Early Buddhism - Words of the Buddha

206 readers
2 users here now

A community dedicated to supporting awakening to the truth of enlightenment (Nibbāna) through inquiring into the teachings of the Buddha (Dhamma).

One awakens to the truth of enlightenment (aka stream entry) by:

Enlightenment is the elimination of greed, anger and delusion, dissolution of the ego and realisation of non-self.

An enlightened being would experience unconditional joy, contentment, freedom from beliefs, a high degree of concentration, and blossoming personal/professional relationships.

founded 2 years ago
MODERATORS
1
 
 

One of two results is to be expected for a bhikkhu who dwells wakeful, mindful, fully aware, collected, joyful, tranquil, and discerning with clarity at a suitable occasion in regard to the wholesome mental qualities - 1) full awakening here and now, or 2) the state of non-returning.

This was said by the Blessed One, said by the Arahant, as I have heard:

"Bhikkhus, a bhikkhu should dwell wakeful (alert, lucid [jāgara), mindful and fully aware ^[1]^, collected (composed [samāhita]), joyful, tranquil, and there, he should discern with clarity at a suitable occasion in regard to the wholesome mental qualities. Bhikkhus, for a bhikkhu who dwells wakeful, mindful, fully aware, collected, joyful, tranquil, and there, discerning with clarity at a suitable occasion in regard to the wholesome mental qualities, one of two results is to be expected: either final knowledge [of full awakening] here and now, or, if there is any residual clinging for existence, the state of non-returning ^[2].^"

The Blessed One spoke on this matter. In this regard, it is said:

"Those who are wakeful, listen to this,You who are asleep, wake up;Being awake is better than being asleep,For the wakeful, there is no fear.

One who is wakeful, mindful, and fully aware,collected, joyful, and tranquil;By thoroughly examining the mental qualities at the proper time,unified, they dispel the darkness.

Therefore, cultivate wakefulness,The bhikkhu who is with continuous effort, discerning, and who gains jhānas at will;Having cut off the fetter of being born and ageing,will realize the highest awakening right here."

This matter too was spoken by the Blessed One, as I have heard.


[1] mindful and fully aware here is being attentive, present, with full awareness, recollecting to be:

  • mindfulness of the body in and of itself: mindfulness of breathing suffices,

  • mindfulness of sensation (felt experience) in and of itself,

    • pleasant sensation, painful sensation, neither-painful-nor-pleasant sensation [of the worldly kind]

    • pleasant sensation, painful sensation, neither-painful-nor-pleasant sensation [of the spiritual kind]

  • mindfulness of mind (observing for emotions / perceptions rooted in greed, hate, delusion, collected, distracted, limited, exalted, liberated, not liberated) in and of itself, and

  • mindfulness of mental qualities in and of themselves. The mental qualities one is mindful of are:

    • observing for the presence or absence of either of the five hindrances of doubt, sensual desire, ill-will, dullness and drowsiness, restlessness and worry,

    • observing for the arising and passing away of form, sensation, perception, volitional formations, and consciousness

    • observing for the arising of an unarisen fetter, or abandoning of an already arisen fetter wrt the contact through the six sense doors: eye/ear/nose/tongue/body/mind

    • observing for the presence or absence of the awakening factors, e.g. is there the awakening factor of mindfulness present in me? likewise for others

    • observing for the presence of suffering, discerning its specific cause when it is present, observing for the ending of suffering, observing for the efficacy of a practice if it is bringing about the ending of suffering.

[2] the state of non-returning is attained if there is any any remnant of grasping remaining for renewed becoming. At this point, one has dropped the five lower fetters have been dropped.

Related Teachings:

Eight Persons Worth of Gifts (AN 8.59) - The Buddha is sharing in this teaching that it is very beneficial to be associated with individuals that are enlightened or practicing to attain enlightenment.

Reviewing (Ud 6.3) - The Buddha reviews the multitude of harmful and unwholesome mental qualities he has abandoned, and the multitude of wholesome mental qualities he has developed to completion. [One continues periodically discerning on mental qualities]

The Path and the Way of Practice for removal of five lower fetters (MN 64) - In this teaching, the Buddha shares the path and the way of practice for removal of the five lower fetters of: 1.) personal existence, 2.) doubt regarding teachings and one's ability to attain full awakening, 3.) adherence to rules and observances, 4.) sensual desires, and 5.) ill-will.

2
 
 

A series of questions and answers between Venerable Sāriputta and Venerable Mahākoṭṭhika on clarifying subtle yet important aspects of the teachings. Topics include right view, existence and the first jhāna.

These questions are preceded by the questions and answers on wisdom, consciousness, sensation, perception, and purified mind-consciousness.

Right View

12 "And friend, how many conditions are there for the arising of right view?"

"Friend, there are two conditions for the arising of right view: the words of another and wise attention (proper attention, prudent use of the mind, wise reflection, attention to the source [yoniso + manasikāra]). These, friend, are the two conditions for the arising of right view."

13 "And friend, by how many factors is right view supported such that it leads to the fruit and benefit of release of mind and the fruit and benefit of liberation by wisdom?"

"Friend, supported by five factors, right view leads to the fruit and benefit of release of mind (mental liberation, emancipation of heart, a meditation attainment [cetovimutti]) and the fruit and benefit of liberation by wisdom (emancipation by insight [paññāvimutti]). Here, friend, right view is supported by 1) ethical conduct, 2) by learning, 3) by discussion, 4) by tranquility (serenity, calming [samatha]) and 5) by insight (seeing clearly, penetrating internal vision [vipassanā]). Friend, supported by these five factors, right view leads to the fruit and benefit of release of mind and the fruit and benefit of liberation by wisdom."

Existence

14 "And friend, how many realms of existence are there?"

"Friend, there are three realms of existence: the realm of sensual existence, the realm of form existence, and the realm of formless existence."

15 "And friend, how does the production of renewed existence occur in the future?"

"Friend, through thorough enjoyment in this and that (taking delight here and there, relishing this and that [tatratatrābhinandanā]) on the part of beings obstructed by ignorance (shrouded by not understanding the nature of how things have come to be [avijjānīvaraṇa]) and bound by craving, the production of renewed existence occurs in the future."

16 "And friend, how does the production of renewed existence not occur in the future?"

"Friend, through the fading away of ignorance, through the arising of wisdom, and the ending of craving (cessation of wanting, yearning, longing, attachment, lit. thirst [taṇhānirodha])—thus, the production of renewed existence does not occur in the future."

First Jhāna

17 "And friend, what is the first jhāna?"

"Here, friend, a bhikkhu, secluded from sensual pleasures, secluded from unwholesome (unhealthy, unskillful, unbeneficial, or karmically unprofitable [akusala]) mental qualities, enters and dwells in the first jhāna, which is accompanied by reflection (with thinking [savitakka]) and examination (with investigation, evaluation [savicāra]), born from seclusion (secluded from the defilements [vivekaja]), and is filled with joyful pleasure (imbued with joy and happiness, with delight and ease [pītisukha])."

18 "And friend, how many factors does the first jhāna have?"

"Friend, the first jhāna has five factors. Here, friend, for a bhikkhu who has attained the first jhāna, there is reflection, examination, joy, pleasure, and unification of mind (oneness of mind [cittekaggatā]). Thus, friend, the first jhāna has five factors."

19 "And friend, how many factors are abandoned in the first jhāna, and how many factors is it endowed with?"

"Friend, in the first jhāna, five factors are abandoned and it is endowed with five factors. Here, friend, for a bhikkhu who has attained the first jhāna, sensual desire is abandoned, ill-will is abandoned, dullness and drowsiness (fuzziness, sluggishness, lethargy [thinamiddha]) are abandoned, restlessness and worry (agitation and edginess, distraction, fidgeting, fiddling, uneasiness [uddhaccakukkucca]) are abandoned, and doubt is abandoned; and there occur reflection, examination, joy, pleasure, and unification of mind. Thus, friend, in the first jhāna, five factors are abandoned and it is endowed with five factors."


In 19, first jhāna (jhana): the abandoning of the hindrances is of a temporary nature, typically done in a retreat setting or through an integrated gradually cultivated practice (MN 107) as part of one's daily routine. Through the [temporary] abandoning of the five hindrances, one is able to experience the arising of the awakening factor of joy (sometimes translated as rapture), a pleasant sensation that arises apart from the sensual pleasures.

Related Teachings:

Hindrances as different bowls of water (SN 46.55) - The brahmin Saṅgārava asks why sometimes verses stay in memory while other times they don’t. The Buddha replies that it is due to the presence of either the hindrances or awakening factors. He gives a set of similes illustrating each of the hindrances with different bowls of water.

Six Qualities to Abandon To Dwell in the first jhāna (AN 6.74) - The thoughts or perceptions of sensual desire, ill-will or harm, when present, prevent for the unconditioned mental quality of joy to arise in the mind.

5 qualities to abandon to dwell in the first jhāna (AN 5.256) - Stinginess regarding dwellings, families, gains, reputation and teachings should be abandoned to dwell in the first jhāna.

3
 
 

Thus have I heard - At one time, the Blessed One was dwelling in Sāvatthi, in Jeta's Grove, Anāthapiṇḍika's Park.

Then the venerable Mahākoṭṭhika, having emerged from seclusion in the evening time, approached venerable Sāriputta. Having approached, he exchanged greetings with the venerable Sāriputta. After exchanging pleasant and polite conversation, he sat down to one side. Sitting to one side, the venerable Mahākoṭṭhika said this to venerable Sāriputta:

Wisdom

1 "'One who is undiscerning, one who is undiscerning,' friend, it is said. In what way, friend, is one said to be undiscerning?"

"'One does not discern, one does not discern,' friend, that is why one is called undiscerning. And what does one not discern? One does not discern: 'This is suffering (discomfort, pain, unease, unpleasantness, stress, discontentment, dissatisfaction [dukkha]).' One does not discern: 'This is the arising of suffering (source of stress, appearance of discomfort [dukkhasamudaya]).' One does not discern: 'This is the ending of suffering (ending of discontentment, cessation of distress [dukkhanirodha]).' One does not discern: 'This is the way of practice leading to the ending of suffering (i.e. the noble eightfold path [dukkhanirodhagāmī]).' 'One does not discern, one does not discern,' friend, that is why one is called undiscerning."

Saying, "Good, friend," the venerable Mahākoṭṭhika approved and rejoiced in the words of venerable Sāriputta. Then, he asked him a further question:

2 "'One who is wise, one who is wise,' friend, it is said. In what way, friend, is one said to be wise?"

"'One discerns, one discerns,' friend, that is why one is called wise. And what does one discern? One discerns: 'This is suffering.' One discerns: 'This is the arising of suffering.' One discerns: 'This is the ending of suffering.' One discerns: 'This is the way of practice leading to the ending of suffering.' 'One discerns, one discerns,' friend, that is why one is called wise."

Consciousness

3 "'Consciousness, consciousness,' friend, it is said. In what way, friend, is consciousness so called?"

"'It distinguishes, it distinguishes,' friend, that is why consciousness (quality of awareness — subjective awareness of experiences and the knowing of objects through the six sense doors [sight, sound, smell, taste, touch, and mind]; fifth of the five aggregates [viññāṇa]) is called so. It distinguishes: 'This is pleasant,' it distinguishes: 'This is painful (unpleasant, unsatisfactory [dukkha]),' it distinguishes: 'This is neither painful nor pleasant.' 'It distinguishes, it distinguishes,' friend, what is why consciousness is called so."

