this post was submitted on 18 Jul 2024
204 points (88.3% liked)
Progressive Politics
1074 readers
284 users here now
Welcome to Progressive Politics! A place for news updates and political discussion from a left perspective. Conservatives and centrists are welcome just try and keep it civil :)
(Sidebar still a work in progress post recommendations if you have them such as reading lists)
founded 1 year ago
MODERATORS
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
just gonna open with that with zero supportive evidence huh? Jesus Christ.
As an expert in another field, I’ll gladly go on the record refusing to rule out almost anything that is not actually impossible. That doesn’t mean I think it happened, or even that it’s even slightly likely.
If you ask your experts “is this possible” you are not getting your money’s worth.
Was there evidence supporting the lab-leak "theory" at the time? I think there was not. And yet, Fox News was harping on this hypothesis, Trump was calling Covid the "Kung Flu", and racists were hate-criming Asian Americans in the streets. There is a reason we were saying just shut up about the lab leak at the time. (Admittedly, it might be true, but that doesn't mean its proponents in 2020 were right.)
Yeah, probably not the best example...
Fauci backtracked all his previous lies about the lab leak being a conspiracy theory https://youtu.be/AqYZw1TNFZ4?t=1m38s
UsRighttoknow found evidence that a US company outsourced virus research that described covid19 to the Wuhan Lab.
Of course it's no surprise that the Wuhan Lab of Virology is responsible for the outbreak of a virus right next to it. But hey that Pangolin wet market story sounds so funny let's keep repeating it.
wtf is a fauci and what kind of source is a youtube video.
The doctor who led America through Covid as official presidential advisor. And the one responsible for lab leak being called a conspiracy theory.
Him backtracking on lab leak says everything.
For the leak documents see https://usrtk.org/covid-19-origins/scientists-proposed-making-viruses-with-unique-features-of-sars-cov-2-in-wuhan/
This is so dumb. We'll never know exactly but from what we do the initial infections don't convincingly point to workers from the lab, genetic evidence suggests zoonautic origins are probable, there is no proof either way. The Chinese government isn't allowing an audit, and by this point it's too late anyway.
There is no reason to believe it's likely. Let alone certain. It's literally just "China, who the usaians call red china, is uncooperative" and "there's a lab studying Coronavirus's in a region with lots of them"
You just got linked proof.
Even the person who gaslighted the world into believing lab leak was a conspiracy, has backtracked it last month. You just saw the video
Just accept that the government lied.
What government? what are you fucking on about? I don't give a shit about political games in some hick filled military cult if you're talking about the evil empire.
There is zero evidence sars2 came from a lab, zero. Something being technically possible is not the same as it being likely.
The American government.
https://usrtk.org/covid-19-origins/scientists-proposed-making-viruses-with-unique-features-of-sars-cov-2-in-wuhan/
Consider reading the article instead of responding without ever reading anything. You just don't want to see the evidence.
Yeah nobody who wrote that article or edited it understands virology and neither do you. This is not evidence.
Yeah sure bro you're a medical expert. You know all about pangolins and bats I'm sure of it.
Idk how to explain epistemology to you. This whole yeah yeah cleavage sites spike protein blah blah you gotta ask. Why were people proposing investigating that? Oh because they were anticipating viruses like that would be highly infectious and could emerge.
Coincidences actually do happen, how many proposed researches into coronaviruses don't match sars 2? Why don't initial cases line up with what we know of where lab workers lived and travelled? why is there no testimony relating to the lab work? scientists have souls you know.
Viruses jump species, novel mutations happen. Everyone was expecting a Coronavirus pandemic and guess what? In a completely predictable fashion we got one.
You can't just put red string between every vaguely cooincidental thing and conclude something. That'll have you going bonkers.
Yeah they just so happened to research a Corona variant in a lab in Wuhan right where the outbreak happened that matched Covid.
And now Fauci is walking back his claims about lab leak being a conspiracy.
But people have bought into his gaslighting so much that even when the person who did the gaslighting starts backtracking they are already fully bought in.
That research never went ahead you moron. Look I'm done, go huf petrol somewhere else
Yes so vaguely coincidental there were demands for researching a virus exactly like Covid in the Wuhan Lab, and then Covid broke out right in their area.
What a massive coincidence.
If you call Stewart both an expert and a commentator it's true!