this post was submitted on 22 May 2024
1094 points (97.5% liked)
Memes
49860 readers
3038 users here now
Rules:
- Be civil and nice.
- Try not to excessively repost, as a rule of thumb, wait at least 2 months to do it if you have to.
founded 6 years ago
MODERATORS
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
True, increased demand for meat is one of the driving factors of ecological malpractise as it's found in the meat industry.
Plant based diets and a lifestyle free of animal products provide a more sustainable and ecologically beneficial alternative. As does reducing the overall world population of course.
A lifetime free of animal products is not sustainable. Humans need at least some meat to survive. The average person eats too much which isn't helping. Advocating a vegan (or even vegetarian) diet is ignoring science and how our bodies function. It causes long-term, serious harm to people who do not supplement their diet with at least some meat.
Pure veganism is a cult that ignores science, diet, and common sense. Nothing wrong with eating vegan meals (I love them) but completely cutting out meat is bad for you.
That is not correct.
To the contrary. It is very much supported by science. Are you interested in the scientific literature? I'll happily share.
It's impossible to trust any sources these days because there are hidden agendas. The fact remains: we are omnivores and have shown to have used meat to evolve to current humans with high intelligence.
No amount of "scientific literature" can contradict actual, basic, fundamental science about who we are and what we are supposed to eat. Anyone who does has an agenda.
Sounds more like, "I don't like it, so it must be an agenda".
If you have issues trusting science we won't come to an agreement here. Having a biased view and choosing what you want to believe, despite contradicting evidence, is building an illusion and not having an accurate picture of reality.
Note that research on that topic has not just popped up in the last couple of years. Also you may take a look at other cultures for hands-on counterexamples, e.g. some monks who live and have lived their whole lifes without consuming animal products.
I wonder how you decide what a "fact" is, since you have issues trusting the work of scientists.
Anyway:
The fact also remains that digestion capabilites, i.e. being able to eat both plant and animal matter, don't necessarily impose dietary recommendations.
What you need to survive is a set of nutrients your body can digest. In which form they come, is less important.
The science doesn't agree with that
https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/27886704/
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/am/pii/S1050173818300240
https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/12778049/
So precisely how long are vegans able to survive without suffering ill effects? Because I mean we've all heard of people who have lived on that diet long term, so at what point do the wheels start to fall off so to speak? Is there some kind of extended latency period where you are okay before you get sick, or are vegan influencers just pretending to be healthy?
Also your how do you propose we change our agricultural practices so that our food supply isn't tainted by sick meat grown in poor conditions? There's a lot of evidence that there's not enough land mass on earth to feed everyone a diet of free range grass fed beef. Or do you propose we run full steam ahead with factory farming and damn the consequences?
No vegan has lived on a pure vegan diet long enough to not have severe issues. If you search you will find tons of former vegans who were forced off of their pure vegan diets by severe medical issues. People who call themselves "vegans" and are still doing well after a long time are either really vegetarians who eat a lot of animal-derived products to compensate, or cheat and eat meat here and there.
Yes i understand what you are getting at there, but my question is precisely how long does one have before the wheels fall off while eating a strict vegan diet? Are we talking a matter of days, weeks, months, years, or decades?
Sources or STFU.
Can you provide some links to that science?
Every single unbiased description of a human being ever. Don't bother with your vegan-funded "health" organizations who just want to kill us.
It's funny how every single vegan comes after me whenever I say the obvious fact that we need meat. Almost like they are a cult and want to hide the truth. The reason I come after vegans is because it's dangerous and abusive and unhealthy, not because of some programmed agenda that has to be carefully hidden by a death cult.
I'm not vegan, I eat meat. I ask for evidence because you're clearly biased and using emotionally charged and unscientific language when you dismiss the vegan diet. So I don't believe you have a real understanding of the science or potential nutritional complications.
Don't bother replying with "it's just common sense" reworded for a third time. If you can't provide evidence, that's fine, but you don't need to keep going on your dramatic crusade against something you don't understand in the comments. I'm not asking for your opinion.
What evidence do you want? The tons of descriptions about human beings in our entire history isn't enough for you? The fact that our teeth, our digestive system, and every single part of us is engineered to require meat? You can't argue against science, because you're just wrong if you do. All of these "studies" are doing is trying to rally against established science. This isn't opinion. This isn't some "dramatic crusade". This is fact. You are the one that cannot and will not understand facts. And I don't care if you claim to eat meat, you're apparently arguing against it which goes against what you say you are doing which makes me believe that you're lying just to make people think you're "objective" and "open minded" when you're anything but.