4 "Friend, wisdom and consciousness—are these qualities closely associated (connected, entwined [saṃsaṭṭha]) or unassociated? And can these qualities be unpacked, unraveled, and their differences be explained?"

"Friend, wisdom and consciousness—these qualities are closely associated, not unassociated. And it is not possible to unpack them, unravel them, and explain their differences. For what one discerns, that one distinguishes; and what one distinguishes, that one discerns. That is why these qualities are closely associated, not unassociated. And it is not possible to unpack them, unravel them, and explain their differences."

5 "Friend, wisdom and consciousness—if these qualities are closely associated, not unassociated, what is the basis for their distinction?"

"Friend, wisdom and consciousness—these qualities are closely associated, not unassociated. Wisdom should be developed (cultivated [bhāvetabba]), and consciousness should be fully understood (completely comprehended [pariññeyya]). This is their distinction."

Felt Experience

6 "'Felt experience, felt experience,' friend, it is said. In what way, friend, is felt experience so called?"

"'Experiences, experiences," friend, that is why it is called felt experience (pleasant, neutral or painful sensation, feeling; second of the five aggregates [vedanā]). And what does one experience? One experiences: 'This is pleasant,' one experiences: 'This is painful,' one experiences: 'This is neither painful nor pleasant.' 'Experiences, experiences,' friend, that is why felt experience is called so."

Perception

7 "'Perception, perception,' friend, it is said. In what way, friend, is perception so called?"

"'Perceives, perceives,' friend, that is why it is called perception (the ability to recognize, identify, and conceptualize objects and experiences; third of the five aggregates [saññā]). And what does one perceive? One perceives blue, one perceives yellow, one perceives red, one perceives white. 'Perceives, perceives,' friend, that is why perception is called so."

8 "Friend, felt experience, perception, and consciousness—are these qualities closely associated or unassociated? And can these qualities be unpacked, unraveled, and their differences be explained?"

"Friend, felt experience, perception, and consciousness—these qualities are closely associated, not unassociated. And it is not possible to unpack them, unravel them, and explain their differences. For what one senses, that one perceives; and what one perceives, that one distinguishes. That is why, these qualities are closely associated, not unassociated. And it is not possible to unpack them, unravel them, and explain their differences."

Purified Mind-Consciousness

9 "Friend, what can be cognized (can be known, understood [neyya) with a purified mind-consciousness (bright, purified mind-consciousness of the fourth jhāna [parisuddha + manoviññāṇa]) released from the five faculties?"

"Friend, with a purified mind-consciousness released from the five faculties, the base of boundless space (field of boundless expanse, sometimes translated as dimension of infinite space [ākāsānañcāyatana]) can be cognized as 'space is boundless'; the base of boundless consciousness (field of limitless awareness [viññāṇañcāyatana]) can be cognized as 'consciousness is boundless'; and the base of nothingness (field of awareness centered on the absence of any distinct "something" to grasp or hold onto [ākiñcaññāyatana]) can be cognized as 'there is nothing.'"

10 "And friend, by what does one discern a mental quality that can be known?"

"Friend, one discerns a quality that can be known through the eye of wisdom (insight [paññācakkhu])."

11 "And friend, what is the purpose of wisdom?"

"Friend, wisdom is for the purpose of direct knowledge, for the purpose of full understanding, and for the purpose of letting go."


These are the first 11 questions from the MN 43 discourse on the greater series of questions and answers.

Ignorance of the four noble truths is entwined with the quality of consciousness itself. This influences how consciousness distinguishes (or doesn't) the suffering, the arising of suffering, the ending of suffering, and the way of practice leading to the ending of suffering.

For an ordinary person, the felt experiences that are taken as:

  1. pleasant (pleasurable, euphoric, happy, exciting, or associated with perceptions of comfort, belonging, hope),

  2. painful (often associated with a perceptions of sadness, discomfort, anger, envy, fear, anxiety, shame, or guilt) and,

  3. neutral (neither pleasant nor painful kind of felt experiences, often associated with perceptions of boredom, loneliness, shyness, melancholy, unsatisfactoriness, discontentment).

are just so due to the ignorance of the four noble truths. The arising of wisdom is about the gradual discernment [in each moment] of the four noble truths as it relates to these felt experiences, and associated perceptions.

An ordinary person living an unexamined life takes the pleasant felt experiences associated with pleasant perceptions as a substantial reality (appropriating an I/me/mine with these), and uses a variety of coping mechanisms to avoid feeling painful or neutral felt experiences.

A disciple of the noble ones undertakes The gradual training guidelines (MN 107), practicing in them gradually, to experience these felt experiences by gradually letting go of the same appropriations and coping mechanisms, and cultivating mindfulness to discern the four noble truths in each moment.

Related Teachings:

Steadying the mind against the poisons of greed, hate and delusion (AN 4.117) - The Buddha's teachings when practiced become a support for the mind, allowing it to remain steady in situations that once used to shake it up.

A regular practice of meditation clears the mind of obstructions - The role of meditation is as an active training of the mind to clear any build up of obstructive states of sensual desire, ill-will, dullness and drowsiness, restlessness and remorse, and doubt or perplexity; as these states when present, do not allow for the discernment of the four noble truths.

One devoted to diligence is incapable of decline (DhP 30, 31, 32) - The word diligence is a translation of the Pali word appamāda. It can also be translated as heedfulness. The mental quality of wishing to do one's work or duty well and thoroughly, with alertness, with care, and also with gentleness (serenity, tranquility, not agitated, not rushed).

4
 
 

116

One should hasten to do good (what is beneficial, wholesome, skillful, meritorious [kalyāṇa]),

and restrain the mind from harm (evil, wrong, worthless, bad [pāpaka]);

For when one is slow in doing good,

the mind takes delight in harm.

117

If a person commits harm (produces harm to oneself, harm to others, or harm to both),

they should not do it again and again;

One should not take delight in it,

for the accumulation of harm brings suffering.

118

If a person does good (produces good for oneself, good for others, or good for both),

they should do it again and again;

One should take delight in it,

for the accumulation of good brings contentment (ease, comfort, happiness, pleasure [sukha]).


Picture: Parallel, Oil on linen, Jason Anderson

Related Teachings:

The four right efforts and the power of tiny improvements over a longer timeframe (AN 4.13) - Applying the four right efforts consistently by periodically reflect on the wholesome and unwholesome qualities leads to compounding growth.

The wise and the immature (SN 12.19) - The Buddha explains the similarities and the differences between the wise and the immature persons through dependent co-arising.

The mind arises first, and the mental qualities follow it (AN 1.56, 1.57) - Observing for the presence and absence of the wholesome and unwholesome mental qualities is a good way to observe for the trajectory of the mind.

5
 
 

This teaching is part of the section The Happiness Visible in This Present Life: From "In the Buddha's Words" by Bhikkhu Bodhi ↗️.

The Buddha explains the four kinds of happiness that are attainable by a lay person who enjoys sensual pleasures.

Then the householder Anāthapiṇḍika approached the Blessed One. Having approached and paid homage to the Blessed One, he sat down to one side. When Anāthapiṇḍika was seated to one side, the Blessed One addressed him thus:

"Householder, there are these four kinds of happiness (ease, comfort, pleasure, contentment [sukha]) that are attainable by a lay person who enjoys sensual pleasures, from time to time, and on appropriate occasions. What four? The happiness of ownership, the happiness of using wealth, the happiness of debtlessness, and the happiness of blamelessness.

1 And what, householder, is the happiness of ownership (pleasure of having [atthisukha])? Here, householder, a son of a good family has acquired wealth through initiative and effort, built up by hard work, earned by sweat, lawfully and legitimately obtained. When he reflects, 'I have acquired wealth through initiative and effort, built up by hard work, earned by sweat, lawfully and legitimately obtained,' he attains happiness and pleasure. This is called the happiness of ownership, householder.

2 And what, householder, is the happiness of using wealth (pleasure of enjoying wealth [bhogasukha])? Here, householder, a son of a good family enjoys wealth acquired through initiative and effort, built up by hard work, earned by sweat, lawfully and legitimately obtained, and he does good deeds with it. When he reflects, 'I enjoy wealth acquired through initiative and effort, built up by hard work, earned by sweat, lawfully and legitimately obtained, and I do good deeds with it,' he attains happiness and pleasure. This is called the happiness of using wealth, householder.

3 And what, householder, is the happiness of debtlessness (pleasure of being debt-free [ānaṇyasukha])? Here, householder, a son of a good family owes nothing to anyone, whether little or much. When he reflects, 'I owe nothing to anyone, whether little or much,' he attains happiness and pleasure. This is called the happiness of debtlessness, householder.

4 And what, householder, is the happiness of blamelessness (pleasure of being faultless [anavajjasukha])? Here, householder, a disciple of the noble ones is endowed with blameless bodily conduct, blameless verbal conduct, and blameless mental conduct. When he reflects, 'I am endowed with blameless bodily conduct, blameless verbal conduct, and blameless mental conduct,' he attains happiness and pleasure. This is called the happiness of blamelessness, householder.

These, householder, are the four kinds of happiness that are attainable by a lay person who enjoys sensual pleasures, from time to time, and on appropriate occasions.

Having known the happiness of debtlessness,

and furthermore, the happiness of ownership;

A mortal enjoying the happiness of using wealth,

by that, sees clearly (understands with insight [vipassati]) with wisdom.

While seeing things clearly, the wise one,

knows both kinds of happiness [1];

Compared to the happiness of blamelessness,

these do not amount to even a sixteenth part.


[1] The two kinds of happiness compared here are: the happiness of debtlessness, ownership, and the enjoyment of wealth as one kind, available to laypersons who enjoy sensual pleasures; and the happiness of being blameless as the second kind, available to laypersons who enjoy sensual pleasures and in addition are purified in ethical conduct, disciples of the noble ones.

The Buddha isn't sharing the practice of ethical conduct as a rule or a commandment, rather, he is inviting one to personally experience and observe for the benefits of practicing in this way for themselves. One can practice by training in purification of ethical conduct for several weeks to a few months, and then reflect to independently confirm this teaching through one's own experience of it.

While the Buddha’s focus here is to help laypersons recognize the superior happiness of blamelessness—achieved through purified physical, verbal, and mental conduct—this foundation of good conduct also serves as the basis for the higher spiritual attainments, as illustrated in MN 6.

Related Teachings:

Happiness in this life and in the future life (AN 8.54) - Here, the Buddha shares a teaching to a householder on securing happiness in this life and in the future life by means of a moral and ethical living in society.

I Will Not Tell An Intentional Lie Even As A Joke (From MN 61) - The Buddha teaches Rāhula about the importance of truthfulness, teaching him to not tell an intentional lie even as a joke.

The Uposatha Observance (AN 8.41) - The Uposatha, when observed endowed with the eight factors, of great fruit, of great benefit, superbly bright, and far-reaching. The eight factors are - 1) refraining from taking life, 2) refraining from taking what is not given, 3) refraining from sexual activity, 4) refraining from false speech, 5) refraining from intoxicants and states of negligence, 6) eating only one meal a day, 7) refraining from dancing, singing, music, and watching shows, and 8) refraining from high and luxurious beds.

6
 
 

The Buddha describes the three quests of sensual pleasure, renewed existence, and spiritual life.

