Matchmaking changes should be good, that's the first thing that stood out to me. Lots of good changes like the behaviour system and low priority queue. Lots of map changes too, will have to go in game to get a feel for those. The change from Orange lane to Green seems random to me, anyone have an idea of why this change was made?
this post was submitted on 13 Sep 2024
29 points (100.0% liked)
Deadlock
450 readers
56 users here now
A Lemmy community for the upcoming Valve Corporation game Deadlock
founded 2 months ago
MODERATORS
I know I had trouble quickly spotting where the creep line was at on orange lane, spotting where it changed from orange to red so maybe related or maybe I'm an odd one out?
I think it was for color-blind friendliness
Isn't orange good and green bad in terms of colour blind friendliness? I might have been misinformed.
As a color impaired loser, any attempt to assign colors as a static for everybody will fail the goal. The only way to really address it is to let us choose the colors in a config.
This is because there are many variations of color blindness and no two are impacted the same.
Or, and I can't stress this one enough as a good solution. Stop using colors as the identifier.
They do have streetnames, which the characters sometimes use when pinging.
I'm for it, what alternative are we using? Bot/mid/top works for 3 lane games because names of lanes on maps is more convoluted than a symbol, like color or shape. For example, in any game ever that uses names (even like Paladins where it has the name at the top visible of where in the map you are) I am completely useless if you tell me Broken Ridge and expect me to know which of the 5 areas of the map that could be.
I feel that is why color is so relied on, since it's a clear (note: contrasting) visual indicator. I like the idea of using symbols though, but there would have to be a lot of good design choices to have each shape be visually distinct with a simple name without using color identifiers. I'm almost certain that's the main reason colors are so prevalent, because they are fairly distinct and generally are monosyllabic making them easy call outs. But you're definitely right that they aren't ubiquitous, and so it would be cool to have good alternatives.
It sucks that color is such an unbeatably simple and convenient signifier for those capable of seeing it. The best alternatives I could come up with would be symbol based: triangle, square, circle for example. Or better yet for the theme, suits of cards: clover, spades, hearts, diamonds.
Still, they would take up more real estate on the minimap than colored lane lines, which is a real concern in a MOBA.
I was thinking shapes as well, but then it comes down to design again - how a simple inflection of color nearby could suddenly attribute spade to blue then we're back to square one.
It's an interesting thing to develop for. I think you're onto something with theme, each of the 5 lanes for Deadlock could couple to a lore-related word. Something like, Siege, Blitz, Moor, Caldera, Fortitress (fortified fortress?). Each of the words have a distinct symbol present on the lane.
For future developers that seems like something relatively feasible. It's a little more design work than just tossing a color on a line and calling it a day, but it seems like it could work well. It seems like it solves the core issue of color-only referencing and it can enhance the game by giving it some additional lore. It also should function effectively the same as color would, since the association is the location of the lane (1 through 5) to the symbol (previously color).
The one caveat left is the line itself, however I think for the case of Deadlock it's actually pretty simple, it just risks being very visually busy. Each Diamond at the minimap could just have the symbol instead.
I think each lane will have its own visual identity once the game is closer to release so you'll always know where you are without having to check the minimap, but that still doesn't necessarily solve the need for color coding.
Each lane actually already has a name starting with the same letter as it's colour: York (Yellow), Greenwich (Green), Broadway (Blue) and Park (Purple). It's just that nobody uses them. Maybe with stronger visual theming people will, and the issue will be alleviated.
I do think each lane being grey wouldn't be great, so maybe make it black/dark when empty and white when player is nearby?
I don't think the solution to help color inhibited people should be to remove all colours, it should be to see if there are ways to help them navigate too.
That's awesome, I didn't know that bit! I was coming from a colorless perspective for this engagement simply for the idea that if color is present, that it might become the predominant name.
But as you mentioned, having them share the same letter actually resolves that issue completely
What would you think about symbols at the tip of the lane (how far it's been pushed), like a tree for "Orchard" (~~orange~~ green) and other symbols for whatever the heck they're called.
My brain is fairly direct in a lot of these things. I'd suggest just numbering them so all that the numbers are presented to the team viewing them from their perspective.
Since the map rotates to the teams perspective, just start on the left with 1 to 4.
The new mini-map is... interesting. I'm not too big of a fan of it, but I noticed it did give the game a slightly less serious vibe with the cartoon icons and such.
I'm also not a fan of the icons but the minimap itself is an improvement IMO. Much better contrast and it's easier to see what's happening.
can't wait to try it!