In addition to what everyone else said, which is basically right, I suspect that reddit has thorough data and research tracking how topics are discussed en-masse and how narratives form across the site. I would wager that we were visible enough to actually make a dent in the liberal centrist "hive mind" and they had an incentive to snuff us out before our ideas started to affect the general vibes of the place by providing coherent, popular, and catchy anti-capitalist and anti-American sentiments
this post was submitted on 18 Nov 2024
56 points (100.0% liked)
chat
8197 readers
368 users here now
Chat is a text only community for casual conversation, please keep shitposting to the absolute minimum. This is intended to be a separate space from c/chapotraphouse or the daily megathread. Chat does this by being a long-form community where topics will remain from day to day unlike the megathread, and it is distinct from c/chapotraphouse in that we ask you to engage in this community in a genuine way. Please keep shitposting, bits, and irony to a minimum.
As with all communities posts need to abide by the code of conduct, additionally moderators will remove any posts or comments deemed to be inappropriate.
Thank you and happy chatting!
founded 3 years ago
MODERATORS
This isn't the right question. The right question is why cth3 got banned for hate speech when it clearly hated speech.
Honestly, being banned for saying "kill slave owners" was sick as fuck. Reminds me off thallman death scene
We were inciting violence against long dead historical figures. That's the official reason. In reality reddit has consistently b& subreddits which turn a critical lens on the rest of the site.
The earliest one I can remember being a part of was the r/shitredditsays community which helped expose a bunch of child porn adjacent and other gross communities and misanthropic power users. Nothing was done about these communities until the efforts of r/SRS to shed light on them were picked up by more mainstream media platforms. This resulted in the questionable communities being banned (they mostly just popped back up under different names) and also the r/SRS subreddit network being banned.
Reddit will tolerate circlejerk and drama communities, but once people actually take intra-site activism seriously they shut that shit down ASAP every time because advertisers tend to recoil in horror once they learn what the platform actually hosts.
The dynamics are a bit different these days now that platforms are being co-opted by well funded political parties and their subsidiary support orgs.
Kill ALL slave owners john brown did nothing wrong
/r/cth was the only subreddit openly cheering the George Floyd uprising and subsequent race riots; we had dope pictures of the precinct and cars going up in flames.
It didn’t help as a mod, I’d re-approve removed comments which I thought did not deserve it. 😅
We love our mods! 
it was saying that it was good to kill slave owners and that john brown did nothing wrong. and not removing posts that said that even though reddit told the mods that they had to take it down cuz it was "violent rhetoric."
larger context was Bernie being shut out of the primary and George Floyd
https://www.mintpressnews.com/jessica-ashooh-reddit-national-security-state-plant/277639/
And cause bash the fash is apparently hate speech, and cth was one of the last one to ban it.
It's hate speech toward a protected class: cops
r/cth had gained some amount of notoriety in the public eye years before even the quarantine. It was a meme that the subreddit was more popular than the podcast.
I went digging and here were some posts from the r/cth mods when communicating about the quarantine.
September 2019: Announcement: Quarantine Appeal Sent
Before the quarantine there was a shadow war with r/TD. r/cth got sabotaged by r/TD sympathizers back in 2018 so brazenly it made Mother Jones
The moderators’ changes came two weeks ago, after a group of leftists users from the r/ChapoTrapHouse podcast subreddit had allegedly “brigaded” r/Libertarian. (“Brigading” is a Reddit term for when outside users come into a group to troll it by downvoting posts.) One of r/Libertarian’s moderators, Reddit user rightc0ast, and new moderators that rightc0ast brought on between December 6 and 7, argued that they needed to tighten the group’s laissez-faire rules to protect it from outside trolling.
...
The subreddit’s users, along with posters in other libertarian subreddits like r/LibertarianUncensored and r/LibertarianPartyUSA, immediately decried the changes as a departure from libertarian ethos while calling attention to the background of users behind the change. Most of the five new moderators have a posting history showing them taking part in r/The_Donald, an infamous pro-Trump subreddit, and r/Physical_Removal, a subreddit dedicated to the idea of eventually forcibly removing liberals and leftists from society that was banned in 2017 for “posting content that incites violence.” Two of the moderators who helped engineer the changes—one has since been removed—had previously voiced support for the regime of Chilean dictator Augusto Pinochet and debated the merits of fascism.
Rightc0ast, who played a key role in taking over the group by inviting new allied moderators, has a particularly troubling trail of posts across Reddit. In August 2017, Rightc0ast promoted the then-upcoming Unite The Right white supremacist protests in Charlottesville, Virginia. The white nationalist provocateur has also backed the idea of an ethnostate and supported the Fash The Nation podcast, which was created by a neo-Nazi blog. On Reddit, he was a moderator of r/The_Donald and a moderator of r/Physical_Removal.