This was said by the Blessed One, said by the Arahant, as I have heard:

"Bhikkhus, there are these three quests (searches, pursuits [esanā]). What three? The quest for sensual pleasure, the quest for renewed existence, and the quest for spiritual life. These are the three quests."

The Blessed One spoke on this matter. In this regard, it is said:

"Collected (composed, settled [samāhita]) and fully aware (clearly comprehending [sampajāna]),

the mindful [1] disciple of the Buddha;

Understands quests,

and the source of quests.

Where these [quests] cease (finish, vanish, reach an end [nirujjhati]),

and the way of practice leading to their cessation (leading to their wearing away [khayagāmī]);

With the cessation of quests, the bhikkhu,

is satiated (satisfied, desireless [nicchāta]) and completely quenched [2]."

This matter too was spoken by the Blessed One, as I have heard.


[1] mindful = remembering to be present with continuous effort, observing the body in and of itself, feelings in and of itself, mind in and of itself, mental qualities in and of itself

[2] completely quenched in the context of mental defilements = completely cooled, with the fetters never arising again regardless of the exposure to objects that previously or potentially should lead to the arising of fetters on contact.

The state of being collected, fully aware, and mindful during all times of the day corresponds to the guideline 5 per the Gradual Training, Gradual Practice, and Gradual Progress (MN 107).

  1. Training in ethical conduct

  2. Training in sense restraint

  3. Training in moderation in eating

  4. Training in wakefulness

precede this guideline. When practiced in gradually as per each of these guidelines, one at a time, approaching each guideline as a formation of a new habit until its practice becomes easy, automatic and second nature, is the ideal way to cultivate the faculties mentioned in this teaching to understand the different quests, their causes and their ending.

Picture: Spiral head, Pavel Tchelitchew, 1950

Related Teachings:

Diversity of external contacts (SN 14.9) - The Buddha describes how dependent on the diversity of elements, there arises a diversity of perceptions, intentions, contacts, sensations connected with contact, desires, fevers, quests, and acquisitions.

Six Directions: A teaching on purifying ethical conduct (DN 31) - Purification of ethical conduct is the first training guideline that the Buddha shares for gradually cultivating right view. This is not a rule or a commandment, rather, a guideline that one can independently verify for its efficacy by practicing for a period of time and observing for the growth of positive mental qualities.

7
 
 

"Bhikkhus, there are these eight worldly conditions that revolve around the world, and the world revolves around these eight worldly conditions. What eight?

  • Gain (acquisition, money, profit, possessions [lābha]) and loss (not getting, not obtaining, not finding [alābha]),

  • fame (glory, prestige [yasa]) and disgrace (loss of reputation, infamy [ayasa]),

  • blame (criticism, disapproval [nindā]) and praise (commendation, approval [pasaṃsā]), and

  • pleasure (ease, comfort, happiness, contentment [sukha]) and pain (unease, discomfort, unpleasantness, discontentment [dukkha]).

These, bhikkhus, are the eight worldly conditions that revolve around the world, and the world revolves around these eight worldly conditions.

Gain and loss, fame and disgrace,

blame and praise, and pleasure and pain;

These conditions among humans are impermanent (not lasting, transient, unreliable [anicca]),

unstable (perishable [asassata]) and subject to change.

A mindful (who has recollection, is aware, present [satimant]) and discerning (wise [sumedha]) person, having understood these conditions,

sees them as being subject to change;

Favorable (pleasing, likeable, cherished [iṭṭha]) conditions do not stir (agitate, disturb, or excite [matheti]) their mind,

and unfavorable conditions cause no repulsion (resistance [paṭighātameti]).

They having dispelled alignment (favor [anurodha]) and opposition (aversion, resistance, hostility [virodha]),

these are gone and no longer present;

Having understood the unblemished (pure, stainless [viraja]), sorrowless state,

they comprehend rightly, having crossed beyond becoming (state of existence, rebirth [bhava])."


Related Teachings:

Acquire a possession which is permanent (from MN 22) - The Buddha shares to the bhikkhus that they could acquire a possession which is permanent, stable, of unchanging nature; or they could hold on to a self-view that doesn't cause any sorrow, displeasure and despair when holding on it.

Not being affected by praise and blame (DhP 81) - Just as a solid rock is not shaken by the storm, even so the wise are not affected by praise or blame.

The Five Unobtainable States (AN 5.48) - A wise person reflects on their nature, so they do not suffer when struck by loss.

8
 
 

The Buddha explains the difference between immature and wise persons, and how mental defilements increase or decrease based on how one perceives.

2.98

"Bhikkhus, there are these two kinds of immature (lacking in good sense or judgement, child-like in understanding [bāla]) persons. What two? One who takes responsibility for what has not yet come, and one who does not take responsibility for what has come. These are the two kinds of immature persons, bhikkhus."

2.99

"Bhikkhus, there are these two kinds of wise persons. What two? One who does not take responsibility for what has not yet come, and one who takes responsibility for what has come. These are the two kinds of wise persons, bhikkhus."

2.108

"Bhikkhus, [mental] defilements increase in two kinds of persons. What two? One who feels anxious (feels uneasy about, worries about, is mentally agitated about [kukkuccāyati]) about what should not be felt anxious about, and one who does not feel anxious about what should be felt anxious about. Mental defilements increase in these two persons, bhikkhus."

2.109

"Bhikkhus, mental defilements do not increase in two kinds of persons. What two? One who does not feel anxious about what should not be felt anxious about, and one who feels anxious about what should be felt anxious about. Mental defilements do not increase in these two persons, bhikkhus."

2.100

"Bhikkhus, there are these two kinds of immature persons. What two? One who perceives what is not allowable as allowable, and one who perceives what is allowable as not allowable. These are the two kinds of immature persons, bhikkhus."

2.101

"Bhikkhus, there are these two kinds of wise persons. What two? One who perceives what is not allowable as not allowable, and one who perceives what is allowable as allowable. These are the two kinds of wise persons, bhikkhus."

2.110

"Bhikkhus, mental defilements increase in two kinds of persons. What two? One who perceives what is not allowable as allowable, and one who perceives what is allowable as not allowable. Mental defilements increase in these two persons, bhikkhus."

2.111

"Bhikkhus, mental defilements do not increase in two kinds of persons. What two? One who perceives what is not allowable as not allowable, and one who perceives what is allowable as allowable. Mental defilements do not increase in these two persons, bhikkhus."

2.104

"Bhikkhus, there are these two kinds of immature persons. What two? One who perceives what is non-Dhamma as Dhamma (teachings of the Buddha that point to the nature of reality, the ultimate truth [dhamma]) and one who perceives what is Dhamma as non-Dhamma. These are the two kinds of immature persons, bhikkhus."

2.105

"Bhikkhus, there are these two kinds of wise persons. What two? One who perceives what is non-Dhamma as non-Dhamma, and one who perceives what is Dhamma as Dhamma. These are the two kinds of wise persons, bhikkhus."

2.114

"Bhikkhus, mental defilements increase in two kinds of persons. What two? One who perceives what is non-Dhamma as Dhamma, and one who perceives what is Dhamma as non-Dhamma. Mental defilements increase in these two persons, bhikkhus."

2.115

"Bhikkhus, mental defilements do not increase in two kinds of persons. What two? One who perceives what is non-Dhamma as non-Dhamma, and one who perceives what is Dhamma as Dhamma. Mental defilements do not increase in these two persons, bhikkhus."


One can perhaps visualize something akin to a life balance chart to periodically note on their gradual progress of the increase or decline of the mental defilements through the growth or decline in the arising of the hindrances.

The Buddha here is sharing three areas that can lead to the arising of hindrances:

  1. When one is concerned about what has not yet come, but unconcerned about what has come (what is present)

  2. When one perceives what is not-allowable as allowable, or what is allowable as not-allowable

  3. When one perceives what is not-Dhamma as Dhamma, or what is Dhamma as not-Dhamma

Related Teachings:

Appamāda sutta - Diligence (SN 3.17) - Diligence leads to happiness in both here and now, as well as in the next life. Buddha shares on this in a conversation with King Pasenadi.

Eight states to observe for to verify if one has understood the true dhamma (AN 8.53) - A teaching by the Buddha on investing and independently verifying true dhamma from counterfeit dhamma.

The path naturally flows for an ethical person (AN 11.2) - A virtuous person need not make a wish; it is natural for the path to flow on.

9
 
 

183

To avoid all injurious [intentions and actions] (harmful, bad, potentially evil [pāpa]),

to cultivate wholesome (healthy, beneficial, useful [kusala]);

And purifying one's mind (removing the five hindrances [sacittapariyodapanā])—

this is the teaching of the Buddhas.

185

Not speaking ill (refraining from slander, not blaming [anūpavāda]) of others, not harming others,

restraint according to the moral code of conduct;

Knowing moderation in eating,

dwelling in secluded places;

Dedication to the higher mind (meditation, mental development [adhicitta]),

this is the teaching of the Buddhas.


Related Teachings:

Leading to harm or benefit (AN 1.98 - 1.113) - A series of short teachings on internal factors to verify for seeing if harm or benefit are being produced.

Causes for the arising and expansion of the five hindrances (AN 1.11 - 20) - Short teachings on what leads to the arising and expansion of the five hindrances, and what leads to the decline and abandoning of the five hindrances.

Five factors of well-spoken speech (AN 5.198) - Following the five factors of well-spoken speech leads to improvements in one's personal and professional relationships.

10
 
 

This teaching is from the section The Four Noble Truths - The Matrix of the Teaching from "Noble Truths, Noble Path" by Bhikkhu Bodhi.

The Buddha explains why he teaches only a little compared to what he has not taught with the simile of the rosewood leaves.

Once, the Blessed One was dwelling in Kosambi, in the rosewood grove (grove of Simsapa trees, Dalbergia tree forest [sīsapāvana]). Then, taking a few rosewood leaves in his hand, the Blessed One addressed the bhikkhus: "What do you think, bhikkhus, which is more numerous — the few rosewood leaves that I have taken in my hand, or those in the rosewood grove above?"

"Very few, venerable sir, are the rosewood leaves that the Blessed One has taken in his hand; indeed, those in the rosewood grove above are far more numerous."

"In the same way, bhikkhus, what I have taught you is only a little compared to what I have not taught you. Why have I not taught it? Because it is not beneficial, does not relate to the fundamentals of the spiritual life, and does not lead to disenchantment (de-illusionment [nibbidā]), to fading of desire (dispassion, detachment [virāga]), to ending (cessation, termination [nirodha]), to tranquility (calmness, serenity, stillness, peace [upasama]), to direct knowing (experiential understanding [abhiññāya]), to full awakening (perfect understanding, enlightenment [sambodha]), to Nibbāna (complete cooling, letting go of everything, deathless, freedom from calamity, the non-disintegrating [nibbāna]). That is why I have not taught it.

And what have I taught, bhikkhus? 'This is suffering (mild suffering, intense suffering, discomfort, pain, disease, unpleasantness, stress, discontentment, dissatisfaction [dukkha]),' bhikkhus, I have taught; 'this is the arising of suffering (source of stress, appearance of discomfort [dukkhasamudaya]),' I have taught; 'this is the ending of suffering (ending of discontentment, cessation of distress [dukkhanirodha]),' I have taught; 'this is the way of practice leading to the ending of suffering (i.e. the noble eightfold path [dukkhanirodhagāmī]),' I have taught.

