In this comprehensive discussion on gut health and low-carbohydrate diets, the speaker challenges common nutritional beliefs, emphasizing that dietary fiber is not essential for a healthy diet. The presentation highlights that certain low-carb foods rich in fiber and FODMAPs (fermentable carbohydrates) can cause bloating, constipation, and other gut symptoms. The speaker critically reviews scientific evidence around fiber’s role in constipation and finds that, contrary to popular belief, increasing fiber intake may worsen constipation and bloating. In contrast, low- or zero-fiber diets have shown significant improvements in bowel symptoms.
The talk explains the physiological basis of constipation and why fiber’s function of increasing stool bulk might not aid stool passage, as larger stools can be harder to expel. It also clarifies that fiber does not hydrate stools, debunking another common assumption. The fermentation of fiber by gut bacteria produces short-chain fatty acids (SCFAs) and gases, which can cause discomfort.
The speaker further explores FODMAPs, a group of poorly absorbed short-chain carbohydrates that cause osmotic effects and gas production, contributing to irritable bowel syndrome (IBS) symptoms like bloating, diarrhea, and constipation. Many low-carb foods, including broccoli and nuts, contain FODMAPs, which explains why some people on low-carb diets experience digestive issues.
The role of gut microbiota is examined, particularly the relationship between bacterial phyla (Firmicutes and Bacteroidetes) and obesity. While changes in gut bacteria are associated with weight loss or gain, the speaker clarifies that diet-induced changes in microbiota are likely a consequence, not a cause, of weight changes. The famous 2006 mouse study showing that microbiota transplants can affect weight is discussed, but limitations are pointed out.
Finally, the talk touches on how modern dietary components, such as trehalose (a sugar used in processed foods), can alter gut bacteria and lead to serious infections, underscoring that what we eat impacts our microbiome, sometimes negatively.
The concluding message is clear: fiber is not indispensable for gut health, some low-carb foods high in fiber or FODMAPs can cause gut discomfort, and the idea of manipulating gut bacteria to lose weight remains scientifically unsupported.
Highlights
- 🌾 Fiber is not essential for a healthy diet and may worsen constipation and bloating.
- 🥦 Certain low-carb foods rich in fiber or FODMAPs can cause gut symptoms like bloating and constipation.
- 💨 Fermentation of fiber by gut bacteria produces gases causing discomfort, not hydration of stool.
- 🦠 Gut microbiota changes with diet but are more likely effects, not causes, of weight loss or gain.
- 🍞 FODMAPs, found in many foods including some low-carb ones, contribute significantly to IBS symptoms.
- 🐁 Microbiota transplant studies in germ-free mice have limitations and do not directly translate to humans.
- 🍦 Modern food additives like trehalose can negatively impact gut bacteria, leading to serious health issues.
Key Insights
-
🌱 Fiber’s Role in Constipation Is Overstated: Despite widespread recommendations, there is no strong randomized controlled trial evidence supporting fiber’s efficacy to relieve constipation symptoms. In fact, clinical observations show that a zero-fiber diet can completely alleviate constipation symptoms in many patients, challenging the dogma that fiber is always beneficial. This insight demands a re-evaluation of fiber’s role in managing bowel health, especially in those with chronic constipation.
-
💨 Gas Production from Fiber Fermentation Affects Gut Comfort: Soluble fibers ferment in the colon, producing short-chain fatty acids (SCFAs) and gases such as hydrogen. This fermentation can cause bloating and abdominal pain, especially when excessive fiber is consumed. Insoluble fibers, while increasing stool bulk, do not hydrate stools or ease passage, often exacerbating symptoms by increasing rectal distension. Therefore, fiber's mechanical and fermentative effects on the gut can be counterproductive for individuals prone to bloating or IBS-like symptoms.
-
🥦 FODMAPs and Low-Carb Diets: Many people following low-carb diets inadvertently consume significant amounts of FODMAPs from vegetables like broccoli and nuts, which can ferment and attract water in the gut, causing diarrhea or constipation. Recognizing FODMAP content in low-carb foods is vital for managing digestive symptoms, illustrating that low-carb does not automatically mean low-fermentable carbohydrate intake. This subtlety is critical for dietary adjustments in sensitive individuals.
-
🦠 Microbiome Changes Are a Consequence, Not a Cause, of Weight Loss: Although gut microbiota composition differs between obese and lean individuals (e.g., higher Firmicutes in obesity, higher Bacteroidetes in leanness), these changes follow dietary shifts rather than drive weight changes. The 2006 mouse microbiota transplant study, often cited to support causality, applies to germ-free mice without existing microbiota, a condition not comparable to humans. Thus, diet modification remains the primary tool for weight management, with microbiome changes as secondary phenomena.
-
🔬 Short-Chain Fatty Acids (SCFAs) and Colon Health: SCFAs produced by bacterial fermentation are not solely beneficial. While they provide energy to colonocytes and may support gut integrity, their production is not unique to fiber fermentation. Animal-based diets rich in protein also generate SCFAs. Moreover, circulating ketones, such as those produced in ketogenic diets, may be more effective for colon health than SCFAs, indicating alternative metabolic pathways support colonocyte function beyond fiber intake.
-
🍭 Artificial Sweeteners and Gut Health: Polyols, sugar alcohols commonly used in low-carb bars and snacks, poorly absorbed in the intestine, can cause osmotic diarrhea and gas, leading to discomfort. This explains why some individuals on low-carb diets experience diarrhea after consuming products like Atkins bars. Awareness of these additives is essential for managing digestive health in low-carb dietary contexts.
-
⚠️ Dietary Components Can Adversely Affect Microbiota: The example of trehalose, a sugar increasingly used in processed foods, illustrates how novel food additives can promote the growth of harmful bacteria such as Clostridium difficile, leading to serious infections. This highlights the dynamic and sometimes detrimental impact of modern diets on gut microbiota, underscoring the importance of understanding how food additives influence gut health beyond macronutrient content.
Conclusion
This talk fundamentally challenges entrenched nutritional wisdom, particularly the universal promotion of dietary fiber for gut health. It provides evidence that high fiber intake, especially insoluble fiber, can worsen constipation and bloating, and that zero-fiber diets can effectively resolve these symptoms. It also clarifies the role of fermentable carbohydrates (FODMAPs) in digestive discomfort, even within low-carb diets, and cautions against simplistic views about the gut microbiome’s causal role in obesity. The nuanced examination of microbiota, SCFAs, and dietary additives like trehalose offers a more critical understanding of how diet shapes gut health. Ultimately, the speaker calls for a more evidence-based view of fiber and microbiota manipulation, advocating awareness of individual responses to fiber and fermentable carbohydrates, especially in low-carb dietary frameworks.
Why This Could Happen When You Start Carnivore Are you experiencing joint pain, rashes, fatigue, or strange symptoms after starting the carnivore diet? You might be dealing with oxalate dumping—a hidden detox process that most people have never heard of.
In this video, Dr. Tony Hampton breaks down:
- What oxalates are and how they build up in the body
- What “dumping” really means and why it happens when you stop eating plants
- The symptoms to watch for—and how to know it’s not just “the meat”
- Step-by-step strategies to reduce oxalate dumping symptoms
- What to eat and avoid during this detox phase
Whether you're new to carnivore, coming from a plant-based diet, or just want to understand what’s happening inside your body, this video gives you the science, solutions, and encouragement to keep going.
summerizer
Summary
The video, presented by Dr. Tony Hampton, addresses a common concern among people who have recently started the carnivore diet or other low-carb regimens like keto: feeling worse instead of better. Symptoms such as joint pain, rashes, fatigue, cloudy urine, and other strange bodily sensations may actually be due to a process called oxalate dumping rather than the diet itself. Oxalates are natural defense compounds found in many plant foods like spinach, almonds, beets, and sweet potatoes. When consumed in large quantities over time, oxalates accumulate in the body’s tissues, joints, kidneys, and skin, often without immediate symptoms. However, when someone suddenly cuts these oxalate-rich foods out of their diet, the body begins to detoxify and release stored oxalates—a process known as oxalate dumping. This can cause uncomfortable and confusing symptoms that mimic illness or diet intolerance.
Dr. Hampton explains that oxalate dumping can take days, weeks, or even months to begin after dietary changes. People who previously consumed high-oxalate diets or had gut issues like leaky gut, IBS, or SIBO are especially prone to this. There may also be genetic factors affecting oxalate excretion. To manage oxalate dumping, Dr. Hampton advises not to panic or quit the diet but to ease the transition by tapering off oxalate-rich foods gradually rather than abruptly. Hydration, mineral intake (especially calcium and magnesium), electrolyte balance, gut and liver support, and avoiding high doses of vitamin C are all critical strategies to support detoxification and reduce symptoms. He recommends carnivore-friendly foods rich in natural calcium and nutrients, such as beef, lamb, pork, eggs, sardines with bones, and bone broth.
Oxalate dumping is difficult to diagnose with standard medical tests and is primarily identified through symptom patterns correlated with dietary changes. Dr. Hampton reassures viewers that feeling worse initially is a sign of the body beginning to heal and detoxify, not a failure of the diet. He encourages patience, education, and support, emphasizing that this phase is temporary and that perseverance will lead to breakthroughs in health.
Highlights
- 🥩 Oxalate dumping occurs when the body releases stored oxalates after cutting out high-oxalate plant foods.
- 🌿 Oxalates are natural compounds in many plants used as defense mechanisms against being eaten.
- ⚠️ Symptoms of oxalate dumping include joint pain, rashes, fatigue, cloudy urine, and headaches.
- 🐄 Gradually tapering off oxalate-rich foods helps reduce the severity of dumping symptoms.
- 💧 Staying hydrated and maintaining mineral balance, especially calcium and magnesium, supports oxalate detox.
- 🔍 Oxalate dumping is mostly diagnosed through clinical history and symptom patterns, not routine lab tests.
- 💪 Feeling worse temporarily is a sign of healing, not a reason to quit the carnivore or keto diet.
Key Insights
-
🧬 Oxalates as a Plant Defense Mechanism: Oxalates serve as a natural defense for plants, discouraging animals from consuming them by forming sharp crystals that can irritate or harm tissues. This evolutionary adaptation explains why many nutritious plants contain these compounds and why they can accumulate harmfully in humans who consume them regularly over time. Understanding this biological role helps contextualize why oxalate accumulation occurs and why sudden removal of these foods triggers detox symptoms.
