Ask Lemmy

I’m not understanding your point here. Can you reword it perhaps?

If I’m not happy with how /r/knives is run on Reddit, I can make /r/knife to compete with it.

Ah, gotcha. Thank you for that. I understand your example. My response is, irrespective of /r/knives or /r/knife if Reddit bans the word "luigi" both subreddits are affected. That isn't the case with Lemmy where if one instance bans a word, other instances don't have to follow suit.

The modlog entries I’ve read show the offending comment as well as the moderator given reason for a ban.

It shows part of the comment. I think there’s a limit on length, and it does not show media. The mod log is a good idea, but there’s room for improvement.

This is good information. I didn't know about the limit length. I did some Google searches and could only find references to the 10,000 character Lemmy post limit, but nothing about the limit of modlog entires. Any idea what it is?

You make a good point on media. I didn't know that either.

I will say that for any modlog entry I've seen of a removed comment I largely agree with the moderator's actions about 95% of the time. I'm guessing a character limit would have to be VERY short for it to not capture the gist of an offending comment though. I'm prepared to retract that if you tell me its extremely small.

Where I’ll disagree with you that one has to exist or Lemmy will fail.

I never said Lemmy will fail, and that is not my position.

Apologies if I mistook your statements. I saw you referring to Lemmy as a whole, and the need for a Fediverse wide fix being your opinion to be necessary for Lemmy to not be eventually destroyed as a whole. If you have a more nuanced opinion on the points we're discussing, I'm open to hearing it.