this post was submitted on 29 Jun 2025
301 points (98.7% liked)
Tech
1462 readers
213 users here now
A community for high quality news and discussion around technological advancements and changes
Things that fit:
- New tech releases
- Major tech changes
- Major milestones for tech
- Major tech news such as data breaches, discontinuation
Things that don't fit
- Minor app updates
- Government legislation
- Company news
- Opinion pieces
founded 1 year ago
MODERATORS
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
I'm sorry, I don't really get it. What sides? And who didn't read the article? That's their main conclusion as well. Plus they add some fluff before and after. But that's not really important. Could you maybe explain what an "device open alternative" is? I don't know that term. And it's kind of hard to find anything just by googling "device open".
I'm talking about all the people going "good" in this thread out of hostility for Windows/MS without realizing the change being described is a move to a more closed-off, privacy-invasive environment, not the opposite. Which is a result of either not reading past the headline or being so polarized on the issue that they are willing to take the downsides for the sake of schadenfreude.
As for what I meant by that vague term, I just didn't want to say "an open mobile OS". Mostly because... well, it invites a lot of open questions about Android I don't think are interesting right now, but also because I think "mobile OS" is increasingly a misnomer.
People are clearly using iOS and Android as their main computing platforms now, both of them are rolling out full multi-window desktops for larger devices out of the box and they're both already usable that way with limitations right now. When you say "mobile OS" people visualize a phone and want to talk about Linux on phones and... that's probably not the right answer or the right way to look at it.
Thanks for explaining. It's a bit tricky if you invent words without explaining them at the same time.
You're right. I'm used to read stupid takes here on Lemmy, so I mainly ignored those. It is like you said. People are moving more towards mobile devices where they're not in control of anything. They're mostly walled gardens. You don't get administrator privileges, Google or whoever is making those choices for you. And they're so easy to use, you don't even learn anything about the internet and their inner workings. It's all a service and content magically appears on your screen. All of that is a step down from where we've been before.
I struggle to recommend Microsoft instead. While it's still a computer and that definitely changes things, they're headed in exactly the same direction. Everything is set on spying per default these days, and they also try to lure you in into their walled gardens, paid services instead if owning software or disk space... It's not the same level. But not good either.
Ideally we don't want any of them to be in control of our platforms and devices, but have some control ourselves. With smartphones that's next to impossible. With windows you might be able to pull it off if you put in some effort, since it's not the default experience. Given it's something that can be changed.