-
🔄 Oxalate Dumping as a Detoxification Process: The concept of oxalate dumping reframes adverse symptoms experienced on diets like carnivore or keto as a natural healing process. When the intake of oxalates stops, the body sequestered oxalates begin to mobilize and exit through urine and tissues. This process can produce symptoms that mimic illness or diet intolerance, causing confusion and leading some to abandon beneficial diets prematurely. Recognizing oxalate dumping prevents misattribution of symptoms and promotes adherence.
-
🕰️ Variable Onset and Duration of Symptoms: Oxalate dumping symptoms don’t always appear immediately after dietary change; they can arise days, weeks, or months later. This delayed and fluctuating timing adds complexity to diagnosis and management. Symptoms are often transient, migratory, and cyclical, reflecting the dynamic nature of oxalate mobilization. Patients and clinicians should maintain awareness of this pattern to avoid misdiagnosis.
-
👥 Risk Factors Increase Oxalate Load: Diets high in spinach, nuts, sweet potatoes, and other oxalate-rich foods, combined with gut issues such as leaky gut, IBS, or SIBO, increase oxalate absorption and storage. Additionally, genetic differences in oxalate transport proteins can impair excretion. This multifactorial risk profile explains why some individuals experience severe symptoms while others do not, underscoring the need for personalized dietary transitions.
-
🛠️ Practical Strategies Mitigate Symptoms: Gradual dietary tapering rather than abrupt elimination of oxalates lessens the intensity of dumping symptoms by allowing the body to detoxify more gently. Adequate hydration supports renal excretion of oxalates, while calcium and magnesium bind oxalates in the gut to prevent reabsorption. Supporting gut and liver health through nutrient-dense foods and supplements facilitates detox pathways. Avoiding high-dose vitamin C is crucial because excess vitamin C converts to oxalates.
-
🔬 Challenges in Medical Diagnosis: Oxalate dumping is primarily a clinical diagnosis based on patient history and symptom chronology rather than standard laboratory tests. While oxalate crystals may be visible under a microscope in urine, this is rarely assessed clinically. Awareness among healthcare professionals remains low, leading to potential misdiagnosis or unnecessary investigations.
-
🌟 Healing Is a Process, Not an Event: Dr. Hampton’s message emphasizes that worsening symptoms during dietary transitions are not failures but signs of the body’s innate ability to heal and clear accumulated toxins. This perspective encourages patience, reduces fear, and builds resilience during challenging phases. Support, education, and gradual dietary adjustments empower individuals to continue their health journeys without losing hope.
This comprehensive understanding of oxalate dumping offers valuable guidance not only for those adopting carnivore or keto diets but for anyone transitioning away from high-oxalate plant-based eating patterns. By recognizing and managing oxalate dumping, individuals can avoid unnecessary distress, optimize detoxification, and ultimately achieve improved health outcomes.
TLDR - Linoleic acid is bad, has gone up by 140%, has a half life of 600 days, and gets stored in fat tissue, Dietary sources of LA (industrial oils) have a direct influence on body composition.
Linoleic acid (LA) is a bioactive fatty acid with diverse effects on human physiology and pathophysiology. LA is a major dietary fatty acid, and also one of the most abundant fatty acids in adipose tissue, where its concentration reflects dietary intake. Over the last half century in the United States, dietary LA intake has greatly increased as dietary fat sources have shifted toward polyunsaturated seed oils such as soybean oil. We have conducted a systematic literature review of studies reporting the concentration of LA in subcutaneous adipose tissue of US cohorts. Our results indicate that adipose tissue LA has increased by 136% over the last half century and that this increase is highly correlated with an increase in dietary LA intake over the same period of time.
Full Paper https://doi.org/10.3945/an.115.009944

I was doing so good, 10 months of clean pure carnivore. I had amazing results (45kg lost). I didn't have any cravings.
I feel off the wagon 2 weeks ago. It started innocently enough - A friend visiting from out of town wanted to go to a coffee shop and eat. They had pastrami bagels, I got one, scrapped off the meat - didn't eat the bagel. It was good. Really good. I found myself ordering this pastrami bagel to my house. Slowly enough that I didn't realize it, my old carvings came back. I found myself thinking of a deep dish pizza, over and over and over again.
There must have been sugar in the pastrami, I think I got triggered. I got the pizza, rationalizing it - I've been so good, just one cheat will be fine, then back on track. I felt bloated, stuffed, sick even - for the rest of the day. But... the next day, now I REALLY wanted a pizza - Fuck it. Got the pizza, and coffee (oh, did I mention I quit coffee 5 months ago?), and rice krispie treats.
Fast forward a few binge days... I'm feeling both HUNGRY and bloated at the same time. I tell myself I'm in control, I just need to get it out of my system. I fast for one day. I feel back in control. So it's ok to cheat again... pizza again.
During this 2 week orgy of old habits - I ate a bunch of pizza, rice krispies, cookies (that I hated, but still finished). Eventually I stopped feeling bloated, I just felt hungry.
Serious things I noticed
- Constant cravings for old addictions
- Gained 2kg
- eczema came back on my hands
- pimple breakout
- acid reflux while trying to sleep
- old joint problem flared up, with constant pain
- eye floaters came back
- gym performance steady decreased
- gym recovery time went from almost immediate, to 3 days
- sauna endurance plummeted (I could only stand half the time)
- reduced sexual function
So why, why with these bad things, the constant joint pain, the acne, the eczema, the bloating... did I keep going on? When I ate I felt like I could stop it, but every day I told myself the next day. Tomorrow never came. The urges were persistent, just there constantly, I could say no... for a few hours but eventually I pulled the trigger.
8 days ago my friend came over, she has uncontrolled t2d, we both agreed to start getting clean the next day. I tried, she tried, we both couldn't do it... but I lied to her, I said I was being clean (or rather omitting that I had cheated on our pact). and the next day, and the next day.
4 days ago - I finally was able to stay clean all day. I was extremely triggered. Like a degenerate I kept putting food into my delivery app, looking at it, looking at different options - browsing my own food hookup app. I could have a Cannoli, it's been years since I had a cannoli! How about one last rice krispie, some fudge? Looking at my youtube watch history it was dominated by food, food preparation, more food porn. I struggled through it until the pizza place was closed, and I could hold off till the next day
3 days ago - The cravings were diminished, but replaced by a persistent longing - a gossamer hand on my shoulder turning me to old thoughts. It got bad, I almost cracked. Finally I mixed 75g of protein powder as a shake and downed it... Felt bloated, felt painfully full, but the food noise died down enough I could get past that day.
2 days ago - Mostly clean all day, I had the urge but if I kept busy I could ignore it. When I slowed down or had time to myself it came back. I was clean for two days, one last taste to set me up for success... I talked with my friend, we talked about the struggle, getting someone else involved helped.
Continued in comment below -

This Nick Norwitz video presents the biochemical link between inflammation and anxiety
It made me wonder - is this part of the reported cool that you hear about in carnivore circles. Is it just (or maybe mostly) that the lifestyle prevents the bulk of inflammation and thus the anxiety that inflammation would have caused
7 Reasons Plant-Based Diets Can Harm You Are plant-based diets really the healthiest choice?
In this video, Dr. Tony Hampton—board-certified obesity specialist and former vegetarian—dives into 7 hidden dangers of plant-based eating that can silently impact your brain, bones, metabolism, and more.
While plant-based diets can work with extreme intention, most people don’t realize what they’re missing—literally. From vitamin B12 and omega-3s to retinol and zinc, Dr. Hampton explains why so many well-meaning vegans and vegetarians eventually experience issues like fatigue, premature aging, low muscle mass, and poor immunity.
summerizer
Summary
This video presents a critical examination of plant-based diets, specifically highlighting seven key nutrient deficiencies common in such diets that can accelerate aging and impair overall health. The speaker, who spent eight years as a vegetarian and vegan, shares personal experience and clinical insights from his work as a healthcare provider. He explains that while plant-based diets initially seem healthy—thanks largely to the elimination of processed foods—they often lack essential nutrients critical for maintaining muscle, bone, nerve, brain, immune, blood, and skin health. The deficiencies include leucine (an essential amino acid for muscle maintenance), vitamin K2 (which directs calcium to bones), vitamin B12 (necessary for nerve function and red blood cell formation), long-chain omega-3 fatty acids DHA and EPA (crucial for brain and eye health), zinc (important for immunity and hormone production), bioavailable iron (required for oxygen transport), and retinol (preformed vitamin A necessary for skin and vision). The speaker argues that relying solely on plants without careful supplementation or animal-based foods can lead to premature aging, cognitive decline, muscle loss, bone fragility, depression, and other chronic health conditions. He advocates for an animal-inclusive diet as a nutrient-dense, efficient, and safer long-term solution, especially for communities lacking access to extensive testing and supplements. The video ends with a call to action for viewers to evaluate their diet, consider reintroducing animal foods if needed, and engage with the channel for ongoing nutritional education.
Highlights
- 🥦 Initial plant-based benefits often stem from cutting out junk food, not from nutrient completeness.
- 💪 Leucine deficiency in plant-based diets accelerates muscle loss and frailty.
- 🦴 Lack of vitamin K2 can misdirect calcium, causing bone loss and artery calcification.
- 🧠 Vitamin B12 and DHA deficiencies from plant diets impair brain health and increase neurodegeneration risk.
- 🛡️ Zinc shortage weakens immunity, skin health, and hormone balance.
- 🩸 Plant-based iron is poorly absorbed, causing fatigue and impaired oxygen delivery.
- 👁️ Retinol absence in plant diets leads to vision issues, skin problems, and immune dysfunction.
Key Insights
-
💡 Muscle Health Requires Complete Proteins and Leucine: The speaker highlights leucine as a crucial amino acid that signals muscle protein synthesis via the mTor pathway. Plant proteins are often incomplete and low in leucine, which becomes particularly problematic with aging, leading to sarcopenia—a condition of muscle wasting associated with falls and metabolic disorders. This insight underscores that maintaining muscle mass with a plant-based diet demands great care, possibly necessitating sophisticated supplementation or protein pairing that is not always practical.
-
🦴 Vitamin K2 is Essential for Directed Calcium Metabolism: Unlike calcium, which is abundant in plant foods, vitamin K2’s role is less understood but vital—it functions like a GPS system, guiding calcium to bones and preventing its harmful deposition in arteries. Because K2 is virtually absent in plants (except fermented natto, which is rarely consumed), plant-based eaters face heightened risks of bone demineralization (osteopenia, fractures) and cardiovascular calcification, conditions often overlooked when focusing solely on calcium intake.
