The Chinese casino hub once again tops the world in gaming revenue in 2024 as visitors return after the Covid-19 pandemic, but residents like Leong point to a huge disparity in which parts of the economy are bouncing back. As Macau celebrates 25 years under Beijing rule this week, many feel more urgently than ever that the city needs to diversify its economy -- something Beijing has demanded for years to underwhelming results.
Born and raised in the former Portuguese colony, Leong belongs to a population that became China's richest from two decades of wealth spilling out of casinos.But shifting consumer habits among locals and tourists have led her to believe those days are gone for good. Leong's regulars are tightening purse strings while Chinese tourists are now more likely to eat from lunchboxes outside her shop instead of coming in to spend. Compared to the store's heyday, earnings this year have fallen 90 percent. "Macau may look prosperous, but many restaurants and retailers are suffering," she said. "Nobody knows what to do."
Macau's gaming boom began in 2002 when authorities ended the monopoly of late tycoon Stanley Ho and brought in multinational casino operators known as concessionaires. The city -- the only place in China where casino gambling is allowed -- took less than five years to surpass Las Vegas in gross gaming revenue and consistently stayed ahead aside from a Covid-era dip. In Vegas, gaming-related taxes have accounted for around 35 percent of government revenue in recent years. But for Macau, the latest figure stood at 81 percent.
"Since at least a decade ago, the central government had hoped that Macau's economy would diversify, but it didn't budge," said Ieong Meng-u, a politics academic at the University of Macau. "With gaming, the money comes too easily. (Macau) basically didn't have to do much for a robust income."
Xi's anti-corruption drive brought an end to Macau's lucrative junket industry, which enticed wealthy gamblers from China's mainland with perks like VIP rooms and credit lines. The city's six casino operators managed to renew their licences in 2022 only after they pledged to invest in other sectors, with $14.9 billion earmarked for projects such as theme parks and conference venues. Xi, who will visit Macau this week, will probably "want to see for himself what non-gaming, hard investment has eventuated", said Ben Lee, managing partner of consultancy IGamiX.
City officials have even designated six historic areas for revitalisation -- one for each concessionaire -- though Lee said the operators would prefer "easy wins", as non-gaming ventures typically bring paltry returns. "The casinos are rational economic entities. They will only do as little as they think they can get away with."
Now two years into their 10-year concessions, operators have developed a steady rhythm of concerts, conferences and sporting events, including a deal with the NBA to host pre-season games. Aside from boosting tourism, city officials -- including Macau's next leader Sam Hou-fai -- have picked a range of sectors to become new economic drivers. But the government's messaging is "sometimes muddled", said Vitaly Umansky, a gaming expert at Seaport Research Partners. "(The government) would like other industries to start developing" but it would be "very, very difficult" for Macau to compete in proposed fields like financial services, technology and Chinese medicine, he said.
Growing those sectors would likely require foreign talent, and there is a "consensus in the business community (that)... Macau needs to move faster and make bolder moves" on that front, said Jose Carlos Matias, director of Macau Business magazine.
Yes, just like the legal term for a predatory debt spiral disguised as a short term loan used to be "payday loan" (now called something else to avoid regulation imposed on the previous euphemism).
The more innocent-sounding but deceptive term that a predatory industry prefers doesn't become correct just because they successfully bribe politicians to make it become/remain the official one.