We are omnivores. This is a fact. We need at least some meat to live well. This is a fact. I have never claimed that vegetarian or vegan meals are bad for you. I have never claimed that we need to eat a ton of meat; on the contrary, I believe we do eat too much meat as a society and can cut back quite a bit. But cutting it out entirely? No. That's wrong. That goes against everything we are as human beings.
I don't know what else I can tell you. If you still are hung up on your vegan bullshit, I have nothing else to say because you're just brainwashed and in a cult. It's that simple.
I want literally any evidence. You are clearly incapable of providing any to support your even most basic claim. I'm not arguing against meat, I'm arguing against ignorance and dishonesty. I had rotisserie chicken from Walmart for lunch. If you had provided any source for your claim, I would have read it fully and with an open mind. I'm not biased towards veganism, I wanted to know if the claims you are making have any basis in reality so I can make an informed decision. This is your third comment saying the same thing without evidence, and arguing like a child. I don't mean that to be derogatory either, if you're still in school or a child, that's fine. But I'm not interested in a discussion at that level.
You have shown repeatedly that you can't have an honest discussion and are close minded and conspiratorial. I'm not going to bother replying anymore, it's just getting obnoxious.
Instead of constantly badgering me here, maybe try a search or two to get a flood of actual, unbiased proof that vegan diets are unhealthy. Ever think of that? Because that's what I did when vegans started claiming your bullshit.
And tell me this: if you're so fucking convinced vegans are right, why did you eat meat? Hmm? Because you didn't. You're a brainless, starving for actual substance vegan cosplaying as an omnivore trying to gain any shred of credibility. Fuck off.
I'm not convinced vegans are right. If you're so convinced that I'm lying, why do you keep replying? Are you just trolling or do you have anger issues?
And if you can't provide me with a single link to back up your own claim, then I don't believe you have spent a single second researching unbiased proof.
Fucking dumbass didn't even do 2 seconds of googling lmfao
Ah yes humans evolved to eat everything. Now let me just cut a part of that diet out of my life.
We evolved to NEED to eat everything, plants AND animals. Basic science, vegan cultist. You're a death cult and just as bad as religion, spreading unhealthy bullshit to people who don't know any better.
You know what's funny?
People say that like forever. And those "vegan cultists" we told that 3 decades ago (and we were waiting for them to die of malnutrition) are still healthy and happy while the average supermarket-joe got fat and unhappy or is long dead by now.
I'm no vegan btw. but why would i argue with science? Just because we evolved to be able to eat nearly everything doesn't mean we should. We could probably survive a good while on just eating hoofs or tree bark. Doesn't mean we should include it in our diet.
Science says meat contains proteins and nutrients that are incredibly difficult to get and get enough of in plants to live well.
In case you were unaware, it was the fact that we became meat-eating omnivores that is the REASON we evolved to become the intelligent creatures we are. Do vegans want to de-evolve into basic, stupid creatures? Seems that way.
I swear, people like you do nothing but spread misinformation and I'm fucking sick of it. Veganism is a laughable, horrible, unsafe, dangerous cult and you actually defend it.
Science doesn't say we need meat. Also very specially not the crappy processed toxic waste the majority consumes as "meat".
But ever tried a diet only existing of plants/fruits OR meat? Guess on which you'd live longer? Exactly.
And again, no vegan here. Just also sick of this super old "but science says we need meat".
WE.
NEED.
BOTH.
YOU.
UNEDUCATED.
TWATWAFFLE.
"Lasting longer" on plants means we get the nutrition we need to barely continuously function on plants. That's like pushing around a car and claiming it still works. Our cognitive abilities and our core strength both rely on animal meat to run at their full capacity. And even with just plants, our health slowly deteriorates to the point where even that isn't enough any more. Look up the vast number of people online who have recanted their vegan vows because of severe health issues. People who say they're pure vegan and don't have issues are either vegetarian (which an added strong diet of eggs is a vast improvement over a pure vegan diet though not perfect) and/or cheat on their diet (which is much more likely).
You can't argue against science. It's pathetic. You're like the fucking flat earthers and god-lovers. Still clinging to an obsolete, bullshit, laughable belief in fucking 2024 when we should all be together in understanding how the world fucking works.
Get over yourself.
Who needs to get over whom? Probably the ad-hominem hero. Talking about science but behaving like an agitated chimp. Go work less and chill more 😁
I prefer civilized discussion, so... Have a nice life.
What made you think I am vegan?