-
🧠 Vitamin B12 Deficiency Has Severe Neurological and Cardiovascular Consequences: B12’s absence in plant diets leads to neurological impairments including brain fog, memory loss, and neuropathy. It also contributes to elevated homocysteine, a dangerous compound linked to heart and brain diseases. Importantly, people with MTHFR gene mutations face even greater challenges in managing homocysteine, intensifying B12’s essential role and revealing genetic vulnerabilities that plant-based diets must carefully address.
-
🐟 Conversion Inefficiency of Omega-3s Undermines Brain and Mood: While plant-based diets provide ALA (a precursor), the body's conversion rate to EPA and DHA—critical omega-3 fatty acids for brain, retinal, and cell membrane health—is inefficient (often under 5%). This leads to faster brain shrinkage, higher rates of depression, cognitive decline, and neurodegeneration in plant-only eaters. In contrast, DHA fats from animal sources are readily available, bypassing this metabolic bottleneck.
-
🛡️ Zinc Absorption is Compromised by Plant-Based Phytates: Despite zinc’s crucial roles in immunity, testosterone production, skin health, and healing, plant-based phytates bind zinc and block its absorption. This leads to subtle deficiency symptoms such as frequent infections, skin problems, and libido issues that may go unnoticed until critical, demonstrating that plant-based diets require vigilant zinc management.
-
🩸 Non-Heme Iron's Poor Bioavailability Fuels Chronic Fatigue and Organ Stress: Iron deficiency anemia is common among plant-based eaters because plant iron is non-heme and poorly absorbed, especially when inhibited by phytates and oxalates. This deficiency manifests as fatigue, pale skin, brittle nails, and cold sensitivity, stressing multiple systems like the thyroid and brain—even if standard blood tests show "normal" iron levels.
-
👁️ Retinol Deficiency Stunts Vital Functions Beyond Vitamin A Precursors: Plant foods supply beta-carotene but require conversion to retinol, the active form of vitamin A essential for night vision, skin renewal, immune defense, and reproductive health. This conversion decreases with age, thyroid issues, gut health problems, and genetic factors. Animal-sourced retinol is ready-made, mitigating these risks and supporting critical systems that plant-only diets may jeopardize over time.
In essence, these insights expose the complexity and hidden risks of plant-based nutrition, emphasizing the importance of either meticulous supplementation or the inclusion of animal products for long-term vitality and disease prevention. The video troubles the oversimplified perception that plant-based diets are universally beneficial by illuminating crucial micronutrient deficiencies and their physiological consequences.
In this video, I break down what Joe Rogan has said about and experienced on the carnivore diet.
Joe Rogan is divisive, but he is probably the most famous person to try carnivore.
Max German puts together a EXCELLENT over view of the data, science, and best practices I've seen about Carnivore. I can't find fault with anything Max covers. He even talks about Rogan's adaption issues.
summerizer
Summary
The video transcript details a personal experience and an in-depth exploration of the carnivore diet, supplemented by insights from Joe Rogan's experimentation and commentary on this nutritional approach. The narrator recounts their own month-long carnivore diet journey, noting significant weight loss (12 pounds), sustained, stable energy levels, and improvement in an autoimmune condition (vitiligo). They emphasize how eliminating carbohydrates prevents the typical blood sugar spikes and crashes that cause cravings and energy dips, leading to more consistent satiety on a meat-only diet. Joe Rogan’s perspective is heavily spotlighted, highlighting his views on how carnivore naturally limits food intake, functionality in fat loss, and mental clarity due to ketosis and the brain’s preference for ketones over sugars.
The discussion critically deconstructs common epidemiological studies suggesting red meat consumption is harmful, noting these studies often suffer from major flaws such as self-reported dietary data, uncontrolled variables, healthy user bias, and poor categorization of processed meat with whole meat consumption. The video stresses there is no credible scientific proof that meat directly causes disease and that human biology is evolved to consume meat optimally.
Transition difficulties when starting the carnivore diet, such as diarrhea and bile production lag, are explained as temporary disruptions as the gut microbiome adapts and bile output increases. Mental improvements on the diet are attributed to consistent energy, reduced inflammation from plant toxins, and the essential role of saturated fats and cholesterol in maintaining brain myelin and neural function.
The video also addresses muscle glycogen and exercise performance, explaining that initial fatigue in athletes starting carnivore is due to the body’s transition phase before becoming “fat adapted.” After adaptation, gluconeogenesis replaces dietary carbs as the glycogen source, allowing athletes to perform equally well or better on low-carb or carnivore diets. Contemporary research and some top sports scientists, including converted carbohydrate advocates, back this view. The success of various top athletes and teams adopting similar diets is cited.
Overall, the video endorses the carnivore diet as biologically appropriate and beneficial, complimenting Joe Rogan’s firsthand positive experiences, while suggesting longer-term adherence is key for overcoming early adaptation challenges and fully reaping benefits.
Highlights
- 🥩 The carnivore diet leads to stable energy levels by avoiding blood sugar spikes and crashes typical of carbohydrate intake.
- ⚖️ Carnivore naturally limits food intake, contributing to effective fat loss and satiety.
- 🔬 Epidemiological studies linking red meat to disease often rely on biased, uncontrolled self-report data and do not prove causation.
- 🧠 Brain function improves on carnivore due to ketones as fuel and reduced inflammation from plant toxins.
- 🚽 Initial digestive issues like diarrhea during carnivore are caused by gut microbiome shifts and adaptation of bile production.
- 💪 Athletes experience temporary fatigue starting carnivore due to glycogen adaptation but match or exceed performance after becoming fat-adapted.
- 🏅 Numerous elite athletes and teams succeed with low-carb or carnivore diets, indicating viability for high-level performance.
Key Insights
-
🥩 Carnivore Diet’s Effect on Satiety and Energy Stability: The diet’s exclusive focus on protein and fat eliminates carbohydrate-driven insulin spikes that inhibit leptin signaling—the hormone responsible for feeling full. This biochemical mechanism explains why people on carnivore experience prolonged satiety and steady energy, reducing overeating and cravings. This contrasts sharply with “standard” diets rich in carbohydrates that provoke cycles of hunger and energy crashes.
-
🔬 Faults in Epidemiological Meat Studies and “Healthy User Bias”: Many studies reporting negative health effects from meat consumption are misinterpreted survey analyses subject to recall errors, confounding lifestyle factors, and funded biases. “Healthy user bias” occurs because meat eaters might neglect other health behaviors, skewing data against meat, which gets falsely implicated as the culprit. This insight underscores the importance of distinguishing correlation from causation and demands stricter scientific rigor before making dietary policy recommendations.
-
🧠 Neural Efficiency and Brain Health on Carnivore: The diet’s high-fat content, rich in saturated fats and cholesterol, supports the synthesis of myelin—a key insulating sheath for neurons that enhances signal conduction speed and brain processing power. Coupled with ketone-based brain fuel that reduces oxidative stress, this biological synergy explains why mental clarity and cognitive function reportedly improve on the carnivore diet, especially over carbohydrate-based diets.
-
🚽 Gut Microbiome and Bile Adaptation during Diet Transition: Changing from a plant-based or mixed diet to carnivore disrupts established gut bacteria and challenges bile production (needed for fat digestion). The initial phase can cause diarrhea and digestive discomfort, emphasizing that dietary shifts require physiological adaptation time. Understanding this helps set realistic expectations and can improve adherence. Once adapted, digestion often surpasses previous performance.
-
💪 Glycogen Metabolism and Athletic Performance on Carnivore: Contrary to popular belief, carbohydrates are not mandatory for muscle glycogen storage and performance. The body uses gluconeogenesis to convert protein, fat, and lactate into glucose, replenishing glycogen in a metabolically flexible and sustainable manner after fat adaptation. This mechanism allows athletes to maintain or improve endurance and strength while on low-carb or carnivore diets, lasting beyond the initial adaptation period.
-
🏅 Real-World Athlete Success and Shifting Scientific Consensus: The video highlights numerous elite athletes and sports teams that have adopted carnivore or low-carb, high-fat diets with marked success, challenging the historically dominant high-carb paradigm. Leading exercise physiologists, like Professor Tim Noakes, who once supported carb-heavy diets, now endorse fat adaptation based on emerging evidence. This signals a possible paradigm shift in sports nutrition and a growing acceptance of carnivore applicability.
-
🍽️ Biological Adaptation to Meat Consumption Over Plants: Humans evolved as primarily carnivorous or omnivorous without the specialized digestive adaptations herbivores possess to process plant toxins. Ingesting large quantities of plants exposes the body to defense compounds which can cause inflammation and gut distress. This evolutionary and biochemical perspective supports the premise that a meat-based diet may be more aligned with human physiology, especially for those with autoimmune or inflammatory conditions.
This community gets lots of negative attention, and for a very vocal group of people it becomes a focus of animosity
Carnivore is a tool - the people using this tool want to be healthy
Opportunities for common causes:
-
- Whole foods - Single Ingredient foods - No Processed Foods
The Zero carb community as a whole focuses on single ingredient foods, without any processing.
-
- Sustainably produced
We all live on spaceship earth, and that system needs to be maintained for our future and our children's future. Any solution to health needs to be sustainable ecologically. That means using natures own biocycles and minimizing the need for industrial chemicals. i.e. crop rotation rather then mono-cropping, using ruminants to regenerate top soil
-
- Locally sourced foods
Moving a special product around the globe via airplanes or ocean vessel simply is a waste of energy, time, and logistics. This should be minimized in the food supply, and any solution to health and sustainability shouldn't use any imported food or ingredients. Food independence is critical for every community.
-
- Ethically raised animals
Carnivores are aware that they are part of a complex biocycle that involves many levels of life and nature interacting. Sadly this means animals will die for food production (this is unavoidable regardless of food choice). Animals that live as close to their natural biocycle as possible are the healthiest for the food supply. Good carnivores who can afford it will try to find sources of ethically raised and harvested meat - animals that are eating their natural diet in as close to their natural environment as possible.
Industrial farming is bad, and needs reform.
-
- Reduction of sugars in the diet
By virtue of being zero carb Carnivores avoid dietary sugars, but we do recognize how dangerous fructose and sucrose is in the general population (remember most of us are here to be healthy). Many Carnivores recognize the benefits of ketogenic and low carb metabolism.
