this post was submitted on 22 Jul 2025
1140 points (98.6% liked)
Curated Tumblr
5703 readers
50 users here now
For preserving the least toxic and most culturally relevant Tumblr heritage posts.
Here are some OCR tools to assist you in transcribing posts:
-
FOSS Android Recs per u/m_f@discuss.online: 1 , 2
Don't be mean. I promise to do my best to judge that fairly.
founded 2 years ago
MODERATORS
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
I mean... Fuck AI and all, but hard way = better is definitely not some universal principal we should be applying to education.
The most famous example is all of the people who grew up when calculators were large and expensive pieces of equipment, who were told "you need to memorize your multiplication tables because you won't always have a calculator with you", which sounds absolutely ridiculous to anyone today.
I think it's important for humanity to ask itself: which cognitive processes should we dedicate our fleshy organic brains to, and which cognitive processes are better off outsourced to external technologies? "AI" as a modern buzzword seems to be trying to positively brand these products that are trying (and usually failing) to take on processes that are best left within the brain.
Did you really not memorize your multiplication tables? Can you do mental math? For me, knowing multiplication tables is a matter of convenience; it takes a few seconds to pull out a calculator and type in the numbers when I'm perfectly able to do it instantly. Even two by one digit multiplication is faster than pulling out a calculator.
It's important to distinguish between what you memorized as part of a rote process as a child as part of your formal education process versus what you have remember as part of your lifetime of experiences. And if your own personal first exposure to multiplication tables was being made to memorize them, you are probably going to think that's the only way to do it.
For example, most adults would probably the ones they use the most often memorized without any formal education. People use halves, quarters, doubles, and quadruples all the time, so the brain creates shortcuts for those.
Personally my older sister taught me the principles of multiplication and division a couple of years before I encountered them in elementary school. So I had already started to think of it as like... A nested adding function. And also using the algebraic properties (communicative, distributive, associative... I'm probably forgetting some of their names) helped me to understand the numbers and their relationships. So memorizing that 10x means you move the decimal place, but then extrapolating that so that n x 5 = n x 10/2 , which is often easier. Or that n x 9 = (n x 10) - n. So memorizing not the results, but the process.
So when I got to 2nd grade and they started teaching multiplication tables my experience was different from my peers. They would hand out sheets of multiplication problems for the class to do quietly, and at first I was about average: faster than the kids who weren't trying, but slower than the ones who had begun to memorize the table. But I was less prone to the errors that other kids would make: mixing up 6's and 9's or 1's and 7's because they look similar, for example. And I quickly got faster than them, especially when we expanded beyond aingle-digit tables. It also helped me in the process of learning division: when we on from just leaving remainders as an R# to actually writing out decimals or using fractions. My peers would get tripped up trying to divide a number that did not fit nearly into the tables they had memorized. Then they introduced exponents, which a lot of people struggled with but for me was the next logical step to take (although my sister probably showed them to me earlier too).
And even today I totally break out the calculator app or even spreadsheet app on my phone. Not for help with the algebra, but to make a record and make sure that I'm including everything I need to. If I were in the grocery store trying to predict what my end cost will be at checkout, it's much more likely I would get it wrong from missing an item, missing a promotion, or not knowing enough about sales tax eligibility than from any algebraic mistake.
You make a good point. I'm interested to know how old you are, because the 'correct' way to teach math has been debated for 70ish years New math was introduced in the 50's, and emphasized the understanding of how base-10 works. This is commonly mistaken for common core math,which put even more emphasis on understanding the procedures used for math rather than the right answer. When I grew up, addition was mainly based in new math, whereas multiplication was introduced as successive addition, but was mostly focused on memorizing tables.
I'm in my 30's. Just barely missed Common Core but I remember hearing parents with younger children complaining about it. I don't remember the math I was taught having any specific branding with it, though it may have been a late variant of New Math.
What I was taught in schools definitely still had a lot of memorization involved. I consider myself lucky that my sister taught me earlier, because I saw a lot of my bright peers struggle with the way it was taught in schools. I never had to study math outside of school for my entire academic career. She helped me to understand computers (she also taught me binary, octal, and hexadecimal systems. Hexadecimal is very useful for a kid with a GameShark and Pokemon).