Fuck AI

Ok so i do know there are some people with aphantasia who do art but didn't want to get into a long rant about this but congratulations your comment has triggered me by sharing the first search result with no commentary (did you even read it?).

First off, yes, art comes in many forms. I use my artistic expression in my writing. But abstract art can still be visualized in advance by artists, something i literally cannot do. Can i still make art (abstract and otherwise), yes, but it takes longer than someone else who can visualize. Also telling me i can just do abstract art is like telling someone who can't use their legs that they can still walk if they use some hands crunches and drag their legs along. Is it possible? Maybe! Is it something that will be enjoyable? Probably not. I don't feel people would respond to a handicapped person this way but maybe they do. They do respond this way to me, all the time. Maybe they think they are helping, but it's not helpful.

Anyway, the animator. So if you actually read the article it talks about the difference between seeing it describing things. I cannot see my wife in my head, but i have studied her face countless times over the decades. If i were to describe her face to you it would be a series of long lists about each feature of her face. This is what i would compare to someone's job as domain knowledge. If you do something many times, you have experience with this. If i were an animator for a company then yeah i could have domain knowledge and get by doing that since i have prepared long lists of different characters, objects, or general setting characteristics for new things (it will still be harder than someone who can visualize since they don't need to iterate as much).

Now if you ask me about something else though, the details i can recall are much less. If i want to draw a cthulu-esque monster combined with two humanoid legs then i could try to recall details about these things but my cthulu piece is just a blob, i don't really know much besides describing tentacles. Of course i could look things up but then im just back to copying things.

But what if i just want to make my own original art? Well, i need to describe it in my head first. Describe it in great detail and then hope the words i have used to describe it match how i actually want it to appear for my writing.

And that's the type of art i care about. And that's the type of art genAI can help me visualize if i use it (again, i don't anymore). But imagine that handicap person who can't walk now getting some robotic assisted crutches. That's what i imagine it felt like for me to visualize things with genAI. I could just feed it lists of details and it effortlessly showed me approximations of what my detail-lists are. I could "see" my thoughts for the first time. Could i do all of this myself without genAI? Yeah if i spent enough time on it. It just isn't fun for me.

And what do you do for work or hobbies? Do you do anything that you're dogshit at? Do you do something that you do have a physical or mental disadvantage in? Ive done hobbies to push myself in other areas of my life, but not this one. Like i said, it isn't fun for me. And telling me to do other kinds of art isn't helpful either.

And to be clear, I'm not using any of this as a justification to use genAI on unlicensed work. My original comment expressed my desire to have models with licensed work. Because i do want to just effortlessly "see" my thoughts like everyone else. That's it.