-
- Progress not Perfection
For the most part the zero carb people I've met are very welcoming, non-judgmental, and don't prosecute people for not being perfect. I think we all have histories of struggling, and the understanding and empathy we can provide is the best thing we can do for each other (including our non-zero-carb friends).
-
- The need for self-experimentation
Seeing is believing, encouraging people to try their different theories and diets and seeing their own results is the only way to resolve "debates". Whatever the "philosophy" is it should be tested, and if its not working it needs debugging, or given up on.
-
- Avoiding industrial processed oils
Along the philosophy of avoiding processed foods, and foods from plants, we have double strikes against most of the industrial seed oils. While there is open debate and unclear literature on the harm of these oils, there is almost no downside to removing them from a diet, and it just becomes another uncontrolled variable that could be impacting people's results. This is just KISS
-
- Monitor your progress, only you are responsible for you
Everyone should record their biometrics periodically, especially if they are experimenting with a diet. I think Carnivore's by virtue of trying to be healthy are very likely to have a record of their biometrics going back years. This helps in the self-experimentation of the dietary adventure. In addition to the normal metrics
- height
- weight
- muscle mass
- blood pressure
- resting heart rate
- lipid panels
- hba1c
people should include a daily feeling journal, how much energy they had, any small aches or issues, just so they can look back and see their mood changing over time and make connections with diet.
While we may not agree on most things, or even many things, there should be some philosophical overlap so that our communities could be on nodding terms with each other.

Two popular carnivore influencers are being called out for supposedly becoming pre-diabetic. But is the data really what it seems? Dr. Eric Westman breaks down one of the most misunderstood metrics in all of nutrition—HbA1c—and unpacks why some people on low-carb or carnivore diets may show unexpected blood sugar markers. Could your "normal" lab results actually be misleading? What role does red blood cell lifespan play in these readings? And does this mean you're actually at risk—or is there something deeper going on? Don't miss this one.
summerizer
Summary
In this detailed video, Dr. Eric Westman addresses the controversial claims that following a carnivore diet causes pre-diabetes or diabetes. Highlighting recent viral social media critiques targeting popular carnivore influencers, Dr. Westman explains why these claims oversimplify and misinterpret key health markers, particularly blood glucose and hemoglobin A1C (HbA1C) levels, when taken out of context. He clarifies what type 2 diabetes truly means—prolonged elevated blood sugar accompanied by elevated insulin—and emphasizes that rising blood glucose numbers alone are insufficient to diagnose diabetes, especially in individuals who consume little to no carbohydrates. Dr. Westman dives into the biochemistry behind glucose metabolism on carnivore diets, such as gluconeogenesis, and explains how blood sugar and HbA1C readings can differ due to longer red blood cell lifespan or lower insulin levels. He critiques typical diabetes definitions as being carb-centric, which overlook metabolic nuances on low-carb or carnivore diets. He concludes that despite slightly elevated HbA1C readings in some carnivore diet followers, these values do not necessarily indicate diabetes or pre-diabetes because intracellular glycation and insulin levels remain low. He also stresses the need for comprehensive clinical evaluation rather than relying solely on standard blood sugar markers and encourages use of continuous glucose monitoring for personalized insight. Dr. Westman reassures viewers that type 2 diabetes often reverses on carnivore diets due to cessation of dietary carbohydrates and reduced insulin resistance. Overall, he urges critical thinking about nutritional misinformation and offers balanced perspectives rooted in current biochemical and clinical understanding.
Highlights
- 🥩 Carnivore diets do not inherently cause diabetes, despite online claims targeting influencers.
- 📊 Type 2 diabetes is defined by both high blood sugar and high insulin over prolonged periods, not just blood sugar alone.
- 🧬 Hemoglobin A1C alone can be misleading in carnivore diet followers, due to differences in red blood cell lifespan and metabolism.
- 🔄 Gluconeogenesis allows the body to maintain blood glucose levels without any dietary carbohydrate intake.
- 🩸 Fasting glucose levels for carnivore diet followers studied were mostly normal and below diabetic thresholds.
- 🛑 Elevated HbA1C in carnivore diet followers does not equal intracellular glycation damage caused by high carbohydrate intake.
- 🔍 Continuous glucose monitoring provides a clearer picture of blood sugar stability on low-carb or carnivore diets.
Key Insights
-
🥩 Carnivore Diet and Blood Sugar: Carnivore diets dramatically reduce carbohydrate intake, thereby lowering insulin production. This fundamentally changes how blood glucose and related markers like HbA1C should be interpreted. Traditional diagnostic criteria for diabetes—developed for carb eaters—do not always apply directly to carnivore dieters. This distinction is crucial in avoiding misdiagnosis based solely on elevated HbA1C or mildly elevated glucose readings.
-
🧬 Glycation Beyond Blood Sugar: Dr. Westman emphasizes that diabetes-related damage is caused not just by elevated blood sugar but by glycation inside cells—when sugar molecules stick to proteins and enzymes, impairing cell function. High insulin levels and carbohydrate metabolism exacerbate this intracellular glycation. In contrast, carnivore dieters with low insulin have much lower intracellular glycation risk even if their blood sugar or HbA1C readings are modestly elevated.
-
📉 Role of Insulin in Diabetes Definition: Elevated fasting glucose without elevated insulin, as seen in many carnivore dieters, does not fulfill Dr. Westman’s definition of type 2 diabetes. Insulin resistance, not just blood glucose, is central to disease pathophysiology. This nuance often gets lost in public discourse, leading to confusion and fear about blood sugar numbers alone.
-
🔄 Gluconeogenesis as a Glucose Source: The body naturally produces glucose from proteins, fats, and lactate through gluconeogenesis, creating precisely the amount needed even on zero-carb diets. This process explains how carnivore diet followers maintain necessary blood glucose without consuming dietary carbohydrates, underscoring that humans have no mandatory carbohydrate requirement for survival or metabolic health.
-
⏳ Hemoglobin A1C Limitations: HbA1C measures average blood glucose by gauging sugar “stickiness” on hemoglobin in red blood cells. However, if red blood cells live longer—as may happen on carnivore diets—HbA1C values can be artificially elevated despite otherwise healthy glucose metabolism. This challenges the general utility of HbA1C as a standalone diagnostic tool in these populations and highlights the need for additional measures like insulin levels or continuous glucose monitoring.
-
🌡️ Importance of Contextual Testing: Using standard diabetic thresholds (like fasting glucose over 100 mg/dL or HbA1C over 5.7%) without considering diet type, insulin levels, or clinical symptoms can lead to incorrect conclusions. For example, the two studied influencers had normal fasting glucose and insulin but one had an HbA1C slightly in the pre-diabetic range. Dr. Westman argues this alone should not lead to a pre-diabetes diagnosis without further context.
-
⚖️ Reversibility of Type 2 Diabetes on Carnivore Diet: Since type 2 diabetes fundamentally involves excess sugar in the blood and insulin resistance, reducing carbohydrate intake and consequently insulin demand—such as on a carnivore diet—allows many people to reverse their diabetic state. This notion is aligned with current low-carb and ketogenic literature showing improvement of metabolic markers in diabetes patients who restrict carbs.
-
🔬 Need for Ongoing Research: Dr. Westman acknowledges gaps in research, including data on red blood cell lifespan and insulin levels in carnivore followers, which would clarify these biochemical phenomena. He encourages transparency and public availability of laboratory data as more studies emerge on carnivore and low-carb populations.
-
🩺 Clinical Practicalities and Broader Health: Carnivore diet followers or anyone concerned about blood sugar should also monitor for diabetes complications such as neuropathy, rather than relying solely on glucose or HbA1C. Drugs, lifestyle factors like caffeine intake, and weight status continue to influence glucose metabolism and must be considered in clinical evaluations.
-
🔔 Critical Thinking on Nutritional Misinformation: The discussion highlights how viral social media claims can spread misinformation by ignoring biochemical complexity and dietary context. Dr. Westman advocates for an evidence-based, balanced approach to interpreting blood sugar and diabetes diagnostics, particularly for non-traditional diets like carnivore.
Conclusion
Dr. Eric Westman presents a nuanced and scientifically grounded argument that the carnivore diet does not cause type 2 diabetes as defined by both elevated blood sugar and insulin levels. While some followers may show mildly elevated HbA1C values, these markers do not necessarily signify pathological glycation or pre-diabetes without corroborating insulin or glucose evidence. The natural physiology of glucose production on zero-carb diets through gluconeogenesis supports metabolic stability despite low dietary carbohydrates. He stresses the limitations of conventional diabetes diagnostic cutoffs when applied indiscriminately and advocates for comprehensive, context-aware testing including continuous glucose monitoring. Ultimately, the carnivore diet may help many reverse type 2 diabetes by eliminating dietary sugars and lowering insulin demand, reaffirming the importance of personalized medical assessment over simplified online narratives.
From our previous discussions about the "sugar" diet, the key mechanism appears to be stimulation of FGF-21 which is triggered by protein sparing, and not sugar.
FGF-21 decouples mitochondria from cells and appears to increase basal metabolic rate by ~20%.
MD Shawn Baker does a protein sparing carnivore diet experiment (butter only) for 3 days - which should also stimulate FGF-21 increases.
Shawn Baker lost 4.5kg (10lbs) in 3 days doing this protein sparing diet.
THIS DIET IS NOT HEALTHY! You need protein.
We have discussed this before as a "fat" fast, but never in the context of FGF-21.
The mobile khanates are documented eating horse meat and dairy products along their vast nomadic tracts
Renowned for their ability to ride for days and immediately go into battle, this maps to what we understand about modern carnivore - eating only when necessary, skipping meals, very high levels of energy speak to a fat based metabolism
Obviously the Mongols were not exclusive carnivores - they were opportunistic
https://www.historyonthenet.com/what-did-the-mongols-eat
Farming was not possible for the most part, so the most prominent foods in the Mongol diet were meat and milk products such as cheese and yogurt. The Mongols were a nomadic, pastoral culture and they prized their animals: horses, sheep, camels, cattle and goats. As their herds ate up the grass, the Mongols would pack up their gers, tent-like dwellings they lived in, and move their herds to fresher pastures.
Thus, their food groups were predominantly milk products and a variety of meats. While the Mongols appreciated milk products, they didn’t drink fresh milk; instead they fermented milk from mares, making an alcoholic drink known as airag or kumiss. After women finished milking the cattle, goats and sheep, they would process the milk into milk curds, yogurts and airag. The usual beverages were salted tea and airag, fermented mare’s milk.