Why have I taught this? For this is beneficial, relates to the fundamentals of the spiritual life, and leads to disenchantment, to fading of desire, to ending, to tranquility, to direct knowing, to full awakening, to Nibbāna. That is why I have taught it.

Therefore, bhikkhus, effort should be made to fully understand (understand in principle, then discern in each moment and then experientially penetrate): 'This is suffering';

effort should be made to fully understand: 'This is the arising of suffering';

effort should be made to fully understand: 'This is the ending of suffering';

effort should be made to fully understand: 'This is the way of practice leading to the ending of suffering.'"


Related Teachings:

The effects of cultivating the eightfold path are gradual (DhP 273) - The noble eightfold path is a comprehensive collection of training guidelines that one should practice for the ending of the unwholesome mental qualities and for the benefits of enlightened mental qualities shine through.

Gradual Training, Gradual Practice, and Gradual Progress (MN 107) - The gradual training guideline teaching of the Buddha is how a student starting out in the teachings of the Buddha should gradually practice in to see gradual progress towards breakthrough of fully understanding the four noble truths.

Diversity of external contacts (SN 14.9) - When one is muddle-minded, there is an arising of diverse perceptions, intentions, contacts, sensations, desires, fevers, quests, and acquisitions. Furthermore, for an uninstructed ordinary person, these mental patterns are often mistaken as aspects of the self, taken hold of, and assumed to be "who I am."

11
 
 

The Buddha explains the six kinds of persons found in the world based on their mental qualities and understanding of the teachings.

Then, in the morning, Venerable Ānanda dressed, took his bowl and robe, and went to the residence of the laywoman Migasālā. Having arrived, he sat down on the prepared seat.

Then, the laywoman Migasālā approached Venerable Ānanda. After approaching, she paid her respects to him and sat down to one side. Sitting to one side, Migasālā addressed Venerable Ānanda, saying, "Venerable Ānanda, just how should this Dhamma (teachings of the Buddha that point to the nature of reality, the ultimate truth [dhamma]) that has been taught by the Blessed One be understood, where a celibate practitioner and a non-celibate practitioner might attain an identical destination in the next life (in a future existence [abhisamparāya])?

My father Purāṇa, venerable sir, was a celibate practitioner, living apart and abstaining from sexual intercourse, which is the common practice of laypeople. When he passed away, the Blessed One declared that he had attained the stage of a once-returner (the second stage of awakening [sakadāgāmī]) and was reborn in the Tusita heaven.

My paternal uncle Isidatta, venerable sir, was a non-celibate practitioner, but was content living with his wife. When he passed away, the Blessed One declared that he had attained the stage of a once-returner and was reborn in the Tusita heaven.

Venerable Ānanda, just how should this Dhamma that has been taught by the Blessed One be understood, where a celibate practitioner and a non-celibate practitioner might attain an identical destination in the next life?"

"It was indeed in this way, sister, that the Blessed One declared it."

Then, venerable Ānanda, having received alms food at the residence of the laywoman Migasālā, rose from his seat and departed. Later, after his meal and upon returning from alms, venerable Ānanda went to the Blessed One. Having arrived, he paid his respects to the Blessed One and sat down to one side. Sitting to one side, venerable Ānanda addressed the Blessed One:

"Venerable sir, earlier this morning, I dressed, took my bowl and robe, and went to the residence of the laywoman Migasālā. Upon arriving, I sat down on the prepared seat. Then, venerable sir, the laywoman Migasālā approached me. After approaching, she paid her respects to me and sat down to one side. Once seated to one side, she said to me, 'Venerable Ānanda, just how should this Dhamma that has been taught by the Blessed One be understood, where a celibate practitioner and a non-celibate practitioner might attain an identical destination in the next life? My father, Purāṇa, venerable sir, was a celibate practitioner, living apart and abstaining from sexual intercourse, which is the common practice of laypeople. When he passed away, the Blessed One declared that he had attained the stage of a once-returner and was reborn in the Tusita heaven. However, my paternal uncle, Isidatta, venerable sir, was a non-celibate practitioner, yet he was content living with his wife. When he passed away, the Blessed One declared that he too had attained the stage of a once-returner and was reborn in the Tusita heaven. Venerable Ānanda, just how should this Dhamma that has been taught by the Blessed One be understood, where a celibate practitioner and a non-celibate practitioner might attain an identical destination in the next life?' When she said this, venerable sir, I replied to the laywoman Migasālā, 'It was indeed in this way, sister, that the Blessed One declared it.'"

"And Ānanda, who indeed is the laywoman Migasālā—an immature person (lacking in good sense or judgement, child-like in understanding [bāla]), inexperienced, and influenced by her mother's mind and wisdom; and who can understand the superior and inferior faculties of individuals? There are, Ānanda, these six kinds of persons found existing in the world. What six?

1. Here, Ānanda, there is a certain person who is gentle and easy to live with, and their fellow practitioners appreciate dwelling together with them. Yet they have not heard [the teachings], nor become learned [in them], nor have they penetrated [them] by view, and they do not attain even temporary liberation. After the breakup of the body, after death, they go towards a state of decline, not towards distinction; they are indeed on a path of decline, not on a path of distinction.

2. Here further, Ānanda, there is a certain person who is gentle and easy to live with, and their fellow practitioners appreciate dwelling together with them. They have heard [the teachings], become learned [in them], have penetrated [them] by view, and they also attain temporary liberation. After the breakup of the body, after death, they go towards distinction, not towards a state of decline; they are indeed on a path of distinction, not on a path of decline.

In this case, Ānanda, some people with limited understanding measure others, thinking: 'This person has the same qualities as that person, so why is one considered inferior and the other superior?' This leads to their harm and suffering for a long time.

In this case, Ānanda, the certain person who is gentle and easy to live with, and their fellow practitioners appreciate dwelling together with them, who has heard [the teachings], become learned [in them], and have penetrated [them] by view, who attains temporary liberation, is more excellent and more sublime than the other person. For what reason? Because, Ānanda, this person is carried along by the stream of the Dhamma. But who can know this difference except the Tathāgata?

Therefore, Ānanda, do not be among those who measure people, do not make judgments about people. For, Ānanda, one who measures people is harmed. Either I, Ānanda, or someone who is like me might measure people.

3. Here, Ānanda, there is a certain person who has anger and pride ingrained within, and from time to time, greed arises within them. They have not heard the teachings, nor become learned in them, nor have they penetrated them by view, and they do not attain even temporary liberation. After the breakup of the body, after death, they go towards a state of decline, not towards distinction; they are indeed on a path of decline, not on a path of distinction.

4. Here further, Ānanda, there is a certain person who has anger and pride ingrained within, and from time to time, greed arises within them. They have heard the teachings, become learned in them, have penetrated them by view, and they also attain temporary liberation. After the breakup of the body, after death, they go towards distinction, not towards a state of decline; they are indeed on a path of distinction, not on a path of decline.

In this case, Ānanda, some people with limited understanding measure others, thinking: 'This person has the same qualities as that person, so why is one considered inferior and the other superior?' This leads to their harm and suffering for a long time.

In this case, Ānanda, the certain person who has anger and pride ingrained within, and from time to time, greed arises within them, who has heard the teachings, become learned in them, and have penetrated them by view, who attains temporary liberation, is more excellent and more sublime than the other person. For what reason? Because, Ānanda, this person is carried along by the stream of the Dhamma. But who can know this difference except the Tathāgata?

Therefore, Ānanda, do not be among those who measure people, do not make judgments about people. For, Ānanda, one who measures people is harmed. Either I, Ānanda, or someone who is like me might measure people.

5. Here, Ānanda, there is a certain person who anger and pride ingrained within, and from time to time, impulsive or harmful speech arisen in them. They have not heard the teachings, nor become learned in them, nor have they penetrated them by view, and they do not attain even temporary liberation. After the breakup of the body, after death, they go towards a state of decline, not towards distinction; they are indeed on a path of decline, not on a path of distinction.

6. Here further, Ānanda, there is a certain person who has anger and pride ingrained within, and from time to time, impulsive or harmful speech arises within them. They have heard the teachings, become learned in them, have penetrated them by view, and they also attain temporary liberation. After the breakup of the body, after death, they go towards distinction, not towards a state of decline; they are indeed on a path of distinction, not on a path of decline.

In this case, Ānanda, some people with limited understanding measure others, thinking: 'This person has the same qualities as that person, so why is one considered inferior and the other superior?' This leads to their harm and suffering for a long time.

In this case, Ānanda, the certain person who has anger and pride ingrained within, and from time to time, impulsive or harmful speech arises within them, who has heard the teachings, become learned in them, and have penetrated them by view, who attains temporary liberation, is more excellent and more sublime than the other person. For what reason? Because, Ānanda, this person is carried along by the stream of the Dhamma. But who can know this difference except the Tathāgata?

Therefore, Ānanda, do not be among those who measure people, do not make judgments about people. For, Ānanda, one who measures people is harmed. Either I, Ānanda, or someone who is like me might measure people.

And Ānanda, who indeed is the laywoman Migasālā—an immature person, inexperienced, and influenced by her mother's mind and wisdom; and who can understand the superior and inferior faculties of individuals. There are, Ānanda, these six kinds of persons found existing in the world.

Ānanda, if Isidatta had possessed the same kind of virtuous behavior that Purāṇa had, Purāṇa could not have even known his destination. And if Purāṇa had possessed the same kind of wisdom that Isidatta had, Isidatta could not have even known his destination. In this way, Ānanda, these two persons were each deficient in one respect."


The Buddha is sharing that when one regularly hears the teachings, learns them, and applies their mind to understand them by view (in theory, in belief, in attitude, in opinion) and they also attain some temporary liberation (a reference to either a jhāna or a formless attainment or to a well-developed practice of loving-kindness or compassion or sympathetic joy or equanimity) but do not awaken to stream-entry or another stage of awakening, then the stream of the Dhamma carries one towards a path of distinction, not of decline, even if they occasionally indulge in impulsive or harmful speech, or if occasionally greed arises in them.

The Buddha is also advising against measuring or judging his teachings (or other people) on topics that are not readily verifiable through one's experiences thus far. As far as such teachings go, on kamma, rebirth, psychic abilities, Nibbāna or some other topics, one can adopt these as a provisional view (similar to a hypothesis) and verify if holding this provisional view and practicing in line with it leads to cultivation of the positive qualities of mind. As the mind gradually awakens and as one develops sharper faculties through the practice of the eightfold path, one can revisit and gradually directly know on such topics at a later time.

Related Teachings:

Five Faculties and Way of Practice (SN 48.10, SN 48.18) - The superior and inferior faculties are reference to the five faculties of faith (confidence), energy, mindfulness, collectedness (concentration), and wisdom.

Four Persons wrt how and when they attain Nibbāna (AN 4.169) - The development of strong faculties leads to the experience of the psychic abilities as well as Nibbāna in this very life. A soft (weak) development of them leads to the experience of Nibbāna after death or in a future rebirth.

The effects of cultivating the eightfold path are gradual (DhP 273) - The noble eightfold path is a comprehensive collection of training guidelines that when one practices in gradually, leads to the ending of the unwholesome mental qualities and to the cultivation of the wholesome mental qualities.

