this post was submitted on 14 Oct 2023
228 points (93.2% liked)
World News
32315 readers
1206 users here now
News from around the world!
Rules:
-
Please only post links to actual news sources, no tabloid sites, etc
-
No NSFW content
-
No hate speech, bigotry, propaganda, etc
founded 5 years ago
MODERATORS
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
Protest for Palestine: They throw you in jail
Protest for Israel:
Anyone not seeing the colonial world order as fascist at this point is well beyond redemption.
Have we read the same article?
You are equating Palestine with Hamas.
Prolly referencing the article about France from yesterday
How do they defend civilians? How their recent strike helped civilians? Doesn't heads of Hamas benefit of endless slaughter refuelling the hatred as their platform?
What win lol? Israelites are now bombing regular palestinians, having a free check to erase Hamas.
Hamas doesn't lose anything in sacrificing these pesrinians to further it's standing.
Hamas wins by hurting it's people. That's why they did that senseless attack. It keeps them relevant.
Hamas isn't hurting its people. Israel is.
What was a reason for their attack now/
Israel has been attacking Gaza for a very long time. Hamas fought back. Now Israel has gone mask of and is committing genocide.
What was their targets? Was it effective? Weren't they interested in prolonging a slaughter of palestinians?
The goal was to demonstrate that Israel's government can not keep its people safe and to then use the hostages to further negotiations.
... their assumption that Israel would give a shit about hostages was clearly false, though.
This aged well
You mean the hospital Israel bombed?
>believes Israel and the US state department
>dehumanizes people they disagree with
You hate to see it. 😞
Those festivalgoers and babies on the other side of the wall were a serious threat to Palestinian civilians
Is a protest for palestinians a protest for Hamas? What Hamas did to free palestinians or make them safe from Israel's agression?
Is a protest for palestinians a protest for Hamas? No. No, it's not.
Next question.
Do you 'get in a jail' if you support palestinians excluding Hamas?
Weird question. No, you don't 'get in a jail' in this case. Also you don't get in a jail.
They did the only thing they could.
What would you recommend they do?
It's not the only thing they could, as they could as well not doing it. What they wanted to achieve with it?
I'm not a palestinian, you aren't too. How we'd judje if our takes worth anything?
To do nothing is to die. That's not a real choice.
As for what they achieved? Israel was well on its way to a fascist takeover with the rightist reforms, unprecedented protests were happening inside Israel against the government. Hamas just showed them that their government can not keep them safe and can not be trusted. That's significant, and it might just save Israeli democracy if this leads to Netanyahu's ousting.
Israel was also well on its way to normalizing relations with the entire Arab world, and now Hamas has provoked them into throwing that all out the window and instead inviting condemnation and isolation in the region.
Hamas has also opened up a new front against the American empire. Now instead of only needing to focus on Ukraine it has had its attention split to the 51st state and Greatest Ally. At the same time, there is no House Speaker. And the Republican frontrunner is a criminal.
Hamas is smart. They attacked at a very opportune moment.
And you don't believe Hamas' heads are just opportiunistic assholes like Netanyahu? That they don't want get money and power from it? Like Hamas don't have gains and support from dying palestinian civs?
What Hamas did to palestinians with that attack?
They live under apartheid, what money and power is there to be found? They are staring down the barrel of genocide and fighting for survival.
No, I don't. I think Hamas is ready and willing to die to fight Israel. That's not the behavior of people who only want money and power.
Hamas has done nothing to Palestinians. This is all Israel. Place blame where it belongs.
The same statement could be applied to zionists. They could very well not do colonialism, apartheid, genocide, etc. No one is forcing them to take everything from Palestine and visit extraordinary horrors upon Palestinians.
It sucks what has happened, but it honestly looks to me like they may have achieved their goals. They provoked an overreaction from Israel which has cost them a ton of goodwill from the global community. It's also made more people aware of just how violent Israel has been and how many innocent people they kill. If Palestine still exists at the end of this conflict, I would very much expect changes that make things generally better for Palestinians.