Hockey

It’s hard with Cam; he was a backup that caught fire in the playoffs when they won the Cup and had a few fantastic years after that, followed by a lot of years where he was really a liability and maybe shouldn’t have stuck around. I’d have a hard time putting him in the top 4 all-time.

With the Staals if I were to pick one I’d probably go with Eric, too, but I suppose that could change if Jordan captains this team to a Cup win. I feel like that needs to happen in the next couple years before he ends up retiring, and his value seems to be more elder statesman/mentor than actual production at this point. Still great at face offs, of course.