this post was submitted on 05 May 2024
23 points (100.0% liked)

Technology

967 readers
45 users here now

A tech news sub for communists

founded 2 years ago
MODERATORS
 

So I never got the chance to play with LLMs because of the phone number requirement. But recently duckduckgo added a chat feature which lets you talk to these models so I have been trying them out.

I know these two models aren't state of the art but its tragic how they have devoured terabytes of corpus only to never have understood the meanings of the words they use.

I tried to talking to them about simple political issues. Once I asked why Elon Musk complains about woke while being a multibillionaire. I also asked why it is commonly said that Israel-Palestine conflict is complicated. Both times it gives very NYT-esque status quo-friendly answers which I think is very dangerous if the user is a naive person looking to delve into these topics. But as I question the premise and the assumptions of the answers, it immediately starts walking back and starts singing a completely different tune. Often I don't even have to explain the problems I have and just asking it to explain its assumptions is enough.

I got it from saying "Musk is critical of censorship and the lack of free speech" to "Musk is a billionaire in a highly unequal society and his societal criticisms are to be taken with a ton of salt". For the Palestine one, it started off with a list of reasons behind the complexity. Then I got it to strike them off one by one eventually concluding that the conflict is one of extreme power imbalance and that Palestinians are a clear victim of settler colonialism according to international consensus. My arguments weren't even that strong and it just caved in almost immediately.

I'm still trying to find use cases LLMs. Specifically I would be really happy if I could find a use for a small model like TinyLlama. I find that text summarization is promising but I wouldn't use it for a text I haven't read before because LLM is a liar sometimes.

you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
[–] Shrike502@lemmygrad.ml 12 points 6 months ago

LLMs are just a tool, and just like all other tools under capitalism, they are owned by the bourgeoisie and thus do what the bourgeoisie demands. Think of them as you would of factories that produce ammunition and weapons instead of tractors and useful everyday items.