this post was submitted on 19 Feb 2024
12 points (92.9% liked)
Actual Discussion
272 readers
1 users here now
Are you tired of going into controversial threads and having people not discuss things, circlejerking, or using emotional responses in place of logic? Us too.
Welcome to Actual Discussion!
DO:
- Be civil. This doesn't mean you shouldn't challenge people, just don't be a dick.
- Upvote interesting or well-articulated points, even if you may not agree.
- Be prepared to back up any claims you make with an unbiased source.
- Be willing to be wrong and append your initial post to show a changed view.
- Admit when you are incorrect or spoke poorly. Upvote when you see others correct themselves or change their mind.
- Feel free to be a "Devil's Advocate". You do not have to believe either side of an issue in order to generate solid points.
- Discuss hot-button issues.
- Add humour, and be creative! Dry writing isn't super fun to read or discuss.
DO NOT:
- Call people names or label people. We fight ideas, not people here.
- Ask for sources, and then not respond to the person providing them.
- Mindlessly downvote people you disagree with. We only downvote people that do not add to the discussion.
- Be a bot, spam, or engage in self-promotion.
- Duplicate posts from within the last month unless new information is surfaced on the topic.
- Strawman.
- Expect that personal experience or morals are a substitute for proof.
- Exaggerate. Not everything is a genocide, and not everyone slightly to the right of you is a Nazi.
- Copy an entire article in your post body. It's just messy. Link to it and maybe summarize if needed.
For more casual conversation instead of competitive ranked conversation, try: !casualconversation@lemm.ee
founded 9 months ago
MODERATORS
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
For a bit of context: I generally consider gender to be the social/cultural angle on males/females and sex to be the chromosome/physical body angle. (I can get into atypical chromosomes later if anyone wants).
General thoughts
I more or less am indifferent about the idea of gender. I think on one hand, some people are very firm about "This is how men should act, and this is how women should act," in a traditional sense, while others, in a more modern sense can be equally inflexible in a different way. Ex: "If you exhibit these traditionally feminine or masculine behaviours you should change your gender identity to match them."
I don't particularly empathize with either outlook as I feel that any person should do what 1) Makes sense in any individual situation, and 2) Should do what makes sense within their personal tendencies and abilities. For me personally, most talk about gender identity feels unrelatable in its entirety.
That said, by default I recognize "male/female" as sex, and will default to that when talking to someone. If they have an ambiguous look about them or specifically request it, I'll address them differently. Even if it doesn't particularly mean anything to me, or can be counter-intuitive to my world-view, I will try to be considerate because I realize it means something to them.
Regarding why we have gender stereotypes, and what genuine differences there are between the male and female sex: I think that because of typical physical differences in the sexes (pregnancy, breastfeeding, muscle mass, height, eyesight and so on) we've had a pragmatic division of responsibilities and specialization that tended to make sense along those lines in most cultures. (And it's likely that this has been a two-way evolutionary balance).
While I think some of the most clear-cut " on average" differences in men and women are in their bodies, the least clear are mental. In a very general sense it's difficult to evaluate even hard physical things like brain shape/patterns and to be able to claim that culture/social upbringing within a society hasn't affected those things in some ways. While I'm amenable to there being some differences in the mind, it's difficult to say what adult brains without the influence of culture (and thus concepts of gender) would look like.
Essentially, my view is that there are some inherent average differences between the sexes that lead to some different, on average behaviours, but that those differences aren't so strong that we should be heavy-handed about telling people, particularly in a modern non-tribal society, how they should act, or how they should identify. We should let individuals do as they please without having to concern themselves about the idea of being a man or a woman in any way.
I understand a lot of people probably don't emphatize with my views, but that's more or less what I think.