Technology
This is the official technology community of Lemmy.ml for all news related to creation and use of technology, and to facilitate civil, meaningful discussion around it.
Ask in DM before posting product reviews or ads. All such posts otherwise are subject to removal.
Rules:
1: All Lemmy rules apply
2: Do not post low effort posts
3: NEVER post naziped*gore stuff
4: Always post article URLs or their archived version URLs as sources, NOT screenshots. Help the blind users.
5: personal rants of Big Tech CEOs like Elon Musk are unwelcome (does not include posts about their companies affecting wide range of people)
6: no advertisement posts unless verified as legitimate and non-exploitative/non-consumerist
7: crypto related posts, unless essential, are disallowed
view the rest of the comments
is facebookification a word? I am so sad to see this happen as a long time user of Reddit, been on there for...god, 11 years according to my profile awards. I see a lot of people saying this is the end of Reddit but I have to disagree, it is more like a new age. Reddit will now only be used by people who are fine with getting absolutely fucked with ads and close to nil moderation. I imagine it will be a husk of what it once was - it'll look the same but I'm sure it will just be repost land. It wasn't hard to see this coming, but I can't help but feel a sadness.
Do I need to go outside more? Probably.
RIP
I've been using this term a LOT since coming across that Medium article.
Wow, thanks for teaching me this term! Fuck capitalism!
Check out this essay from Cory Doctorow, the guy who coined the word. https://pluralistic.net/2023/01/21/potemkin-ai/
Does this mean "shittification" and "enshittification" mean the same thing like "valuable" and "invaluable" mean the same thing?
Cory Doctorow is clever, but nobody ever said he was smart. I remember being at a talk where he said the original point of Napster was to sell music and I did a double take. Like dude, you lived through this, how did you already forget?
He's not completely wrong. The founders set it up as a company, so the aim was to make money somehow, and venturing into selling their services was likely the next logical move
With the Fediverse slowly gaining steam, I've been thinking a lot about the structural problems with the big social media platforms of old. I really feel like we set ourselves up for this outcome. Of course Facebook, Twitter, and Reddit were going to let us down sooner or later. We placed our trust in private centralized companies to stay good on their ethics. The moment money even entered the discourse in those spaces, they were doomed to become what they are now. I really hope Lemmy and Mastodon and Frendica and Peertube and the other Fediverse platforms can gain popularity. We have a real chance here to build social media from the ground up, but this time with the long term ethics in mind. I really think this decentralized structure can allow us to keep more transparency and allow for smaller feeling communities to thrive without being subject to tyrannical administration.
Edit: Corrected "momey" to "money". Really sounded like a weird fetish there, I am sorry. Momey is not entering the discourse in any spaces, thank you very much.
Any time I talk about decentralized apps to friends and family I come across as some kind of conspiracy driven weirdo. I do not understand why decentralization comes across as some kind of extreme radical movement. I'm not protesting or anything, everything else just sucks lol
Maybe use familiar terms? Skip the tech jargon, and go straight to things like "Reddit and Twitter and Facebook are boring old media with crappy apps and adds everywhere; the cool kids are now hanging out on Mastadon and Lemmy". But you have to really own it.
"Decentralized" means nothing to most people, or worse has been associated with crypto scams, and the stereotypical Bitcoin proselytizer. The truth is, most people can't handle all that information.
You have to appeal to emotion. Statements like "decentralization prevents interference by third parties... Blablabla" will just go over people's heads if they can't relate to an abstract concept. Say something like "My family/friends in /country/ can't buy anything with their local currency because of hyperinflation, so now they all us USD or even Bitcoin" instead. That will appeal to people's emotions.
In the case of the fediverse an appeal to emotion might look like "Reddit has just turned to shit. It's not the platform I first joined. A lot of us have moved to Lemmy and it reminds us of when we first joined Reddit."
Also, just don't push the subject. Some people are not ready to follow you. Let people figure out the benefits at their own pace. Otherwise they get defensive, and you'll do more to make yourself look like a crazy from that place than to convince.
Also there's two facts that can be used to our advantage: the internet started out non-corporate and decentralized, and it's the for-profit corporate nature of these companies that's causing the enshittification. So you can just say that you like stuff that goes back to the old good days of the internet and don't like being under the control of greedy corporations.
It's because everything is buzzwords these days. They just think decentralized is another buzzword rather than a legitimate descriptor. I blame crypto.
I try to stick to the email analogy, most people have seen email threads distributed across users on a bunch of mailservers. Don't even have to touch the d-word
Do you think "instance" is a bad word to use for the different Lemmy servers? My wife thinks so, but I'm not sure what a better word would be to use other than maybe just "server", but that also feels too techy. I do think "community" is a good non-technical word to use for the equivalent of subreddits.
Not the guy you replied to, but to me personally the word instance comes across as technical, considering how its used in programming
Not too sure if there's a normal sounding alternative, defo could benefit from a non-techie perspective here π€
Ha we had the same thought tho
"Server" has been pretty normalized (albeit abused) by discord especially, so it seems accessible to me?
"Instance" does seem vague and overly techy to me, it's an oop/code term (think "instantiate the class") that's been borrowed for casual use.
"Community=subreddit" sounds pretty good, but runs the risk of being misinterpreted as more of a "community = discord server" thing...
I'm also fond of matrix's "homeserver", a server that (while your home) isn't your only location, but that might be entirely foreign to new users too.
Definitely a tricky problem
Crypto is decentralized, though. It's an honest way of describing it. I think that more to blame are the specific crypto users who gave it a "bad name" with their shenanigans and equally the people who took that as an excuse to dump on crypto in general.
Yeah I should have been clearer, it would have been more accurate to say I blame cryptobros.
I've been trying to tell my friends about the fediverse and how happy I am using it and why I deleted my twitter account etc etc. Every time I bring it up I feel like it's very quickly dismissed as this weird nerdy thing that only I care about.
Some people only join stuff that seems mainstream and cool. You can chart Twitter growth with fans of Oprah and Donald Trump joining: before Oprah it was absolutely a nerdy thing, after I was surprised how many random average people from all walks of life had shown up. I'm talking like startup bros to fast food cashiers overnight.
@Acester47 @dylan, Reddit by default send userdata to Alphabet (Google), Amazon, ComScore and TowerData (known to use even keylogging to profile users). That is, what you write on Reddit is known by most advertising companies, along with your account data. Enshittification is falling short.