12
 
 

DhP 77 One should advise and instruct [others], and prevent what is unwholesome; For one is dear to the virtuous, but to the unvirtuous, one is not dear.

DhP 78 Do not associate with harmful friends, do not associate with base people; one should associate with good friends, one should associate with best amongst people.

DhP 79 One who is joyous in Dhamma dwells at ease, with a clear and tranquil mind; In the Dhamma taught by the noble ones, the wise person always rejoices.

DhP 80 Irrigators direct the water, fletchers bend the arrow; Carpenters shape the wood, And the wise tame themselves.


Related Teachings:

Who to associate with (AN 3.26) - A man who associates with an inferior goes downhill, but associating with an equal, you will never decline; following the best, you will quickly rise up, so you should keep company with people better than you.

Somanassa sutta - Joy (ITI 37) - Endowed with two qualities, one can abide with abundant joy and ease - 1) by being moved on occasions that inspire a sense of urgency, and 2) by wisely striving when aroused with energy.

13
 
 

The Buddha explains the similarities and the differences between the wise and the immature persons through dependent co-arising.

At Sāvatthi.

"For the immature person (lacking in good sense or judgement, child-like in understanding [bāla]), bhikkhus, obstructed by ignorance (shrouded by not understanding [avijjānīvaraṇa]) and bound by craving, this body has arisen. Thus, there is this body and the external name-and-form (external world constructed through perception and experience [bahiddhā + nāmarūpa]). This duality exists. Dependent on this duality, contact arises through one or another of the six sense bases, leading to the experience of ease and discomfort (pleasure and pain, happiness and sorrow [sukhadukkha]).

For the wise person (astute, intelligent, learned, skilled [paṇḍita]), bhikkhus, obstructed by ignorance and bound by craving, this body has arisen. Thus, there is this body and the external name-and-form. This duality exists. Dependent on this duality, contact arises through one or another of the six sense bases, leading to the experience of ease and discomfort.

In this case, bhikkhus, what is the distinction, the disparity, and the difference between the wise and the immature persons?"

"Venerable sir, the Dhamma (teachings of the Buddha that point to the nature of reality, the ultimate truth [dhamma]) is rooted in the Blessed One, guided by the Blessed One, and takes refuge in the Blessed One. It is good if the Blessed One would explain the meaning of this statement. Having heard it from the Blessed One, the bhikkhus will remember it."

"Then, bhikkhus, listen to this and pay close attention, I will speak."

"Yes, venerable sir," the bhikkhus replied. The Blessed One said this:

"Bhikkhus, for the immature person, obstructed by ignorance (fundamental unawareness or misunderstanding of the true nature of reality, not experientially understanding the four noble truths [avijjā]) and bound by craving, this body has arisen. That same ignorance has not been abandoned, and that same craving has not been exhausted. For what reason? Because, bhikkhus, the immature person has not lived the spiritual life [1] rightly for the ending of suffering. Therefore, after the breakup of the body, the immature person fares on to a new body. Being bound to a body, they are not freed from birth, aging, and death, from sorrow, lamentation, pain, displeasure, and despair. I say they are not freed from suffering.

Bhikkhus, for the wise person, though obstructed by ignorance and bound by craving, this body has arisen. Yet that same ignorance has been abandoned by the wise person, and that same craving has been exhausted. For what reason? Because, bhikkhus, the wise person has lived the spiritual life rightly for the ending of suffering. Therefore, after the breakup of the body, the wise person does not fare on to a new body. Being freed from the body, they are freed from birth, aging, and death, from sorrow, lamentation, pain, displeasure, and despair. They are freed from suffering."


[1] Spiritual life in this context is the gradual cultivation of one's life practice based on independent verification of the teachings of the Buddha. This should lead one to gradually understanding the general law of existence of beings, to improvements in one's personal and professional relationships, and to the cultivation of positive mental qualities such as joy, being content with few things, diligence, having initiative and applying effort.

Related Teachings:

A handful of leaves 🍃 - Essential Teachings of the Buddha to Understanding The Four Noble Truths - A collection of the teachings on understanding the four noble truths by view.

Full Understanding Of the Six Sense Bases (SN 35.26) - Without understanding the “all” consisting of the six interior and exterior sense bases and becoming dispassionate towards it, it is impossible to be free of suffering.

Eight causes and conditions leading to cultivation of wisdom (AN 8.2) - The Buddha explains the eight causes and conditions that lead to the attainment, further development, growth, cultivation, and fulfillment of wisdom that pertains to the fundamentals of the spiritual life.

14
 
 

The Buddha explains to King Pasenadi of Kosala how to recognize if someone is an Arahant or on the path to Arahantship.

Thus have I heard - At one time, the Blessed One was dwelling in Sāvatthi, in the Eastern Park, at Migāramāta's mansion. Now, at that time, the Blessed One, having emerged from seclusion in the early evening, was sitting outside by the door entrance. Then, King Pasenadi of Kosala approached the Blessed One; having approached, he paid homage to the Blessed One and sat to one side.

Now, at that time, seven matted-hair ascetics, seven Jain ascetics, seven unclothed ascetics, seven single-cloth ascetics, and seven wandering ascetics, with grown-out body hair and nails, carrying various kinds of equipment, were passing by not far from the Blessed One.

King Pasenadi of Kosala saw those seven matted-hair ascetics, seven Jain ascetics, seven single-cloth ascetics, and seven wandering ascetics, with grown-out body hair and nails, carrying various kinds of equipment, passing by not far from the Blessed One. Seeing them, he rose from his seat, arranged his robe over one shoulder, placed his right knee on the ground, and, with hands joined in reverential salutation toward them, three times he declared his name: "Venerable sirs, I am King Pasenadi of Kosala; I am King Pasenadi of Kosala; I am King Pasenadi of Kosala."

Then, shortly after those seven matted-hair ascetics, seven Jain ascetics, seven unclothed ascetics, seven single-cloth ascetics, and seven wandering ascetics had departed, King Pasenadi of Kosala approached the Blessed One. Having approached, he paid homage to the Blessed One and sat down to one side. While seated to one side, King Pasenadi of Kosala said this to the Blessed One: "Venerable sir, those in the world who are either Arahants or have attained the path to Arahantship — these individuals are among them."

"It is hard for you to know this, great king, a householder who enjoys sensual pleasures, who lives amidst family, who uses sandalwood from Kāsi, who wears garlands, fragrances, and ointments, and who accepts gold and money — whether these individuals are Arahants or have attained the path to Arahantship.

Through living together, great king, ethical conduct can be known. But that is only known over a long time, not a short time; by one who is attentive, not inattentive; by one who is wise, not undiscerning. Through dealings, great king, integrity can be known. But that too is only known over a long time, not a short time; by one who is attentive, not inattentive; by one who is wise, not undiscerning. Through adversity, great king, resilience can be known. But that too is only known over a long time, not a short time; by one who is attentive, not inattentive; by one who is wise, not undiscerning. Through discussion, wisdom can be known. But that too is known only over a long time, not a short time; by one who is attentive, not inattentive; by one who is wise, not undiscerning."

"Wonderful, venerable sir! Amazing, venerable sir! How well spoken this is by the Blessed One: 'It is hard for you to know this, great king, a householder who enjoys sensual pleasures, who lives amidst family, who uses sandalwood from Kāsi, who wears garlands, fragrances, and ointments, and who accepts gold and money — whether these individuals are Arahants or have attained the path to Arahantship. Through living together, ethical conduct can be known. But that is only known over a long time, not a short time; by one who is attentive, not inattentive; by one who is wise, not undiscerning. Through dealings, integrity can be known. But that too is only known over a long time, not a short time; by one who is attentive, not inattentive; by one who is wise, not undiscerning. Through adversity, resilience can be known. But that too is only known over a long time, not a short time; by one who is attentive, not inattentive; by one who is wise, not undiscerning. Through discussion, wisdom can be known. But that too is known only over a long time, not a short time; by one who is attentive, not inattentive; by one who is wise, not undiscerning.'

Venerable sir, these men of mine are thieves, spies, who go undercover to roam and scout the countryside. Once they have scouted, I will then advance. Now, venerable sir, having brushed off the dust and dirt, bathed, applied ointments, with neatly trimmed hair and beards, and dressed in white clothes, they will indulge themselves, fully supplied and engaged with the five chords of sensual pleasure."

Then, understanding the significance of this, the Blessed One at that time expressed this inspired utterance:

"One should not strive indiscriminately,

nor should one be subject to another;

One should not live relying on another,

nor should one trade against the Dhamma."


Engaging in thorough examination and careful verification—whether it pertains to one's progress on the path to awakening, the cultivation of mental qualities, assessing a spiritual teacher, considering a new job opportunity, or evaluating a potential partner—forms a foundation of discernment and clarity. This process may be challenging and demands vigilance, but it provides the grounding needed for steady, confident progress.

Related Teachings:

Investigate the Teacher Himself (MN 47) ↗️ - In this teaching, the Buddha shows his commitment to radical accountability and integrity. He does not merely pay lip service to the notion of open inquiry, but lays out a detailed and exacting procedure by which his students should test him. By extension, this approach may be applied to any spiritual teacher.

Assessing whether someone is fit to hold a discussion (AN 3.67) - This is also a good criteria to screen someone you're interested in building a relationship with: a teacher, a boss, en employee, an advisor, a partner.

Independently verifying and understanding the unwholesome qualities and the wholesome qualities (AN 3.66) - This is a teaching in line with the overall teachings of the Buddha where he recommends against creating beliefs and assumptions (perceptions) based on how things seem, or based on any of the above.

15
 
 

Question from a practitioner and answer by the moderator as per Buddha's teachings.

Question:

So I'm seeing in some sutras that we are calling sexual intercourse a sin and sexual desire the root of rebirth in Samsara. Now I'm wondering if our entire world population was sterilized and infertile is that what the sutras would prefer? Like why don't we just end the human race? Am I being dramatic?

Or does that not solve the problem that theses cravings are ingrained in us and it's not the acts themselves but the underlying desire? Is there a sutra approved way I can enjoy sexuality?

Answer:

The Buddha's teachings are typically tailored individually to a person. For example, here's a sutta where someone asks the Buddha advise on Happiness in this life and in the future life (AN 8.54)

"Venerable Sir, we are householders who enjoy sensual pleasures live with children around us. We use sandalwood from Kāsi, wear garlands, perfumes, and ointments, and enjoy gold and money. Therefore, Venerable Sir, may the Blessed One teach us the Dhamma in such a way that it will lead to our benefit and happiness in this life and in the future life."

There are many other teachings geared towards householders, kings that focus on these aspects.

The entire collection of teachings that we have available today is the sum total of many of the Buddha's teachings where in each case, he was advising an individual or a group of people based on their inclinations and/or potential. Many of these are devoted to the bhikkhus or the monastic community who had left their householder lives to pursue the goal Nibbāna, and in those cases, the teachings are oriented towards that goal. So I'm not sure which specific suttas you're reading on sexual intercourse, but if there is a specific one that you still find concerning, you are welcome to share in reply.

The Buddha through his teachings is not sharing an ideal on how the world should be, he doesn't have a goal for the world to be a certain way. Rather he is pointing to how the world actually is, and a way of practice to awaken to this through self-reliance. For any one choosing to awaken, their life only ever gets better - as through wise decision making and by cultivating wholesome qualities of the mind, one is able to operate with ease in the world, and is gradually seeing improvements in their personal and professional relationships.

