This is an automated archive made by the Lemmit Bot.
The original was posted on /r/tifu by /u/External_Arachnid179 on 2024-08-19 13:54:42+00:00.
So, this happened a couple of days ago, and I’m still cringing every time I think about it.
I’m 29F, and while I’m no professional baker, I’ve always loved baking for friends and family. My best friend (who’s basically my sister) is lactose intolerant, and for her birthday this year, I decided to surprise her with a homemade, dairy-free cake. She’s super careful about what she eats, and I wanted to make something special and safe just for her. Easy, right? Well…
I found this vegan chocolate cake recipe online, and it looked perfect—like, even better than some of the regular cakes I’ve made in the past. I made a special trip to the store, got all the right ingredients, and double-checked everything to make sure it was 100% dairy-free. I was determined not to mess this up.
Everything went smoothly while making the cake. I measured out the almond milk, mixed everything together, and when it came out of the oven, it looked and smelled incredible. I was actually a little proud of myself, thinking, “Hey, maybe I should do this more often!”
Then came the frosting. This is where I royally screwed up. I had bought a tub of dairy-free cream cheese to make the frosting because she loves that tangy-sweet flavor. But—and here’s where I turned into a complete idiot—I accidentally grabbed a regular tub of cream cheese from my fridge. I still don’t know how I managed to overlook the giant “cream cheese” label, but in my mind, I was just on autopilot.
It wasn’t until after I’d mixed it up, spread it all over the cake, and licked the spoon (don’t judge, it’s the best part) that I realized something was wrong. The taste was too creamy, too rich… too real. That’s when I saw the empty tub on the counter. It was the regular, full-fat, lactose-packed cream cheese. I think I stood there in shock for a full minute before the panic set in.
I tried to scrape off the frosting as best I could and made a new batch with the actual dairy-free cream cheese, but I knew it wasn’t going to be perfect. There was no hiding what had happened, especially because I’m a terrible liar.
At the party, I gave her the cake and tried to act all casual, but I ended up blurting out the truth. I told her I’d accidentally frosted the cake with regular cream cheese and then tried to fix it. I was fully expecting her to be upset or at least disappointed, but instead, she burst out laughing. Apparently, she’d been worried I’d stress myself out trying to make everything perfect and was relieved to know I’m still the same slightly scatterbrained friend she’s always known.
In the end, we all had a good laugh about it. She was super understanding and avoided the frosting, just to be safe, but she loved the cake anyway. And of course, everyone else at the party thought it was hilarious. I’m just glad my little screw-up didn’t ruin the day!
TL;DR: Tried to bake a lactose-free cake for my best friend’s birthday, accidentally used regular cream cheese in the frosting, confessed my mistake, and we all ended up laughing about it. She’s still my bestie, and the cake was still a hit!