There are curious theories that the Mongolian decline coincided with a change in their diet https://afe.easia.columbia.edu/mongols/pastoral/masson_smith.pdf
What other famous carnivore civilizations are there?
Hunger and Frequency of Eating are big points of friction when dating someone who doesn't do keto or carnivore.
They are always hungry, I probably was this way before too, but now it's feels like such a huge time sink.
"Let's go to lunch - at the grill!" Great! I love the grill... Literally walking out of the grill "Let's find a snack"... one ice cream later... "Where are we going to have dinner"
I went on a few dates with a vegetarian and they were craving food constantly, even more then the above - every few minutes they had to eat some fruit or something sweet. It was kinda funny until it started to interrupt plans or outings.
I suppose this is just a reflection with how much my relationship with food has changed. Going into markets with a million snack shops seems so out of touch with reality now.
For 4 weeks, I ate 2,000 calories per day of saturated fat to see what it would do to my cholesterol levels. Spoiler alert: NOTHING. That’s 222 grams of saturated fat per day, and my total and LDL "bad" cholesterol levels remained the same. In this video, I break down why this happened and explain why this isn't just clickbait—it's a science-backed demonstration that will challenge conventional thinking about cholesterol, saturated fat, and cardiovascular health. We'll dive deep into how dietary fat influences cholesterol levels, the role of LDL and HDL, and why it's important to rethink what we know about fat consumption. Prepare to have your curiosity piqued and learn the real science behind these surprising results that appear to defy mainstream perspectives cholesterol.
Chapters
0:00 – Consuming 2000 Calories from Saturated Fat: What Happened?
1:02 – How My Baseline Ketogenic Diet Affected My Cholesterol
1:52 – Switching to a Saturated Fat-Rich Diet: The Details
3:08 – Surprising Result: My Cholesterol Didn’t Change
3:25 – Understanding Why My Cholesterol Remained the Same
8:36 – Why Did I Test Saturated Fat’s Impact on Cholesterol?
11:01 – How to Test Your Cholesterol Levels at Home
12:39 – The Importance of Metabolic Context in Cholesterol Levels
LDL cholesterol levels were graphed as ‘baseline normalized,’ i.e. as a ratio of LDL cholesterol at a given timepoint relative to baseline LDL cholesterol level for three reasons (i) Relative change, not absolute value, is most pertinent to the point(s) demonstrated by the experiment (ii) Given Lean Mass Hyper-Responder physiology, my baseline LDL-C on a ketogenic diet – irrespective of the fatty acid composition of that diet – is high. This is not the case when I’m on a diet including carbohydrates, as we’ve published. In prior content, audience has become fixated on absolute numbers relative to their own and attempted to use that as justification for personal choices. The point of the video is a physiologic demonstration, not a “dietary hall pass,” as stated explicitly in the video. (iii) We’ve published the absolute numbers in several papers in the peer-reviewed literature. A collection of papers can be found: cholesterolcode.com/papers
I think the zeitgeist would agree that Pizza isn't healthy, it's a junk food
What is a pizza?
- Bread
- Cheese
- Topping (pepperoni)
- Tomato Sauce
By weight bread is the largest component of pizza.
So which part of this makes it a junk food?
Carnivores would say the Cheese and Meat is fine, and the bread and sauce are making it a junk food
What would have to change on a pizza to make it "healthy"?
Ali Morgan has actually been involved with farming in many different ways for decades in many countries all around the world. Today, she busts a lot of myths about animal and crop farming and shows us the truths about what vegetarianism and veganism does to our beautiful planet. She is also one of the authors of the book: Why Vegans Have Smaller Brains.
00:00 Video Start
1:00 Intro
2:55 Who is Ali Morgan?
5:00 Farming knowledge in the west vs elsewhere
7:25 Nutrition quality in different countries
11:19 Reduction in farming industry
12:33 Automation / Mechanisation
14:25 Loss of rotation damages the environment
18:50 When we lost planet-friendly farming
19:49 Definition of organic farming, vegan farming myths
22:28 Definition of conventional farming
23:30 Soya’s carbon emissions
24:16 Beef doesn’t hurt the amazon
26:06 Crops vs livestock for the environment
36:34 Conventional vs organic vs regenerative farming
45:00 Definition of regenerative farming
48:14 Grain-free poultry?
50:56 Chickens now vs 100 years ago
53:45 How to choose eggs
54:10 What does free range mean?
56:07 Beef breeds & diet-heart hypothesis
59:58 Supermarkets keeping farmers poor, EU subsidies
1:05:10 Milk price factors, cow welfare, pollution from crop farming
1:04:40 Pollution of the environment from farming
1:11:15 Farmers losing money from milk
1:13:20 Mental health / suicides in farming
1:15:44 Further loss of farming industry
1:18:02 Is farming better in other countries?
1:19:50 How do we actually improve food quality?
1:23:49 Buying food in a way that helps farmers
1:26:24 Hormones in meat
1:30:30 Antibiotics in meat
1:37:17 Less meat means more deaths
1:38:15 Financial losses today for farmers
1:43:20 Politicians that understand farming difficulties
1:44:57 Cowspiracy bullshit - the biogenic carbon cycle
1:59:04 Deaths caused by livestock vs. crop farming
2:06:40 What regenerative farming looks like
2:12:58 Pesticides = biodiversity loss, babies with eye deformities
2:20:09 Can we grow crops without pesticides? Glyphosate
2:25:47 Vegans kill more animals than carnivores
2:34:03 How you can help farmers help us
summerizer
Summary
This extensive interview with Allison Morgan, an experienced agricultural expert, challenges common assumptions about farming, diet, and environmental impact, particularly the widely-held belief that vegan or plant-based diets are inherently better for the environment. Morgan draws on decades of firsthand experience in both developed and developing countries to explain the complex relationship between livestock, soil health, crop production, and ecosystem sustainability. She emphasizes that livestock farming—especially ruminants like cattle and sheep—is critical for maintaining soil fertility, carbon sequestration, and biodiversity, while continuous arable crop farming without livestock damages soil and ecosystems. The discussion highlights how modern farming practices, mechanization, and policies have drastically changed traditional mixed crop-livestock systems, often harming soil, environment, and farmer livelihoods. Furthermore, Morgan elucidates the economic challenges farmers face, the mental health crisis within farming communities, and criticisms of oversimplified views on methane emissions from livestock. The interview advocates for more nuanced understanding, better support for farmers, and systemic societal changes to ensure sustainable food systems that balance environmental health, animal welfare, and human economic well-being.
Highlights 🌱 Vegan-only farming without livestock accelerates soil degradation. 🚜 Modern intensive arable farming relies heavily on fossil fuels and agrochemicals, damaging soil health. 🐄 Grazing livestock play a vital role in restoring soil fertility and promoting biodiversity. 🤯 Farmers face high economic pressures, with many barely breaking even or losing money. 💔 Farming professions have some of the highest suicide rates due to stress and financial instability. 💨 Common claims about methane emissions from cattle are often scientifically inaccurate or misleading. 🛒 Direct farm-to-consumer sales and regenerative practices can support better farmer livelihoods and sustainability. Key Insights
🌍 Integrated Crop-Livestock Systems Are Environmentally Essential: Morgan explains that traditional mixed farming systems where livestock graze and manure is returned to fields are crucial for maintaining soil organic matter and fertility. Crops alone, especially in intensive arable rotations, deplete soil carbon and structure, leading to erosion and loss of productivity. This counters the idea that plant-based diets, relying solely on crop farming, are inherently greener. The grass-livestock nexus ensures ecosystem balance and reduces agrochemical dependence.
🔄 Soil Disturbance and Carbon Loss from Arable Farming: Annual crops require plowing and frequent soil disturbance, exposing soil organic matter to oxidation and releasing large amounts of CO₂—estimated as a third of modern carbon emissions from soil. In contrast, perennial grasslands with livestock prevent these losses by maintaining continuous ground cover, which is critical for long-term carbon sequestration and ecosystem resilience.
🐖 Livestock Feed and Sustainability Nuances: Intensive pig and poultry farming in developed countries relies heavily on grain and imported soy, which carries environmental costs and global supply chain concerns. However, ruminants like cattle and sheep mostly graze on permanent pastures, using less grain and soy. These grazing animals fit naturally into ecosystems and can foster biodiversity, unlike more intensive monogastric livestock systems.
💸 Economic Reality of Farming Unveiled: The interview highlights that many farmers, especially beef and sheep producers, operate at a loss without subsidies. Prices dictated by large retailers and supermarkets severely dent farmer incomes, while subsidies often subsidize processors and retailers more than farmers. This economic precarity contributes to mental health crises in farming communities.
💨 Myth Busting Methane Emissions: Contrary to popular media like Cowspiracy, methane from ruminants is part of a short biogenic carbon cycle. Methane breaks down within about a decade into CO₂, which is then reabsorbed by plants, creating a cyclical balance unlike fossil fuel emissions. The demonization of cattle methane grossly exaggerates livestock’s climate impact, overlooks soil carbon capture by grasslands, and neglects wild ruminants.
🐔 Challenges in Regenerative Monogastric Farming: Regenerative poultry and pig farming face inherent challenges because these animals naturally consume more diverse diets, including insects and roots, rather than solely grains. Systems like “mob grazing” where chickens follow cattle and feed on insects in dung offer more sustainable alternatives but cannot eliminate grain feed completely without compromising growth and productivity.
🌿 Agrochemicals, Pesticides, and Biodiversity Collapse: Intensive crop farming applies multiple herbicides, insecticides, and fungicides numerous times a season, resulting in severe declines of beneficial insects, earthworms, and soil biodiversity. This “cocktail of carnage” reduces soil health and critically threatens ecosystem services, including pollination, which grazing livestock systems largely avoid.
Conclusion
The conversation demystifies many myths around veganism, livestock farming, and environmental sustainability by providing a scientifically grounded, practical perspective from a global farming expert. It underlines the urgent need to support farmers financially and psychologically, rethink farming subsidies, and adopt integrated agroecological systems that utilize the synergy between crops and grazing livestock. Only through such nuanced approaches can we ensure resilient ecosystems, nutrient-dense food, animal welfare, and viable rural communities.