I think of practicing per the Buddha's teachings as akin to experientially understanding the general law that governs the existence of beings. It is similar to how before one experientially understood the natural law of gravity, perhaps as a kid growing up, one would have occasionally slipped or fallen down and now understanding it, one is able to operate with ease in this regard.

Is there a sutra approved way I can enjoy sexuality?

I would suggest that you consider practicing with the five precepts, which only share that one should not commit sexual misconduct. For example: per the guidelines of the precepts, one can enjoy sexuality while being in a loving, committed relationship and still make progress to awakening to stream-entry (first stage of awakening) as well as to being a once-returner (second stage of awakening). And while this is not stated as a rule or a commandment, you can easily observe for the harm that results from sexual misconduct: one may get into verbal or physical arguments, have a sexually transmitted disease, or go to prison even.

Here's a sutta about a student of the Buddha who was awakened and a once-returner while not being a celibate practitioner: https://suttacentral.net/an6.44/ ↗️

In certain cases, you may choose to overcome a craving by not engaging while in certain other cases, you may choose to fulfill it and overcome it. If you would like to enjoy sexuality and do so in a way that there is no harm being produced, then you may do so. The gradual training guidelines can be undertaken while enjoying sexuality: Gradual Training, Gradual Practice, and Gradual Progress (MN 107).

What the Buddha points out regarding sensual pleasures is that they pale in comparison to the pleasure and joy of the jhānas, and this can be accessed when one is gradually practicing per the gradual training guidelines and is secluded from sensual pleasures and unwholesome mental qualities for a period of time. You can have this as a goal and work towards it in tiny steps, slowly but surely. And this can be done while being in a relationship.

Be well and enjoy your day!

Question:

Thanks so much for the good reply. I'm pondering this now and I'll check those links.

As you say, I'm trying to tailor an understanding to my practice, trying to grasp the philosophical and metaphysical consequences of my decisions.

Because we know the minds of sentient beings, what moves them, where they're coming from and going to.. I'm leaning towards the idea that sexuality is too dangerous to be ignored (I'm a man in his late 30's for context) Overindulgence or just a little can reinforce cravings because sexual desire is so powerful isn't it?

What if I end up giving my next lives a great disadvantage, with over exaggerated sexual tendencies? I think this might have already happened to me.. but my Dhamma is that the buck stops with me, this life, ya know? What if I miss out on compassion to sentient beings of the opposite sex because my vision is intoxicated with this? Everything can be sexual misconduct if you look hard enough. What about biological imperatives? I want to be a Buddha or Arhat in modern society, do I care about biological reproduction?

Finally I think I need to step away from this temporarily..what you say about Jhanas is interesting, I'll pursue that! Then come back to this maybe my perspective will be clearer.

Answer

You're welcome, pleased to share. 🙂

Because we know the minds of sentient beings, what moves them, where they're coming from and going to.. I'm leaning towards the idea that sexuality is too dangerous to be ignored (I'm a man in his late 30's for context) Overindulgence or just a little can reinforce cravings because sexual desire is so powerful isn't it?

You're welcome, pleased to share. 🙂

Because we know the minds of sentient beings, what moves them, where they're coming from and going to.. I'm leaning towards the idea that sexuality is too dangerous to be ignored (I'm a man in his late 30's for context) Overindulgence or just a little can reinforce cravings because sexual desire is so powerful isn't it?

Thanks for sharing the context. I recall a time when this fever occupied the mind all the time, this was before I started practicing the teachings in a committed way. The fever of sensual pleasures in the mind is what you would like to resolve for. And if this happens by fulfilling the craving itself, this is okay.

Re: reinforcement, this can be a good inquiry. I would say, this happens through visualising a beautiful or an attractive image in the mind, as well as from not rationally seeing the drawbacks of it. If you're actively considering the drawbacks and cultivating discernment in this regard, that should help with it not becoming a fever within the mind.

What if I end up giving my next lives a great disadvantage, with over exaggerated sexual tendencies?

As you practically cultivate discernment of what actions/habits/conversations/thoughts/tastes/smells/touches leads to the arising of this particular fever, things should only ever get better, both in this life, and then, if there are any next lives remaining, in them as well.

And if a fever does arise, then consider if you're progressing in understanding its causes and growing your awareness of it. Instead of aiming to stop the fever outright, you can see if this progress is continuing. And when all causes have been correctly understood, and the drawbacks of engaging also correctly understood, then it should naturally subside.

I think this might have already happened to me.. but my Dhamma is that the buck stops with me, this life, ya know?

This can be a helpful intention to have in mind. If a complete stop feels natural, then sure, you can. What you would like to do is to then cultivate growth in the awareness of the arising of events that lead up to the fever itself.

What if I miss out on compassion to sentient beings of the opposite sex because my vision is intoxicated with this?

This is certainly a good point to consider.

Everything can be sexual misconduct if you look hard enough. What about biological imperatives? I want to be a Buddha or Arhat in modern society, do I care about biological reproduction?

The biological imperative is recognized as conceit/ego in the teachings, the "I am" notion.

Even with biological reproduction, one can make progress in the teachings, and experience the peace and joy of awakening. So this is a personal choice that you would have to consider.

However certainly, as one sees the benefits of the teachings through the cultivation of the wholesome mental qualities and as they build faith in the Buddha through independently verifying the teachings, there will be progress in being able to let go of this.

You may see this teaching: Sāriputta's bold declaration about Buddhas of the past, future and present (SN 47.2) - the path to being an Arahant or a Buddha is the same. One has to let go of the hindrances first through cultivating discernment, the step that you're actively inquiring into.

Good questions!

16
 
 

The Buddha shares a simile of a dung beetle to explain how acquisitions, respect, and popularity are harsh, bitter, and severe, obstructing the attainment of the unsurpassed safety from bondage.

At Sāvatthi.

"Bhikkhus, acquisitions (gain, money, profit, possessions [lābhā]), respect (honor, accolade, reverence [sakkāra]), and popularity (fame, praise [siloka]) are harsh, bitter, and severe; they obstruct the attainment of the unsurpassed safety from bondage.

Suppose there was a beetle, a dung-eater, stuffed with dung, full of dung, and in front of her was a large dunghill. Because of this she would look down on (have contempt for, be condescending to [atimaññati]) the other beetles, thinking: 'I am a dung-eater, stuffed with dung, full of dung, and in front of me there is a large dunghill.'

So too, bhikkhus, there is a certain bhikkhu who, overwhelmed by acquisitions, respect, and popularity, with his mind consumed (obsessed, controlled [pariyādiṇṇa]) by them, dresses in the morning, takes his bowl and robes, and enters a village or town for alms. There he would eat as much as he wants, he would be invited for the next day's meal, and his alms-food would be plentiful. Returning to the monastery, he boasts (brags or shows off [vikatthati]) in the midst of the community of bhikkhus: 'I have eaten as much as I wanted, I have been invited for the next day's meal, and my alms-food is plentiful. I am one who gains robes, almsfood, resting place, and medicinal requisites, but these other bhikkhus have little merit and are unimportant (of little influence, insignificant [appesakkha]), and they do not gain robes, alms-food, resting place, and medicinal requisites.' Overwhelmed by acquisitions, respect, and popularity, with his mind consumed by them, he looks down on other well-behaved (honest [pesala]) bhikkhus. That will lead to the harm and suffering of that misguided person (vain person [moghapurisa]) for a long time.

Thus, bhikkhus, acquisitions, respect, and popularity are harsh, bitter, and severe; they obstruct the attainment of the unsurpassed safety from bondage.

Therefore, bhikkhus, you should train yourselves thus: 'We will abandon the arisen acquisitions, respect and popularity, and we will not let the arisen acquisitions, respect, and popularity continue to occupy our minds.' Thus, bhikkhus, you should train yourselves."


Related Teachings:

Possessions, Respect and Popularity | Fishing Hook (SN 17.2) - The Buddha explains how acquisitions, respect, and popularity are harsh, bitter, and severe, obstructing the attainment of the unsurpassed safety from the bondage using a simile of a fisherman casting a baited hook.

Reviewing one's failings and successes from time to time (AN 8.7) - The Buddha advises the bhikkhus to review their own failings and the failings of others, and to overcome acquisitions, loss, fame, disrepute, honor, dishonor, evil wishes, and evil friendship.

Eight mental qualities to observe for to verify if one has understood the true dhamma (AN 8.53) ↗️ - A teaching by the Buddha on investing and independently verifying true dhamma from counterfeit dhamma.

17
 
 

The Buddha describes how dependent on the diversity of elements, there arises a diversity of perceptions, intentions, contacts, sensations connected with contact, desires, fevers, quests, and acquisitions.

At Sāvatthi.

"Bhikkhus, dependent on the diversity of elements (varied and manifold sense elements [dhātunānatta]), there arises the diversity of perceptions (variety of conceptions, manifold notions [saññānānatta]), dependent on the diversity of perceptions, there arises the diversity of intentions (volitions, purposes, thoughts [saṅkappanānatta]), dependent on the diversity of intentions, there arises the diversity of contacts (sense impingements, raw experiences, experiences of coming into contact with [phassanānatta]), dependent on the diversity of contacts, there arises the diversity of sensations (pleasant, neutral or painful felt experiences, feelings, second of the five aggregates [vedanānānatta]), dependent on the diversity of sensations, there arises the diversity of desires (inclinations, wishes, impulses, interests, goals, objectives, aspirations [chandanānatta]), dependent on the diversity of desires, there arises the diversity of fevers (burning passion, strong desires, fascination, infatuations, attachments, lust [pariḷāhanānatta]), dependent on the diversity of fevers, there arises the diversity of quests (searches, inquiries, pursuits [pariyesanānānatta]), dependent on the diversity of quests, there arises the diversity of acquisitions (gains, profit, attainments, objects of possession [lābhanānatta]).

And what is the diversity of elements? The objects of vision, sounds, smells, tastes, physical sensations, and mental objects. This is called the diversity of elements.

And how is it, bhikkhus, that dependent on the diversity of elements, there arises the diversity of perceptions,

that dependent on the diversity of perceptions, there arises the diversity of intentions,

that dependent on the diversity of intentions, there arises the diversity of contacts,

that dependent on the diversity of contacts, there arises the diversity of sensations,

that dependent on the diversity of sensations, there arises the diversity of desires,

that dependent on the diversity of desires, there arises the diversity of fevers,

that dependent on the diversity of fevers, there arises the diversity of quests,

that dependent on the diversity of quests, there arises the diversity of acquisitions?"

1. Objects of Vision (form element [rūpadhātu])

Dependent on the objects of vision, there arises a perception of form,

dependent on the perception of form, there arises an intention about form,

dependent on the intention about form, there arises a contact with form,

dependent on contact with form, there arises a sensation connected with form,

dependent on the sensation connected with form, there arises a desire for fine-material existence,

dependent on desire for fine-material existence, there arises a fever for form,

dependent on fever for form, there arises a quest for form, dependent on the quest for form, there arises an acquisition of form.

2. Sounds (voices, noise, sound element [saddadhātu])

Dependent on sounds, there arises a perception of sound,

dependent on the perception of sound, there arises an intention about sound,

dependent on the intention about sound, there arises a contact with sound,

dependent on contact with sound, there arises a sensation connected with sound,

dependent on the sensation connected with sound, there arises a desire for sound,

dependent on desire for sound, there arises a fever for sound,

dependent on fever for sound, there arises a quest for sound,

dependent on the quest for sound, there arises an acquisition of sound.

