this post was submitted on 04 Mar 2024
31 points (100.0% liked)
Reddthat Community and Support
713 readers
1 users here now
Reddthat Community & Support
This community is for us to chat about anything and everything, including support topics!
There is no defining specific rules for this community and it can be anything from "I do not like the weather" to "I've won the jackpot and want to give all the money away to charity!" 😄
Before posting, have you read the rules?
Introductory Required Reading
For anything else, try a search and see what turns up, if not post away!
Alternative Matrix Chatroom:
Alternative Support Forums:
founded 1 year ago
MODERATORS
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
Exactly.
No it's not. Downvotes only matter if the person cares—not even if they're arguing in good faith or not. If I literally don't care what my vote count is, having a negative number won't change that.
All it proves is a mob can vote together. It doesn't prove why the comment is bad, because it could be a very reasonable comment that people simply don't like. I'm sure you've seen plenty of times where someone throws cold water on a topic, but the substantive pushback comes from other users debating the claims, not attaching a negative number to it.
Likewise, bad-faith actors should be moderated by actual moderators, not general users—and unlike Reddit, you not only have community mods, but you have instance mods who aren't (usually) beholden to corporate interests.
While I can appreciate that people like to be able to sort by vote count, I believe all that does is create artificial bias. If a comment is truly that bad, a moderator should probably be looking at it, anyway.
Ultimately, this is Lemmy. We have the opportunity to create something better than Reddit that fosters better discourse.
Agreed
Downvotes keep assholes hidden whether or not they "care." They protect you from exposure to the worst loudmouths, before the moderators are even awake.
And I've seen moderators erase stuff they "simply don't like." People are people. Downvotes are at least a democratic form of exclusion, and have softer consequences than outright censorship. You are free to scroll down and expand where someone's taking a kicking for a presumably-awful comment. But Lemmy severs whole subthreads when one comment gets removed.
Why do even you care if a comment's been downvoted for mere disagreement, if you don't think getting buried matters?
That selection is the central function of this sort of website. The front page is not a chronological feed of what everyone posts, or a true-random potpourri of the last twenty-four hours.
The whole friggin' idea is relying on crowds to sort things.
Otherwise - why have votes at all? Why not get on your admin's case for allowing upvotes, the way you'd apparently chide them for considering downvotes? Feedback is necessary. The use of feedback is why reddit mattered, and the absence of negative feedback is why competing sites sucked. Twitter is a harassment engine where the only response besides engaging with trolls or silently taking abuse is to report someone and cross your fingers. Facebook is a disinformation hugbox, by design, openly encouraging group owners to be heavy-handed petit dictators. TikTok is a firehose of sludge that does not give a dang whether you like it.
Seeing these posts celebrating the lack of a crucial feature is like finding out some instances are flat forums. Like you'd have to scroll through seven pages of signatures and block-quotes to get this reply. Reddit's only good decisions were downvotes, nested comments, and compartmentalization, in that order, and it is bizarre how many people want their choices limited to even less than that.
Friend, what is your purpose here? I made a post on my instance on the instance-specific community for these sorts of posts, with the express purpose of encouraging their decision.
Even if I conceded your points, which I don't, what do you hope you'll achieve in trying to convince me I'm wrong in my own house? If you don't like it, don't join instances like these. That's what makes the Fediverse great.
Then what was the point in making this post at all? You wanna talk about how great this idea is. I vehemently disagree. Disagreement is the only negative feedback your instance allows, which you are specifically celebrating. How could this interaction possibly be surprising to you?
Especially when half the argument is - let's say you're completely right. Why not go one step further? Upvotes still create a gradient, driven solely by users, untouchable by mere moderators. You could petition your instance to be better. Admins of major instances routinely seek that kind of feedback.
It is trivially possible to make moderators the sole power in any community.
Why isn't that what you want?
Because I wanted to encourage my admins for a choice I like. Sorry you don't like what my admins do, but that's why I'm here and you're on sh.itjust.works
Sometimes, people just like to be nice. A weird concept, I know, but this isn't Reddit.
I remember private communities being on the roadmap for Lemmy (e.g. limited to the local users)
I guess once we'll have them we'll be able to discuss topics like this among ourselves.
I mean, even if that never comes to pass, this community is called "Reddthat Community and Support."
The core topic is Reddthat's community. If people don't like how we do things, it seems strange to whinge about it here.
But on the bright side, I was able to add a handful of especially tedious people to my blocklist. So not only can I not see their downvotes, but now I can't see them period!
You've been lovely, and I hope you have an amazing week!
Thanks, have a good one too!
In the absence of downvotes, your condescension allows no recourse besides silently weathering the backhanded abuse, or getting shitty comments like this one.
Do not act surprised when you get shitty comments like this one.
“This isn’t Reddit” Look guys. Gotta make sure we know this place that isn’t Reddit isn’t Reddit. lol. And yeah I’d just downvote you. But you prefer this.
It also keeps people that don't subscribe to the circle jerk opinion hidden, creating an even bigger circle jerk like most of lemme already is.
The voting system has been shown to be too easy to brigade/manipulate and to just create endless circle jerks.
Agree