1024
Yes, also Teslas (media.mastodon.scot)
submitted 7 months ago by Masimatutu@mander.xyz to c/fuck_cars@lemmy.ml
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
[-] wrinkletip@feddit.nl 23 points 7 months ago

As much as I agree, these are different things. EVs are fixing greenhouse gases. While the others are also bad things, they aren't really global climate changers.

[-] HiddenLayer5@lemmy.ml 22 points 7 months ago* (last edited 7 months ago)

Except EVs still have a significant carbon footprint from their manufacture. So do train cars and buses, but to transport everyone in cars instead of public transportation would require orders of magnitude more materials, and therefore a much higher carbon footprint. Not to mention the poor land use that car dependency causes, which both leads to deforestation and impedes reforestation, which is a further climate change contributor.

[-] shasta@lemm.ee 4 points 7 months ago

EVs also have the ability to live longer. If an average EV is usable for twice as long as an ICE vehicle, its carbon footprint from manufacturing is already down to 50%.

[-] HiddenLayer5@lemmy.ml 2 points 7 months ago* (last edited 7 months ago)

So can transit vehicles, in fact they last even longer so I don't see this as an advantage for EVs. In Vancouver, Canada for example, there are fully self-driving electric trains from the 80s that are still running perfectly fine today, and the only reason they're getting scrapped soon is because they're loud and uncomfortable compared to newer trains, which even then I personally don't like the transit agency's decision to scrap them because that's super wasteful, they could probably run another 40 years with good maintenance.

[-] shasta@lemm.ee -2 points 7 months ago* (last edited 7 months ago)

Alright well that's good. When the US shrinks down to the size of Vancouver maybe that will be a good option.

[-] Hildegarde@lemmy.world 3 points 7 months ago

US can't have good transit because it's so much bigger than a single city.

The US doesn't have cities the size of Vancouver, or municipal governments that can solve transit locally.

The country is simply to big for that.

[-] HiddenLayer5@lemmy.ml 3 points 7 months ago* (last edited 7 months ago)

The US has in fact shrunk down to the size of Europe which has excellent public transportation.

[-] Tvkan@feddit.de 6 points 7 months ago

But alternatives we have and know to work solve both greenhouse gasses and local porblems.

We'll have to stop driving gas cars specifically, but we'll also just have to drive less in general.

[-] Mars@beehaw.org -1 points 7 months ago

Are they? Because unless you live in some green energy paradise, most EV are charged using coal plants.

[-] Rookeh@startrek.website 13 points 7 months ago

Doesn't need to be a "green energy paradise", just a reasonably well connected first world country.

Take a look at Electricity Maps. Unless you live somewhere isolated or with very poorly developed grid infrastructure (or some central US states, apparently), you should see a non-trivial amount of electricity being generated by non-fossil fuels. For example, at the time of typing this 77% of the electricity I'm using is low-carbon and 50% of it is renewable.

That's the kicker. EVs don't have to rely on fossil fuels to operate (but they can make use of them depending on the grid infrastructure). ICE cars on the other hand are burning fuel wherever they go.

Walking or cycling will always be the least polluting means of getting around, but if you really need a car then you could do a lot worse than getting an electric one.

[-] Mars@beehaw.org 1 points 7 months ago

I’m really sceptic about that kind of metrics because many of them take carbon offsets into account, and carbon offsets are mostly greenwashing.

Power mix in the world right now is over 50% coal and gas, and only hydro is over a 10%. This is worldwide, so mix varies depending on where you are.

In the end EVs are no making a dent in power demand. They are increasing it. The percentage of fossil fuels is maybe going down but total fossil fuel consumption is increasing as our demand does. Green energy is only taking some of the slack from the increase.

EVs will be remembered as the thing we did to keep using cars and feeling good about it.

[-] SolarMech@slrpnk.net 1 points 7 months ago

The problem is, the way I see it, all energy use is connected. Basically the problem we have is energy consumption grows faster than clean energy production. So requiring more green energy in this context still sucks. Even where I live where all of our energy is green (at least in the grid), extra energy can be sold either via selling it to other provinces/states, or by making deals with companies to do their production here where energy is cheap and green.

Energy is a commodity on a market. If you use it to inefficiently move people, you can't use it for other things. Remember that to move a 150 lbs person in a car, you have to move about a ton and a half of car...

[-] CurtAdams@urbanists.social 7 points 7 months ago

@Mars @wrinkletip Hello, what century are you living in? The US gets only 20% of its electricity from coal and dropping fast. In CA it's 0%.

Aside from that, EVs are so much more energy efficient that an EV using electricity from a coal plant still produces less CO2 than an ICE car.

[-] The_Sasswagon@beehaw.org 1 points 7 months ago

Not op, but the material gathering and building of EVs is far more energy intensive and resource intensive than gas cars. They do even out but it takes a number of years on the road depending on the vehicle.

Additionally they are very heavy which requires more infrastructure maintenance and therefore more emissions.

That is to say EVs are not a sure fire improvement and it depends on the car, the place you are, the supply chain producing your car, where it's going to end up, and your own driving habits.

Or we could just invest in rail instead of doubling down on private vehicles. Then we can be sure.

this post was submitted on 10 Nov 2023
1024 points (88.4% liked)

Fuck Cars

9477 readers
253 users here now

This community exists as a sister community/copycat community to the r/fuckcars subreddit.

This community exists for the following reasons:

You can find the Matrix chat room for this community here.

Rules

  1. Be nice to each other. Being aggressive or inflammatory towards other users will get you banned. Name calling or obvious trolling falls under that. Hate cars, hate the system, but not people. While some drivers definitely deserve some hate, most of them didn't choose car-centric life out of free will.

  2. No bigotry or hate. Racism, transphobia, misogyny, ableism, homophobia, chauvinism, fat-shaming, body-shaming, stigmatization of people experiencing homeless or substance users, etc. are not tolerated. Don't use slurs. You can laugh at someone's fragile masculinity without associating it with their body. The correlation between car-culture and body weight is not an excuse for fat-shaming.

  3. Stay on-topic. Submissions should be on-topic to the externalities of car culture in urban development and communities globally. Posting about alternatives to cars and car culture is fine. Don't post literal car fucking.

  4. No traffic violence. Do not post depictions of traffic violence. NSFW or NSFL posts are not allowed. Gawking at crashes is not allowed. Be respectful to people who are a victim of traffic violence or otherwise traumatized by it. News articles about crashes and statistics about traffic violence are allowed. Glorifying traffic violence will get you banned.

  5. No reposts. Before sharing, check if your post isn't a repost. Reposts that add something new are fine. Reposts that are sharing content from somewhere else are fine too.

  6. No misinformation. Masks and vaccines save lives during a pandemic, climate change is real and anthropogenic - and denial of these and other established facts will get you banned. False or highly speculative titles will get your post deleted.

  7. No harassment. Posts that (may) cause harassment, dogpiling or brigading, intentionally or not, will be removed. Please do not post screenshots containing uncensored usernames. Actual harassment, dogpiling or brigading is a bannable offence.

Please report posts and comments that violate our rules.

founded 3 years ago
MODERATORS