Dr Chaffee presents his paradigm-altering thesis that autoimmune diseases are the result of the body's attack on plant compounds. He presents evidence that removal, as in a carnivore diet, leads to remission of a wide range of autoimmune diseases.
summerizer
Summary
In this presentation at the Regenerate Conference, the speaker challenges the conventional understanding of autoimmune diseases—the idea that these conditions result from the body mistakenly attacking itself due to molecular mimicry or immune dysregulation. Traditionally, autoimmunity is thought to arise when the immune system is sensitized to self-antigens following an environmental trigger, such as a pathogen or toxin, often influenced by genetic predisposition. However, the speaker asserts that this model does not hold up well against clinical and immunological observations. Instead, they propose an alternative explanation focusing on environmental toxins, particularly plant lectins and glyphosate, as causative agents eliciting immune responses. The immune system is not attacking the body indiscriminately but responding appropriately to foreign toxins bound to bodily tissues, which results in collateral tissue damage.
Using celiac disease as a prime example, they explain how gluten, a plant lectin, binds to intestinal lining cells, causing damage that triggers an immune response not against the self but against the offending lectin. Removal of gluten allows intestinal repair despite persistent antibodies, suggesting this is not true autoimmunity. The talk highlights evidence from scientific literature dating back to the early 1990s that supports lectins as major contributors to inflammatory and “autoimmune” diseases, offering a coherent mechanism that accounts for the complex patterns observed in these conditions.
The speaker also discusses how certain populations, like individuals with Down syndrome, show higher prevalence of autoimmune diseases, indicating a genetic susceptibility but emphasizing that genetics alone does not explain the phenomenon. Immunological development processes should prevent self-reactive immune cells from surviving, and if they do not, the immune attack on self-antigens would be severe and relentless, contrary to the typical flare-remission pattern seen clinically.
A critical practical takeaway is that dietary management—specifically removing plant lectins and other toxins—can dramatically improve or even put autoimmune conditions into remission. The carnivore ketogenic diet focused on ruminant meat is highlighted due to its lower lectin and toxin content, and clinical case studies are cited where patients with conditions such as type 1 diabetes and multiple sclerosis experienced significant recovery and symptom remission with this approach. The talk encourages a shift from immune suppression—currently the mainstay of autoimmune disease management and fraught with side effects—to a strategy that removes environmental triggers allowing the immune system to normalize and tissue healing to occur.
Highlights
- 🌱 Autoimmunity may not be the body attacking itself but an immune response to environmental toxins like plant lectins.
- 🧬 Genetic predisposition plays a role but cannot fully explain autoimmune disease patterns.
- 🥩 Diet, especially eliminating plant lectins and consuming ruminant meat, can dramatically improve autoimmune conditions.
- 🌾 Celiac disease exemplifies how immune response targets toxins stuck to tissues, not the tissues themselves.
- 🔬 Traditional immunology models suggest true autoimmune cells would mount an unrelenting attack, unlike observed flare-remission patterns.
- 🧠 Lectins and toxins can cross biological barriers, including the placenta and blood-brain barrier, potentially causing diverse systemic effects.
- 📉 Case studies show remarkable reversals in diseases like type 1 diabetes and multiple sclerosis through dietary interventions.
Key Insights
-
🌿 Environmental toxins as primary drivers: The key insight is that many autoimmune-like conditions are possibly triggered by plant lectins and other environmental toxins bound to bodily tissues. This explains why removing offending foods relieves symptoms and why immune response patterns differ from classic infections. Unlike molecular mimicry models, this explanation accounts for the remission-flare cycles and tissue damage observed clinically without attributing the cause to the immune system malfunctioning or attacking self-antigens inherently.
-
🧠 Immunological central tolerance challenges the autoimmunity theory: During immune cell development in the thymus, autoreactive T cells are generally eliminated to prevent self-attack. For autoimmunity to be genuine, this central tolerance would have to fail catastrophically, which the speaker argues is highly unlikely. Real autoimmune destruction would present as continuous and severe, not remitting. Therefore, the presence of self-reactive antibodies or T cells does not prove the immune system’s intention to attack self, rather it may be responding to foreign substances adhering to self-structures.
-
🍽️ Dietary intervention as a powerful therapeutic tool: Removing lectins and other toxic exposures via strict dietary controls—exemplified by a carnivore ketogenic diet emphasizing ruminant meat—demonstrates striking clinical improvements. The fermentation process in ruminants reduces toxin levels in their meat, making it safer for consumption. Patients show reductions in symptoms, inflammation, and even tissue healing, as seen in autoimmune diseases like Crohn’s, Hashimoto’s, and type 1 diabetes. This represents a paradigm shift from symptom management by immunosuppression to root-cause elimination.
-
🧬 Genetics as susceptibility, not sole cause: People with genetic conditions such as Down syndrome have higher rates of autoimmune diseases, confirming some genetic component. However, shared familial environment and diet, as well as other factors, complicate genetics-only explanations. Thus, genetics may predispose but environmental exposures and dietary factors are likely necessary triggers for disease manifestation.
-
🧪 Lectins damage physiological barriers promoting systemic effects: Lectins’ ability to degrade intestinal microvilli causing leaky gut, and to breach the placental and blood-brain barriers, implicates them in systemic inflammatory and autoimmune-like diseases. This also explains observations such as Parkinson’s disease reduction following vagus nerve removal (a potential entry route for lectins to the brain), reinforcing environmental toxin involvement in disease etiology beyond classical autoimmunity.
-
📉 Immune suppression insufficient and problematic: Current immunosuppressive therapies for autoimmune diseases treat symptoms but suppress overall immunity, increasing risk for infections and cancers without addressing underlying causes. Identifying and eliminating environmental triggers could avoid these pitfalls, representing a safer, more effective long-term strategy.
-
🩺 Clinical case evidence supporting reinterpretation: The speaker cites real-world cases where dietary changes led to normalization of immune function and tissue healing, including insulin production restoration in type 1 diabetes patients and multiple sclerosis lesion reduction. These outcomes challenge the prevailing dogma of irreversible autoimmune tissue destruction and encourage further research into diet and toxin-related mechanisms.
Summary Conclusion
This talk advocates for a fundamental rethink of autoimmune diseases, moving away from the entrenched idea of the immune system attacking self. Instead, it promotes the theory that environmental triggers such as lectins and toxins cause tissue-bound antigens that the immune system responds to appropriately. This new understanding better fits observed clinical patterns and opens avenues for safer, causal treatments focusing on dietary and environmental modifications. While genetic predisposition matters, addressing external triggers is key to management and remission of these conditions, suggesting the potential to revolutionize autoimmune disease therapies.
Up until about 15 years ago lectins were thought of as laboratory tools, useful for histochemistry and blood transfusion work. The fact that many common foods are rich sources of lectin was not considered by most biomedical scientists. In the last decade, however, there has been a flowering of knowledge about the interactions of lectins with body organs and tissues, and it has become clear that many lectins are resistant to cooking and digestion and are distributed to distant parts of the body after ingestion. There is now abundant evidence that dietary lectins can cause disease in Man and animals. This review will adduce evidence that such hitherto mysterious diseases as inflammatory bowel disease, diabetes mellitus, rheumatoid arthritis, glomerulonephri-tis, psoriasis, multiple sclerosis, retinitis and cataracts in the eye, are all explicable in terms of a lectin aetiology, as are congenital malformations, infertility, IgE-mediated allergies and autoimmune states. Complete proof is still lacking in most cases, but the new hypothesis, if true, offers scope for rational therapy in these hitherto intractable diseases
Paper: https://doi.org/10.3109/13590849109084100
Full Paper on zlibrary

In any health intervention there can be the proponents who become zealous and unreasonable, holding people to too high a standard.
In the Keto/Carnivore space there is such excitement from finding a tool that works so well that advocates can become a bit annoying when they overshare with their friends and family.
Addictive personalities probably see quite a benefit in following a eating pattern strictly. These are the people who can not "moderate" temptation and must abstain to maintain their health goals. These are exactly the people who see the proper approach requiring strictness.
Not everyone is going to see the same benefits from the same intervention, and if someone is starting off relatively healthy their tolerances mean the tradeoff of strictness vs benefit isn't worth it.
For myself I've found that I can't hold people around me to the same standard I'm trying to keep myself at - I need the accountability for good outcomes, but that doesn't translate to other people.
At the end of the day all of these interventions are options, a menu of choices, that people can take or leave - I'm happy if I make that decision a informed one even if I wouldn't make the same choice.
Discover the life-changing potential of the carnivore lifestyle with tips from Bella, the Steak & Butter Gal. In this episode we dive into how your cravings usually mean something, they are not to be ignored. But also how a meat-based lifestyle, enriched with nutrient-dense butter, as well as other fat components such as Kefir and more can help you shed body fat, combat chronic illness, end obesity, stop food cravings, end anxiety and more.
Bella gets real on her history and shares her expert insights on why butter and animal fats crush food cravings and reduce anxiety, paving the way for mental clarity and high energy. Whether you’re seeking to reverse health challenges or create the vibrant life you’ve always wanted, this conversation offers actionable strategies and science-backed wisdom to thrive in a carnivore lifestyle.
summerizer
Summary
This video transcript features an in-depth conversation between two advocates of the carnivore lifestyle, focusing primarily on the experiences, benefits, challenges, and nuances of adhering to a carnivore diet, especially for women. Bella, known as the "Steak and Butter Gal," shares her six-year journey on the carnivore diet after prior veganism and discusses how it transformed her health, particularly in healing autoimmune skin issues, stabilizing hormones, and ending disordered eating patterns related to binge eating. Both speakers explore the gender-specific needs within carnivore, emphasizing that women typically require a higher fat intake compared to men due to physiological and hormonal differences.
The dialogue also extends to the psychological and social implications of such a restrictive diet, addressing the challenges of strict adherence, social life impact, and the fear and misconceptions around eating large amounts of animal fat (e.g., butter and beef fat). They discuss "filler" foods that complement a carnivore diet—such as fermented dairy products (kefir), bone broth, raw egg yolks, and fermented meats—to support gut health and digestion.
Further, the speakers touch on circadian health, the importance of natural light exposure, hormone regulation, and the broader lifestyle changes that accompany the carnivore diet, including toxin reduction and holistic wellness. They also debate the role of carbohydrates, concluding that carbs are not necessary for survival and that strict carnivore is best suited for individuals with significant health issues rather than everyone.
The video concludes with reflections on culture, family acceptance, and the need for flexibility and personalization in diet and lifestyle choices. Bella shares practical tips and resources for those interested in the carnivore lifestyle through her social media channels and community.