Bonus find while searching for the above
A Short History of LF: The Original Dirtbag Left/Weird Twitter
About SomethingAwful's old Left section that was the :cool-zone: where all the hip kids hung out, making everybody jealous.
Eventually calls for violence grew louder. At one point, the Secret Service contacted Lowtax (who runs SA) about all the constant death threats to the president-which in retrospect is hilarious.
...
LF was becoming a left-wing version of /pol/ (albeit with a lot less real world impact) and was being put down. At one point everyone who posted in the forum was given the av with "certified forum cancer" and their texted greyed out unless you hovered over it (yes seriously). Then finally by around late 2011 it got shut down.
NEVER STOP POSTING!
A CIA op. Like literally a former CIA agent had just been brought in as a community manager.
Also this https://networkcontagion.us/reports/network-enabled-anarchy/
Take a drink every time you read "anarch-socialist extremism" and try not to die of alcohol poisoning.
If you ctrl f chapotraphouse you can see where we are mentioned.
Correction: NCRI removed “ISIS” from the report’s initial comparison table because many interpreted this claim to mean NCRI was depicting Anarchists/Socialist threats as the same magnitude of ISIS.
Lmao Jesus christ
oh yeah we clowned on them so hard over it they had to issue a retraction.
This is the table in question, all they did was change "ISIS" to "organized jihadi group"
I wish the left was half as organized as this shit assumes
Anacho-Socialist extremists are really serious about not eating Mexican snacks.
lmao I forgot they repeatedly misspelled it
Oh this is ringing bells! I remember this being talked about at the time.
Yeah we did a drinking game with it back on the lifeboat discord and I got wayyy too fucked up.
I remember the last post on there was a thread saying "if this place gets banned then thanks for being the only non-trans specific subr*ddit that actually gives a shit about us on this site" and then the sub got nuked
This was the post. I saved it.
My final comment on r/cth in that very thread. I refreshed the page a few minutes after and it was gone.
Best way to go out, to be honest
r/chapotraphouse was banned by the CIA
My posts were just too good and it was making the deep state nervous
banned r/The_Donald that day too. Reddit admins wanted to seem fair & balanced as if they hadn’t been profiting off of allowing several openly white nationalist hate subreddits to infest their platform for years until it was absolutely necessary to ban them to save their ad dollars and IPO prospects.
It's also worth nothing that r/The_Donald's userbase had moved off of reddit to one of their fashie sites months ago, and the subreddit had been completely dead for months when they banned it.
If I remember right tho The Donald had already mostly moved off of Reddit by that point, the sub was pretty much dead
yeah it had been a ghost town for months, they had moved to thedonald.win
This is jogging my memory now. I remember when The_Donald was banned and people talking about CTH getting banned too. Gotta cut each end of the horseshoe right?
Except the_donald had already left.
Reddit wanted to ban cth so they banned both the sub with 10s of thousands of comments a day and the one with 6 active users to "combat extremism"
The_donald broadcasted unite the right wherein a fascist killed heather heyer
Cth just said words that offended capitalist sensibilities
They had a thread about Unite the Right where the OP was ”I know ’ethnostate’ people are going to be there, but that's the price we have to pay”, they weren't even subtle about associating with Nazis and promoted far more violence than CTH ever did, yet the sub was allowed to exist for years.
It’s also interesting how this is happening with llms
Rhetoric that threatens existing power structures has no room to linger. Since fascism still shares a lot of traits with unmitigated and decaying capital (in addition to the fact that LLMs are trained on Reddit) it hangs around much longer than leftist rhetoric that is openly hostile to the bourgeois.
It’s all an escape from propaganda babeeeeeee
Calling for killing cops and slave owners, just based stuff.
It was popular and sorta leftist. As long as those two conditions existed it was doomed. If it were not banned for one particular post it would have been for another convenient or contrived reason.
Saying slavers should get shot. Bunch of crybaby shitlibs reported us for "violent rhetoric" and reddit had to ban something on the left to seem even handed because it was banning the_Donald at the same time.
The Donald was long dead already they banned the Donald to seem even handed because they had been planning to ban cth
My bad, that's what it was. I remember that false equivalent bullshit but I guess I remembered it backwards
Yeah, it was me sorry. I finally posted hog and it was considered too hot for Reddit to handle so they banned me, and every sub i had ever posted in just to be sure. My B.
Hog’d out and log’d out
Your hog was so epic that I made it my whole personality
The had to purge some nazi subreddits but they wanted to appear 'balanced' so they selected the most popular left wing subs and removed them as well
We will never know the real reason.