3. Smells (odors [gandhadhātu])

Dependent on smells, there arises a perception of smell,

dependent on the perception of smell, there arises an intention about smell,

dependent on the intention about smell, there arises a contact with smell,

dependent on contact with smell, there arises a sensation connected with smell,

dependent on the sensation connected with smell, there arises a desire for smell,

dependent on desire for smell, there arises a fever for smell,

dependent on fever for smell, there arises a quest for smell,

dependent on the quest for smell, there arises an acquisition of smell.

4. Tastes (flavors [rasadhātu])

Dependent on tastes, there arises a perception of taste,

dependent on the perception of taste, there arises an intention about taste,

dependent on the intention about taste, there arises a contact with taste,

dependent on contact with taste, there arises a sensation connected with taste,

dependent on the sensation connected with taste, there arises a desire for taste,

dependent on desire for taste, there arises a fever for taste,

dependent on fever for taste, there arises a quest for taste,

dependent on the quest for taste, there arises an acquisition of taste.

5. Physical Sensations (touch, tactile sensations, tangibles [phoṭṭhabbadhātu])

Dependent on physical sensations, there arises a perception of touch,

dependent on the perception of touch, there arises an intention about touch,

dependent on the intention about touch, there arises a contact with touch,

dependent on contact with touch, there arises a sensation connected with touch,

dependent on the sensation connected with touch, there arises a desire for touch,

dependent on desire for touch, there arises a fever for touch,

dependent on fever for touch, there arises a quest for touch,

dependent on the quest for touch, there arises an acquisition of touch.

6. Mental Objects (mind objects, ideas, thoughts, mental phenomena [dhammadhātu])

Dependent on the objects of the mind, there arises a perception of mental objects,

dependent on the perception of mental objects, there arises an intention about them,

dependent on the intention about mental objects, there arises a contact with them,

dependent on contact with mental objects, there arises a sensation connected with them,

dependent on the sensation connected with mental objects, there arises a desire for them,

dependent on desire for mental objects, there arises a fever for them,

dependent on fever for mental objects, there arises a quest for them,

dependent on the quest for mental objects, there arises an acquisition of mental objects.

Thus, bhikkhus, dependent on the diversity of elements, there arises the diversity of perceptions. Dependent on the diversity of perceptions, there arises the diversity of intentions. Dependent on the diversity of intentions, there arises the diversity of contacts. Dependent on the diversity of contacts, there arises the diversity of sensations. Dependent on the diversity of sensations, there arises the diversity of desires. Dependent on the diversity of desires, there arises the diversity of fevers. Dependent on the diversity of fevers, there arises the diversity of quests. Dependent on the diversity of quests, there arises the diversity of acquisitions."


One can reflect on this teaching to see if this is true in their experience or if there are any exceptions to this. On seeing that this is true without an exception, one can then see the value of training in sense restraint to aid in the gradual progress towards growth in meditation practice, mindfulness, dwelling in jhānas, and to awakening.

Related Teachings:

Gradual Training, Gradual Practice, and Gradual Progress (MN 107) - The Buddha shares the gradual training guidelines in the Dhamma and discipline with the Brahmin Moggallāna. It is through a gradual practice and gradual progression per these guidelines that one attains the ultimate goal of Nibbāna.

Steadying the mind against the poisons of greed, hate and delusion (AN 4.117) - A teaching on the three poisons of the mind.

Causes for the arising and expansion of the five hindrances (AN 1.11 - 20) - The Buddha explains what causes the hindrances to arise and how to abandon them.___

18
 
 

The Buddha shares the benefits for a person acting with a pure mind based on his direct knowledge.

This was said by the Blessed One, said by the Arahant, thus have I heard:

"Here, bhikkhus, I discern with the mind, after examining a certain person with a pure mind (settled mind, mentally full of confidence [pasannacitta]) as follows: 'If this person were to die at this very moment, they would be reborn in heaven, just as if they were carried and placed there.' What is the reason for this? Because, bhikkhus, their mind is pure. Indeed, due to the clarity of mind, bhikkhus, some beings, after the breakup of the body, after death, are reborn in a good destination (fortunate place [sugati]), in a heavenly world."

The Blessed One spoke on this matter. Therefore, it is said thus:

"Having known a certain person here,

to have a pure mind;

The Buddha explained this matter,

in the presence of the bhikkhus —

If this person were to die,

at this very moment;

They would be reborn in heaven,

for their mind is pure.

Just as one might carry something and set it down,

so too is such a person [placed in heaven];

Indeed, due to the clarity of mind,

beings go to a good destination."

This matter too was spoken by the Blessed One, Thus have I heard.


Picture: The garden of the asylum at Saint-Rémy, Vincent van Gogh, 1889

Related Teachings:

Happiness in this life and in the future life (AN 8.54) - Here, the Buddha shares a teaching to a householder on securing happiness in this life and in the future life by means of a moral and ethical living in society.

Why Beings Fare as They Do after Death (MN 41) - The Buddha shares in detail what leads to rebirth in a fortunate state or in an unfortunate state.

The five precepts (AN 8.39) - The Buddha introduces the five precepts as five gifts that one can offer to all beings.

19
 
 

This teaching is from the section The Four Noble Truths - The Matrix of the Teaching from the book "Noble Truths, Noble Path" by Bhikkhu Bodhi.

Do not think harmful and unwholesome thoughts. When you do think, think about suffering, the arising of suffering, the ending of suffering, and the way of practice leading to the ending of suffering.

"Bhikkhus, do not think thoughts that are harmful (injurious, destructive, bad, or evil [pāpaka]) and unwholesome (unhealthy, unskillful, unbeneficial, or karmically unprofitable [akusala]), such as thoughts of sensuality, thoughts of ill-will, and thoughts of harming (idea of hurting [vihiṁsāvitakka]). What is the reason for this? Bhikkhus, these thoughts are not connected with benefit, they are not essential to the spiritual life, nor do they lead to disenchantment (de-illusionment, disinterest, dispassion [nibbidā]), to fading of desire (dispassion, detachment [virāga]), to ending (cessation, termination [nirodha]), to tranquility (calmness, serenity, stillness, peace [upasama]), to direct knowing (experiential understanding [abhiññāya]), to full awakening, to Nibbāna (complete cooling, letting go of everything, deathless, freedom from calamity, the non-disintegrating [nibbāna]).

1 But, bhikkhus, when you do think, you should think: 'This is suffering (mild suffering, intense suffering, discomfort, pain, disease, unpleasantness, stress, discontentment, dissatisfaction [dukkha])';

2 you should think: 'This is the arising of suffering (source of stress, appearance of discomfort [dukkhasamudaya])';

3 you should think: 'This is the ending of suffering (ending of discontentment, cessation of distress [dukkhanirodha])';

4 you should think: 'This is the way of practice leading to the ending of suffering (i.e. the noble eightfold path [dukkhanirodhagāmī]).'

What is the reason for this? Bhikkhus, these thoughts are connected with benefit, they are essential to the spiritual life, they lead to disenchantment, to fading of desire, to ending, to tranquility, to direct knowing, to full awakening, to Nibbāna.

Therefore, bhikkhus, effort should be made to fully understand: 'This is suffering';

effort should be made to fully understand: 'This is the arising of suffering';

effort should be made to fully understand: 'This is the ending of suffering';

effort should be made to fully understand: 'This is the way of practice leading to the ending of suffering.'"


Disenchantment and fading of desire is a basis, a dependent condition based upon which one can experience the ending of suffering, the tranquility and peace of Nibbāna and have a breakthrough in fully understanding the four noble truths. In contrast, enchantment is a basis, a dependent condition based upon which one experiences delight, desire, grasping, holding on to, clinging, attaching, appropriating, taking possession, identifying, i.e. the arising of the whole mass of suffering.

One of the ways to understand stream-entry is the point where one has the ability to discern what thoughts lead to harm and what lead to benefit. So, as one is practicing towards the goal of stream-entry, a periodic review of whether one is gradually moving towards disenchantment (fewness of wishes, contentment, ease of application of sense restraint) and seeing growth in it can be a good indicator of one's gradual progress towards it.

Also disenchantment and fading of desire doesn't imply a lack of initiative and/or sluggishness. On the contrary, one will have more initiative and sustained energy to pursue wholesome habits, routines, goals, objectives, without being distracted or dissuaded by the instability of the external conditions as they progress towards stream-entry.

Related Teachings:

Developing the mind by classifying thoughts into two categories | Right Intention (MN 19) - The Buddha describes how he cultivated his mind with a careful categorization of thoughts to cultivate and thoughts to eliminate, understanding their relationship and how it inclines the mind's underlying tendencies.

Vitakkasaṇṭhāna sutta - Shaping of Thoughts (MN 20) - The Buddha explains how to cultivate the higher mind through similes: when a harmful or unwholesome thought associated with desire, aversion, or delusion arises, apply these five methods in a gradual sequence.

Arising of diverse perceptions, intentions, desires, fevers, quests (SN 14.7) - The Buddha describes how diverse perceptions arise from the diversity of elements, and how that can lead to the arising of diverse intentions, desires, fevers, and quests.

20
 
 

The Buddha shares with Potaliya, the wanderer, the four kinds of persons found existing in the world - 1) one who criticizes the blameworthy, 2) who praises the praiseworthy, 3) who neither criticizes nor praises, and 4) who criticizes the blameworthy and praises the praiseworthy.

Then the wanderer Potaliya approached the Blessed One. Having approached, he exchanged friendly greetings with the Blessed One. After having engaged in cordial and polite conversation, he sat to one side. As he was seated to one side, the Blessed One addressed him:

"Potaliya, there are these four kinds of persons found existing in the world. What four?

  1. Here, Potaliya, a certain person criticizes (dispraises, blames [avaṇṇa]) someone who is worthy of criticism, speaking what is accurate (correct, found to be existing [bhūta]), actual and at the right time (at an appropriate moment [kālena]); yet he does not offer praise (approval [vaṇṇa]) to someone who is worthy of praise, even when the praise would be accurate, actual, and timely.

  2. Then, Potaliya, a certain person offers praise to someone who is worthy of praise, speaking what is accurate, actual, and at the right time; yet he does not speak in criticism of someone who is worthy of criticism, even when the criticism would be accurate, actual, and timely.

  3. Then, Potaliya, a certain person does not speak in criticism of someone who is worthy of criticism, even when the criticism would be accurate, actual, and timely; nor does he offer praise to someone who is worthy of praise, even when the praise would be accurate, actual, and timely.

  4. Then, Potaliya, a certain person criticizes someone who is worthy of criticism, speaking what is accurate, actual, and at the right time; and he offers praise to someone who is worthy of praise, speaking what is accurate, actual, and at the right time.

These, Potaliya, are the four kinds of persons found existing in the world. Now, of these four kinds of persons, Potaliya, which one seems to you the most excellent and the most sublime?"

"There are, friend Gotama, these four kinds of persons found existing in the world. ... Of these four kinds of persons, the one who seems to me the most excellent and the most sublime is the person who neither speaks in criticism of someone who is worthy of criticism, even when the criticism would be accurate, actual, and timely; nor offers praise to someone who is worthy of praise, even when the praise would be accurate, actual, and timely. For what reason? Because what is most surpassing, friend Gotama, is equanimity (mental poise, mental balance, equipoise, non-reactivity, composure [upekkhā])."