Highlights
- 🔥 Bella has been strictly carnivore for six years after a prior vegan lifestyle, never cheating.
- 🍖 Women typically thrive on higher fat intake in carnivore diets, unlike men.
- 🍫 Cravings for carb-heavy, sugary foods often mask the body’s real demand for fat, especially in women pre-menstruation.
- 🥩 Beef fat trimmings and raw consumption are prized for their healing and easy digestion benefits.
- 🕶️ Circadian health and light exposure significantly impact hormone regulation and overall wellness.
- 🍶 Fermented foods like raw kefir and bone broth act as essential "fillers" supporting gut health on carnivore.
- 🌍 Cultural and social aspects pose challenges to strict carnivore adherence but also opportunities for respectful personal choice.
Key Insights
-
🔥 Strict Carnivore Can Heal Chronic Conditions: Bella’s experience shows that adhering to a carnivore diet strictly and consistently can resolve autoimmune skin issues like psoriasis, eczema, and cystic acne, as well as stabilize overall hormonal health. This highlights the therapeutic potential of eliminating plant fiber and processed foods to reduce systemic inflammation.
-
🍳 Fat Intake is Crucial for Female Success on Carnivore: Women often need significantly higher fat levels to maintain hormonal balance and satiety. Hormonal fluctuations, especially related to the menstrual cycle, increase fat craving, which underscores the importance of personalized macronutrient tuning depending on gender and individual physiology.
-
🚫 Disordered Eating Patterns Improve with Carnivore: Both speakers struggled with disordered eating involving sugar binges. Carnivore’s high satiety and fat content helped them overcome compulsive eating behaviors. Allowing unrestricted intake (e.g., large amounts of butter) for a time helped restore hormonal function and mental control over food, illustrating that rigid restriction is not always ideal in recovery from eating disorders.
-
🌗 Circadian Rhythm and Light Exposure Influence Hormones: Beyond food, lifestyle factors like waking before sunrise and getting adequate natural light are pivotal for hormone regulation (melatonin, leptin) and metabolic health. Carnivore’s benefits are maximized when combined with circadian-friendly habits, reinforcing that diet alone isn’t the full picture of health.
-
💡 Fermented and "Filler" Foods Enhance Carnivore Sustainability: Adding fermented dairy (kefir), fermented meats (high meat), raw eggs, bone broth, and even dry-aged meat creates variety, aids digestion with acids and probiotics, and prevents diet fatigue. This challenges the notion that carnivore is only about steak and ground beef, highlighting important dietary adjuncts for gut health.
-
🤝 Cultural and Social Contexts Affect Diet Viability: Food is deeply tied to culture and social life, so strict carnivore diets require navigating family expectations, cultural traditions (especially carbohydrate-rich cuisines), and social interactions. The speakers emphasize leading by example rather than dogmatic persuasion, balancing personal health needs with relationship dynamics.
-
🌟 Carnivore as a Healing Tool, Not a Dogmatic Diet for Everyone: Carnivore’s strict version is mainly suitable for individuals with metabolic or autoimmune issues needing deep healing. For metabolically healthy people, a less strict animal-based or low-carb diet may be sufficient and more sustainable. This pragmatic approach helps prevent unnecessary suffering and supports individualized nutrition.
Additional In-Depth Themes
-
The Psychological Battle with Food: The conversation surfaces how the overconsumption of processed, addictive foods leads to a loss of self-control and disordered habits. The carnivore diet, by simplifying food choices and reducing variety, minimizes these triggers for many, promoting natural satiety and hormonal balance. The speakers’ honest sharing about their extremes—“all or nothing” tendencies—provides validation for listeners facing similar struggles.
-
Importance of Animal Fat Quality and Consumption Method: The preference for raw beef fat trimmings over rendered fat or hot melted fat is rooted in digestive comfort and nutrient absorption. Raw fat contains beneficial stearic acid and doesn’t induce digestive distress as rendered fat might. This practical nuance demonstrates that how fats are consumed matters greatly in diet efficacy.
-
Impact on Social and Friend Circles: Shifting dietary paradigms often lead to shifts in social dynamics. Bella notes distancing from friends who engage in nightlife and drinking late at night, aligning instead with a sleep- and light-driven lifestyle. This real-life cost of carnivore adherence highlights the broader implications extending beyond food choices.
-
Controversy over "Healthy" Plant Foods: Both speakers challenge the modern health hype around certain plant-based foods such as chia seeds, oatmeal, green juices, and flax seeds, labeling them as overrated or misleading “superfoods.” This reflects a growing skeptical movement toward marketed foods not necessarily yielding expected health benefits.
-
Realistic Approach to Transitioning Diets: Bella advises gradual transitions into carnivore or animal-based diets rather than abrupt changes, recognizing personal tolerance and mental/emotional readiness. She stresses that strict carnivore is not a one-size-fits-all, and emphasizing flexibility encourages sustainability and reduced relapse.
-
Role of Testing and Lab Work: Instead of relying heavily on hormone panels or lab tests to track progress, the speakers advocate observing body cues such as period regularity, skin condition, mood stability, and hunger as practical, zero-cost signals of progress—especially relevant for carnivore dieters aiming for hormonal normalization.
-
Connection Between Food and Environment: The discussion links the carnivore diet with a toxin-free lifestyle, promoting non-toxic household products, reducing chemical exposures, and embracing holistic wellness. This points to carnivore as an entry point into deeper health consciousness rather than simply a method of eating.
Conclusion
This video offers rich perspectives on the carnivore lifestyle, blending personal narrative and coaching insights to illuminate how the diet can be profoundly healing but also demanding socially and mentally. It advocates for personalized approaches, especially acknowledging gender differences and mental health factors surrounding food addiction. Beyond nutrition, it elevates circadian rhythm, fermented "fillers," and lifestyle adjustments as essential pillars. Most importantly, it calls for realistic, compassionate, and sustainable implementation tailored to individual needs, dispelling dogma and encouraging mindful evolution in eating habits and health.
The FEM pan is kinda silly, they really should have compared against a induction pan. It's hard to beat induction.
summerizer
Summary
The video explores how advanced heat transfer technologies, commonly used in computers, can be applied to cooking to speed up the process and improve efficiency. The presenter experiments with heat pipes—devices that utilize phase change to transfer heat rapidly—to cook steaks faster. By inserting heat pipes into a steak, the internal temperature rises more quickly, resulting in a 32% faster cooking time compared to a traditional steak. However, the results were somewhat limited because the heat pipes were less effective at transferring heat from the grill air, functioning more like metal fins instead. This insight led to further experimentation with fins, which maximize heat transfer surface area. The presenter introduces the FEM pan, a cooking pan equipped with fins at the bottom designed to capture more heat from a gas stove’s flame, which notoriously wastes over 70% of its heat. Tests comparing the FEM pan to a regular pan revealed the FEM pan boiled water over twice as fast (237% faster), providing rapid and even heating with minimal heat loss. The pan has gained popularity even among Michelin Star chefs due to its efficiency and even cooking. The video concludes by praising the practical application of computer cooling technologies in cooking, highlighting their potential to save energy and improve cooking speed.
Highlights
- 🔥 Heat pipes transfer heat rapidly by utilizing phase changes inside a sealed, vapor-filled tube.
- 🥩 Inserting heat pipes directly into steak speeds cooking time by 32%.
- ⏱️ Heat pipes performed less effectively in the grilling environment than expected, acting more like metal fins.
- ♨️ Gas stoves waste over 70% of heat due to flame and pan design inefficiencies.
- 🍳 FEM pan features fins on its base to capture and transfer more heat to the food.
- ⚡ FEM pan boils water 237% faster than a conventional pan, providing faster and more even cooking.
- 👨🍳 Innovative heat transfer technology is gaining traction with professional chefs for its performance and efficiency. Key Insights
- 🌡️ Phase Change Heat Transfer Significantly Enhances Heat Flow: Heat pipes exploit vapor condensation and evaporation cycles to move heat faster than conduction alone, demonstrating how leveraging physics beyond simple conduction can improve thermal management for cooking.
- 🥩 Direct Heat Transfer Through Heat Pipes Accelerates Cooking: By transferring heat into the steak’s center rather than relying on slow conduction from the surface inward, cooking times drop substantially, signifying that internal heating methods could innovate culinary techniques.
- 🔄 Limitations of Heat Pipe Efficiency in Open Air Environments: The heat pipes were not as effective when exposed to the grill air’s temperature, indicating environmental factors greatly affect heat pipe performance and that phase change mechanisms require controlled conditions for peak operation.
- 🔥 Fins Maximize Heat Transfer by Increasing Surface Area Contact: Adding fins to cookware optimizes heat capture from flames, showcasing how simple mechanical design can reduce heat wastage in common cooking appliances, thereby improving energy efficiency.
- ⏲️ Rapid and Even Heating in Thick Cookware is Possible with Finned Designs: The FEM pan’s fin design allows it to heat faster while maintaining the benefits of a thicker pan that minimizes hot spots and ensures consistent cooking—a blend rarely achieved with traditional pans.
- 💡 Adoption by Professional Chefs Signals Practical Value: The FEM pan’s popularity among Michelin Star chefs highlights how technological innovation transcends novelty to become a valuable tool in professional kitchens, underlining the importance of efficiency and performance in gastronomy.
- 🌍 Energy Efficiency in Cooking Has Broad Environmental and Economic Implications: Reducing heat waste (e.g., on gas stoves) with designs like fins or heat pipes not only saves time but also conserves energy, contributing to sustainability goals and lowering cooking costs.
The video effectively connects cutting-edge heat transfer technology to everyday cooking challenges, demonstrating that advancements first developed for computers can significantly improve culinary efficiency and energy use.
Camille and Scott talk about their journey on the carnivore diet.
summerizer
Summary
Scott and Camille’s journey to health began with Scott weighing over 550 pounds and suffering severe health issues, including congestive heart failure and COPD. Facing a grim prognosis and denied bariatric surgery due to his weight, Scott embarked on a health transformation that started unexpectedly with fasting, inspired by spiritual impressions and later supported by the teachings of Dr. Jason Fung. Integrating intermittent fasting and adopting a keto and later predominantly carnivore diet, Scott lost significant weight, regained mobility, and improved his overall health dramatically. Camille, also battling severe diabetes and other autoimmune conditions, joined this lifestyle change; her diabetes reversed to the point of no longer needing medication.
