How convenient that this happens just a few days after Firefox implements the features that have been blocking me from switching for the last few years.

Still, I'm curious about other browsers. We know Chrome is killing V2, but what about other Chromium-based browsers? I saw below a comment espousing Brave, but I'd rather use Chrome than Brave because of the gross crypto bs. What about Vivaldi, Opera, and Chredge? Will they keep supporting Manifest V2?

[–] Tar_alcaran@sh.itjust.works 5 points 3 months ago (1 children)

just a few days after Firefox implements the features that have been blocking me from switching for the last few years.

Which are those?

[–] Zagorath@aussie.zone 5 points 3 months ago (2 children)

Multi-window support on iPad is the main one. Less important, though it would have bugged me if they didn't have it, is sustained Incognito tabs—which apparently they had until a couple of months ago, then removed without explanation, then added back in just 1 day ago, also without explanation. Found a thread on their forums with a whole bunch of people perplexed and asking what happened.

[–] ivn@jlai.lu 2 points 3 months ago (1 children)

There are actually no alternative browser on iOS. Before the European Digital Market Act all iOS browser have to use webkit, so while you could install Firefox, Chrome and others, they were actually using Safari's rendering engine. I believe that's where a lot of the limitations come from. Now with the DMA Firefox could use it's own rendering engine but this hasn't landed yet. I don't know if any other browser has switched from webkit yet.

[–] Zagorath@aussie.zone 1 points 3 months ago

There are actually no alternative browser on iOS

Sort of. As you say, it's more accurate to say that they're forced to use Safari's rendering, but everything else is up to them, the same as how any other app would be developed. That's how they get their own features like bookmark syncing etc.

Being able to have multiple windows of the same app is a feature Apple introduced in 2019, and obviously Safari supported it immediately. Google Chrome added support for multiple windows after a few months. I switched to Microsoft Edge once they added support for it about a year, maybe 18 months later, and have just been waiting for Firefox to finally support it so I can switch to that.

Incidentally, 2019 is also the year Firefox finally added support on their desktop browser for a CSS property (column-span) that a site I used to frequent required to work. Though by that time I no longer used that particular site.

[–] Mushroomm@sh.itjust.works 1 points 3 months ago* (last edited 3 months ago) (2 children)

Your first point at least is an iPad thing. Nothing is fully featured on the iPad. Not even safari. It's thanks to that exact fact that chrome is at least mostly fully featured on the iPad. If safari had comparable function, you could bank on them blocking those features from the chrome app too. There's a deal made somewhere. I wouldn't be surprised if cash flow from Google is why safari is still the same piece of crap it always has been. "Hey your R&D + return for safari only nets you 1% YOY. We'll give you 2% YOY if you just don't even bother."

They only know raising prices and knee-jerk reactions to competitive moves in their market space. Additional functionality for the user is only granted when it's being used as a cudgle against their competition. Never for users benefit.

If you're seeing new functionality on the iPad Firefox app, it's likely because Firefox figured out a way to implement it without paying apple because they want the user to have that function. Totally different ethos.

[–] Zagorath@aussie.zone 1 points 3 months ago

If you’re seeing new functionality on the iPad Firefox app, it’s likely because Firefox figured out a way to implement it without paying apple because they want the user to have that function

Nothing at all remotely like that. They just don't have enough developers to have implemented it sooner. It's an API that Apple introduced in 2019, that Google implemented within months, Microsoft implemented within a couple of years, and Mozilla finally implemented this July.

[–] ivn@jlai.lu 1 points 3 months ago

Regulations, like the Digital Market Act, are also a big factor.