"There are, Potaliya, these four kinds of persons found existing in the world. ... Of these four kinds of persons, the one who is the most excellent and the most sublime is the person who both criticizes someone who is worthy of criticism, speaking what is accurate, actual, and at the right time; and offers praise to someone who is worthy of praise, speaking what is accurate, actual, and at the right time. For what reason? Because, Potaliya, what is most surpassing is precisely knowing the appropriateness (knowledge of the right time [kālaññutā]) in each situation."

"There are, friend Gotama, these four kinds of persons found existing in the world. ... Of these four kinds of persons, the one who seems to me the most excellent and the most sublime is the person who both criticizes someone who is worthy of criticism, speaking what is accurate, actual, and at the right time; and offers praise to someone who is worthy of praise, speaking what is accurate, actual, and at the right time. For what reason? Because what is most surpassing, friend Gotama, is precisely knowing the appropriateness in each situation.

Excellent, friend Gotama! Excellent, friend Gotama! Just as if one might set upright what had been overturned, reveal what had been concealed, point out the way to one who was lost, or hold up a lamp in the dark so that those with eyes could see forms, in the same way, friend Gotama, the Dhamma (teachings of the Buddha that point to the nature of reality, the ultimate truth [dhamma]) has been explained by you in many ways. I go for refuge to venerable Gotama, to the Dhamma, and to the community of bhikkhus. May venerable Gotama remember me as a lay follower who, from this day forward, has gone to refuge for life."


The Buddha is pointing out a key distinction - that the ending of suffering is not just about a pleasant abiding in the here and now (i.e. an escape), but about wisdom cultivation - discerning what leads to the wholesome and to the unwholesome, to harm and to suffering, and then being able to operate in the world with ease based on this.

Related Teachings:

Assessing whether someone is fit to hold a discussion (AN 3.67) - You can know whether or not a person is competent to hold a discussion by seeing how they take part in a discussion.

Eight causes and conditions leading to cultivation of wisdom (AN 8.2) - The Buddha explains the eight causes and conditions that lead to the attainment, further development, growth, cultivation, and fulfillment of wisdom that pertains to the fundamentals of the spiritual life.

The Ten Tathāgata Powers (From MN 12) - A discourse where the Buddha shares his superhuman attributes, and the ten Tathāgata powers. This is in response to a student who has left the Dhamma and training who is disparaging the Buddha's states as merely human and his teaching as worked out through his own intuition.

21
 
 

113

Even if one were to live a hundred years,

without seeing arising and passing away (appearance and disappearance, formation and dissolution [udayabbaya]);

Better is a single day of life,

of one who sees arising and passing away.

114

Even if one were to live a hundred years,

without seeing the deathless state (epithet of Nibbāna [amata]);

Better is a single day of life,

of one who sees the deathless state.

115

Even if one were to live a hundred years,

without seeing the ultimate truth (the ultimate nature of things [dhammamuttamaṁ]);

Better is a single day of life,

of one who sees the ultimate truth.


Related Teachings:

Even if one were to live a hundred years (DhP 110 - 112) - The pairs of unprincipled / virtuous, undiscerning / discerning and lazy and weak in effort / steady in effort are contrasted.

Not fully understanding and not penetrating the four noble truths leads to continuation in samsara (SN 56.21) - The Buddha describes the wandering in cyclical existence due to not fully understanding and penetrating the Four Noble Truths.

Importance of cultivating wisdom (AN 76 - 81) - A series of short teachings of the Buddha highlighting the importance of cultivation of wisdom.

22
 
 

The Buddha uses a simile of a man who can catch the arrows shot by well-trained archers before they touch the ground to illustrate that life-sustaining conditions wear away faster than that.

At Sāvatthi.

"Bhikkhus, suppose there were four archers, firm in their aim, well-trained, skilled, and accomplished in their craft, stationed in each of the four directions. Then a man might come along and say, 'I will catch the arrows that these four expert archers, firm in their aim, well-trained, skilled, and accomplished, shot in each of the four directions before they touch the ground and bring them back.'

What do you think, bhikkhus, would it be appropriate to say, 'This man is one possessed of the utmost speed?'

"Venerable sir, even if someone were to retrieve the arrow shot by one expert archer, firm in their aim, well-trained, skilled, and accomplished, before it touched the ground, it would be appropriate to say, 'This man is possessed of the utmost speed.' How much more so in the case of four such archers, firm in their aim, well-trained, skilled, and accomplished?"

"Bhikkhus, though the speed of that man is fast, the speed of the moon and the sun is faster than that. And faster still than the speed of the moon and the sun is the speed of the deities who run ahead of them. But faster still than all of these is the [moment-by-moment] wearing away (exhaustion, depletion [khīyati]) of the life-sustaining conditions (life forces, vital formations [āyusaṅkhārā]).

Therefore, bhikkhus, you should train yourselves thus: 'We will dwell diligently (doing one's work or duty well, with alertness, carefulness and care [appamatta]).' Thus, bhikkhus, you should train yourselves."


Related Teachings:

Life Is Short and Fleeting (AN 7.74) - Araka was a famous teacher long ago, when the life span was much greater than today. Nevertheless, he still taught impermanence; how much more is it relevant today!

Rare That One Obtains the Human State (SN 55.47) - The Buddha shares on the difficulty of regaining human existence for an undiscerning person who has fallen into a lower realm.

One devoted to diligence is incapable of decline (DhP 30, 31, 32)

23
 
 

Four contrasting pairs of verbal misconduct and good conducts

"Bhikkhus, there are these four kinds of verbal misconduct. What four?

1 Lying (false speech [musāvāda]),

2 divisive speech (slanderous, defamatory, malicious [pisuṇa vācā]),

3 harsh speech (abusive, rough, hard, unkind [pharusā vācā]),

4 frivolous chatter (meaningless talk, gossip, idle speech [samphappalāpa]).

These are the four kinds of verbal misconduct."

-- AN 4.148

"Bhikkhus, there are these four kinds of verbal good conduct. What four?

1 Truthful speech (speaking what is true [saccavācā]),

2 non-divisive speech (not slanderous, not defamatory, not malicious [apisuṇa vācā]),

3 gentle speech (spoken politely, with a mind of loving-kindness [saṇhā vācā]),

4 wise counsel (relevant, beneficial, to the point [mantabhāsā]).

These are the four kinds of verbal good conduct."

-- AN 4.149


Tendencies to use false speech and truthful speech arise from whether one is actively interested in verifying and examining what is heard, seen, or sensed versus assuming things at face value or jumping to quick conclusions. In addition, intentionally using false speech to deceive others leads to harm—from experiencing a loss of trust with others to an increase in anxiety, guilt, and internal conflicts.

Tendencies to use divisive and harsh speech come from the mistaken belief that by blowing out another’s candle, one’s own light will shine brighter. This behavior can damage friendships and work relationships, lead to social isolation, or result in unnecessary conflicts.

The tendency to engage in frivolous chatter leads to wasted time and energy, shallow relationships, and a loss of mental composure.

On the other hand, practicing the four kinds of right speech, along with speaking at the proper time, leads to wholesome outcomes. One earns the trust and respect of one's friends, colleagues and community by consistently practicing the five factors of well-spoken speech.

Related Teachings:

Speech like dung, flowers and honey (AN 3.28) - This is a teaching where the Buddha is categorizing speech into three types. One can verify this teaching by observing for the hindrances that come up during meditation or with the amount of disagreeable or agreeable contact one comes across in their interactions.

A line drawn in water | A teaching on speech (AN 3.132) - The Buddha is sharing a guidance here on people who can harmoniously interact with others, even in the face of hostility. This is a quality one will gradually cultivate as they work towards enlightenment.

24
 
 

The Buddha explains the benefits of cultivating loving-kindness compared to giving donations.

At Sāvatthi.

"Bhikkhus, if someone were to give a donation (the act of giving or donating, with an intention to give [dāna]) of a hundred pots [of food] in the morning, a hundred pots of food at noon, and a hundred pots of food in the evening, and if someone else were to cultivate a mind of loving-kindness (friendly heart, kind mind, benevolent mind [mettācitta]) even for the brief moment it takes to milk a cow, whether in the morning, at noon, or in the evening — this [cultivation of loving-kindness] would yield far greater fruit than those givings.

Therefore, bhikkhus, you should train yourselves thus: 'Our release of mind (mental liberation, emancipation of heart, a meditation attainment [cetovimutti]) through loving-kindness will be developed, practiced often, made a vehicle, made a basis, firmly established, nurtured, and resolutely undertaken (fully engaged with, energetically taken up [susamāraddha]).' Thus, bhikkhus, you should train yourselves."


Related Teachings:

Five ways to remove arisen resentment (AN 5.161) - 1) loving-kindness, 2) compassion, 3) equanimity, 4) disregarding and non-attention, 5) reflection on kamma.

11 Benefits of practicing Loving-Kindness (AN 11.15) - from sleeping with ease to dying unconfused to going to the Brahma world.

Verses on Loving-Kindness | Metta Sutta (Snp 1.8) - This Metta Sutta offers a practical way to overcome any negative states of mind and root them in contentment, good-will and harmlessness.

25
 
 

The Buddha shares the three unwholesome thoughts - 1) concerning one's reputation, 2) concerning acquisitions, respect, and popularity, and 3) associated with inappropriate concern for others.

This was said by the Blessed One, said by the Arahant, thus I have heard:

"Bhikkhus, there are these three unwholesome thoughts (unskillful thoughts, unbeneficial thinking, karmically unprofitable thoughts [akusalavitakka]). Which three?

  1. A thought concerning one's reputation (about one's social standing [anavaññattipaṭisaṃyutta]),

  2. a thought concerning with acquisitions, respect, and popularity (about material gains or possessions, honor or reverence, and fame or praise [lābhasakkārasilokapaṭisaṃyutta]), and

  3. a thought associated with [inappropriate] concern for others (with excessive compassion for others [parānuddayatāpaṭisaṃyutta]).

These, indeed, are three unwholesome thoughts."

The Blessed One spoke on this matter. Therefore, it is said thus:

Concerned with one's reputation,

valuing acquisitions and respect;

Rejoicing together with associates (colleagues, friends, co-workers [amacca]),

Such a one is far away from the exhaustion of the fetters (wearing away of the bonds that bind one to the cycle of existence [saṃyojanakkhaya]).

Having left behind children and cattle (sons and livestock [puttapasu]),

marriage and acquisitions;

Such a bhikkhu is capable of,

attaining the highest awakening (supreme enlightenment [sambodhimuttama]).

This matter too was spoken by the Blessed One, thus I have heard.


Picture: Boy Behind The Mask, Sarah Weaver, 2008

Related Teachings:

Sensuality is subject to time, of much stress (SN 1.20) - A deity tries to persuade a monk to first enjoy sensual pleasures and then go forth.

Anger, contempt, gain and honor (AN 4.43) - The Buddha shares the four kinds of persons found in the world - those who value anger, contempt, gain, and honor, and those who value the good Dhamma instead.

The Spiritual Life (AN 4.25) - The spiritual life is not led to deceive people, not for gaining their applause, not for acquiring gains and honors, nor for winning an argument, nor out of a desire for people to know 'thus about me'.

view more: next ›