Their story highlights the power of dietary transformation combined with consistent physical activity—daily six-mile walks—and mindset shifts. Both faced skepticism and resistance from medical professionals but found a supportive new physician and community validation through social media and shared experiences. Their carnivore approach is flexible, adapted to their individual preferences and circumstances, rejecting the idea of rigid dogma. Together, they have lost nearly 450 pounds, reversed multiple chronic conditions including diabetes, COPD, fibromyalgia, and even improved mental health, allowing Scott to wean off decades-long antidepressant use.
They stress individualized, sustainable, and gradual lifestyle changes and warn of the long-term harm of carbohydrates for many people. Their consistency in diet and daily exercise brought not only physical health improvements but also significant psychological and emotional benefits. They advocate for taking personal ownership of health, learning what works best individually, and moving beyond conventional medical paradigms that often fail to support lifestyle-based healing.
Highlights
- 🥩 Scott lost over 300 lbs, transforming his health from life-threatening to thriving.
- 🩺 Camille reversed severe diabetes and heart issues to medication-free health.
- 🕒 Fasting, especially 36-hour fasts, played a foundational role in weight loss and metabolic health.
- 🚶 Daily six-mile walks have been key to sustained physical and mental wellbeing.
- 💊 Both overcame significant chronic illnesses, including COPD, heart failure, fibromyalgia, and depression.
- 🥚 The carnivore diet is flexible and individualized, not rigid or dogmatic.
- 🔬 Personal lab testing and self-management empowered healthier choices despite medical skepticism. Key Insights
🥩 Carnivore and Fasting Synergy: The combination of extended fasting and a low-carb, carnivore-based diet can revolutionize metabolic health, addressing insulin resistance, diabetes, and severe obesity, often undetected or underserved by standard medical practices. Scott’s initial unplanned fasting journey evolved into a cornerstone for sustainable fat loss and disease reversal.
🩺 Diabetes Reversal Without Medication: Camille’s experience exemplifies how targeted dietary changes can dramatically reduce A1C from mid-90s to near-normal levels, eliminating the need for insulin and oral drugs. It challenges the medical narrative that diabetes is inevitably progressive and medication-dependent.
🚶 Consistency Over Intensity: Their daily consistent exercise routine—walking 6 miles regardless of weather—illustrates that sustainable, moderate physical activity is more beneficial long term than sporadic intense workouts. It also improved mental health and endurance, enabling participation in events like the 12K Bloomsday race.
💪 Overcoming Medical Resistance: Persistent health improvements often encounter skepticism or resistance from healthcare providers, particularly regarding non-conventional diets and reduced medication reliance. Self-advocacy, seeking supportive doctors, and independent monitoring are critical for patients pioneering lifestyle-based healing.
💊 Mental Health Benefits of Metabolic Healing: Scott’s gradual withdrawal from long-term SSRI antidepressants, facilitated by metabolic improvements, underscores the emerging link between metabolic health and brain function. This raises awareness of dietary approaches as complementary tools for managing depression and anxiety.
🍳 Personalized Dietary Adaptation: The couple’s pragmatic approach—flexible carnivore with occasional plant matter and fish—affirms that strict dogma can be a barrier. Individual palates, preferences, and tolerance guide sustainable adherence, highlighting the importance of “what you can manage” over a one-size-fits-all plan.
🔬 Empowerment Through Self-Monitoring: Utilizing continuous glucose monitors (CGMs) and ordering comprehensive lab tests provided invaluable feedback, helping them fine-tune diet and lifestyle, and challenging medical assumptions. Patients equipped with data can better manage chronic conditions and advocate intelligently for their care.
This comprehensive testimony showcases how deep lifestyle commitment combining carnivore nutrition, intermittent fasting, and daily movement can yield profound, wide-ranging health transformations. It invites rethinking the role of traditional medicine and promotes empowering patients on their path to optimal health.
Scott talks about his journey on the carnivore diet.
summerizer
Summary
Scott Wilson shares his remarkable journey of overcoming severe kidney disease (FSGS nephrotic syndrome) and other health challenges through dietary changes, specifically adopting a ketogenic and then a strict carnivore diet. Initially diagnosed with a grave condition showing just 20% kidney function and battling weight gain, swelling, and immune system issues, Scott faced bleak medical advice that emphasized steroids and immunosuppressants with serious side effects. However, after watching inspirational content about carnivore diets and encouraged by a longtime friend, Scott shifted his approach from medication reliance to a focus on nutrition, eliminating processed foods, carbs, and eventually adopting a zero-carb carnivore regimen.
Within months of changing his diet, Scott witnessed a dramatic improvement in kidney function (increasing GFR from 20% to 45%), significant weight loss (41+ pounds), reduced protein loss in urine, improved cholesterol and triglyceride levels, better mental clarity, energy, and even partial relief from shoulder inflammation. His experience also illuminated the dangers of prolonged NSAID use (which contributed to his kidney damage), the limitations of conventional medicine’s approach, and the potential for dietary intervention to replace certain medications. Scott’s story stands as a testimony to the power of food as medicine, and he is passionate about sharing his experience with others to inspire hope and practical change for those struggling with kidney issues or chronic illness.
Highlights
- 🥩 Scott’s kidney function improved from 20% to 45% within months after adopting a keto-to-carnivore diet.
- 💧 He lost over 40 pounds, mostly fluid related to kidney swelling, improving mobility and comfort.
- 🔬 Traditional medicine offered steroids and immunosuppressants with serious side effects; Scott chose diet over these drugs.
- 🍳 His daily eating includes eggs, uncured bacon and sausage, and ribeye steak, emphasizing simplicity and quality.
- 🧠 Mental clarity and energy levels significantly improved, contrasting previous brain fog.
- ⚠️ Long-term NSAID use contributed heavily to his kidney damage—a cautionary tale for others.
- 🤝 Scott advocates for spreading awareness of dietary healing to kidney patients worldwide. Key Insights
🥩 Dietary intervention can profoundly impact chronic kidney disease: Scott’s move from a standard diet to keto, then carnivore, directly correlated with improved kidney function (GFR rising from 20% to 45%), demonstrating that nutritional changes can support kidney health beyond pharmacological approaches — something often overlooked in conventional nephrology.
💧 Rapid and substantial fluid loss is a key benefit: Scott shed 77 pounds of excess fluid, alleviating anosarca edema—a life-threatening condition. This illustrates how diet can affect kidney-related fluid balance and reduce burdensome swelling without hospital interventions.
⚠️ Long-term NSAID use can irreversibly harm kidneys: His kidney condition was linked to prolonged use of anti-inflammatory drugs, a warning about the hidden risks of common over-the-counter medications and the need to explore alternative pain management strategies.
🧬 Immune suppression isn’t always necessary if underlying causes are addressed: Scott’s WBC count normalized without immunosuppressant drugs, suggesting that diet-induced healing might reduce autoimmune kidney attacks without toxic drugs, challenging current treatment paradigms.
🥚 Simplicity in diet promotes adherence: Eating straightforward, unprocessed animal products with low-carb intake helped Scott bypass the keto flu gradually, underscoring the importance of easy-to-follow dietary steps for long-term compliance, especially in chronic illness.
🧠 Improved cognitive function and energy highlight holistic benefits: Beyond kidney metrics, Scott’s improved mental clarity and physical stamina reveal how diet influences systemic health, mood, and quality of life.
🌍 Barriers exist in medical communities to adopting and promoting dietary approaches: Scott’s nephrologist was skeptical initially but later supportive, acknowledging political and systemic challenges that keep nutritional treatments from wider acceptance, highlighting a need for further education and advocacy.
Scott’s story is a compelling case demonstrating that serious health crises like kidney failure can sometimes be turned around by focusing on food quality and macronutrients rather than solely relying on medications. He urges caution with NSAIDs and highlights how incremental dietary changes eased his transition. Despite initial medical discouragement, his improved labs and quality of life affirm that patients can reclaim control through nutrition, offering hope to others facing chronic diseases.
I see you're quite passionate about the carnivore diet but I'd suggest some adjustments to the diet guide that address key health concerns:
Could you add a section about kidney stone prevention? The carnivore diet significantly increases kidney stone risk due to high animal protein intake, acidic urine, and zero plant-based alkalizing compounds. Studies show 5.9% incidence rate vs 0.25-0.3% in general population: Incidence and Characteristics of Kidney Stones in Patients on Ketogenic Diet: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis
Could you include guidance on fiber supplementation? Since carnivore diets provide zero dietary fiber, users miss the 23% reduction in all-cause mortality and 26% reduction in cardiovascular mortality that fiber provides. Consider discussing supplementation strategies: Dietary fiber intake and all-cause and cause-specific mortality: An updated systematic review and meta-analysis
Could you include guidance on digestive health management? Since fiber feeds beneficial gut bacteria and prevents constipation, carnivore dieters may need specific strategies to maintain gut health without any plant foods: Dietary fiber intake and total mortality: a meta-analysis of prospective cohort studies
Could you add a section on micronutrient monitoring? A nutrient analysrt in multiple essential nutrients including thiamin, magnesium, calcium, vitamin C, folate, and potassium (you can even see it in the nutrient table in the guide). Regular blood work and targeted supplementation may be necessary: Assessing the Nutrient Composition of a Carnivore Diet: A Case Study Model
Could you include cardiovascular monitoring recommendations? Given the significant dietary shift, more frequent lipid panels and blood pressure monitoring could help track how individuals respond to higher saturated fat intake, since responses vary considerably between people. Meta-analyses show both processed and unprocessed red meat consumption are associated with increased CVD, stroke, and heart failure risk: Red meat consumption, cardiovascular diseases, and diabetes: a systematic review and meta-analysis and Health effects associated with consumption of unprocessed red meat: a Burden of Proof study
Could you add a section on cancer risk awareness? A comprehensive analysis of 148 studies found red meat increases breast cancer risk by 9%, endometrial cancer by 25%, and colorectal cancer by 10%. Users should be aware of these risks for informed decision-making: Consumption of red meat and processed meat and cancer incidence: a systematic review and meta-analysis
As with most highly restrictive diets there's lots of bloodwork and supplementation required to make sure you don't damage your body long term and while it may be much harder than having a more varied diet it may be useful if you don't have any other choice.
@zeezee@slrpnk.net Originally expressed these concerns in a comment but due to some federation issues outside of our control it didn't federate properly, so I'm reposting it here so it can be seen by everyone.