can i be nominated for worst poster anyway
chapotraphouse
Banned? DM Wmill to appeal.
No anti-nautilism posts. See: Eco-fascism Primer
Slop posts go in c/slop. Don't post low-hanging fruit here.
I know everyone is having fun here but I personally find this whole thing tres icky. A literal popularity contest?
Maybe someone would like to explain to me how this won't lead to problems like resentment, big egos, anxiety, performance pressure, tensions, jealousies, celebrity, hurt feelings, deference etc. There are just so many pre-existing issues individually and relationally something like this could exacerbate, or even create. For all involved: who do or do not nominate/comment/vote/win.
I feel bad posting this because I guess that it will be read as maybe I don't like the people who are nominated, that I wish to be nominated etc. Anticipate any criticism, no matter the content, will initially be suspected of pettiness. Or that I am belittling the genuine affection being solicited and shared here. Don't think that's just my own idiosyncratic anxieties. The structure is created in such a way as to disincentivize ~~being the fun police~~ criticism. That makes me really uneasy too.
The idea of recognizing people who make contributions is perfectly sound. I am just not sure this is a good way. Making an institution (even as a quote/unquote "bit") of the idea that this is a place where some people are officially popular is a very weird choice for a left/communist community.
The best defense of this I can anticipate is that it'll come and go and nobody'll remember in a week. And besides it's probably a slow time for the site so fewer people than usual will even see it.
It's just a fun silly thing, it's not official. I just made it up. Last years was a wholesome trip down memory lane and this year is looking to be much the same. Nobody actually wins anything this is just a silly format based on something like the Emmys for a end of the year recap post where we call each other out and remember the fun we had together on Hexbear this year. That's all! I'm sorry it makes you feel the ick though that's definitely not the intention.
Well I agree with you, I think it's a very fun idea indeed.
Seems like some harmless fun to me. Imo we should deal with it after it's shown to be a bad idea rather than preemptively shutting it down
Hmm... If everyone is already emotionally mature, then a contest like this can't really have a harmful effect, right? So wouldn't the questions then be, 1) what is our "threat model" for users being emotionally immature; and 2) what exactly is the relationship between emotional immaturity and the ability to win contests or be "officially popular"?
'Cause on the one hand, if you win family game night five times in a row and start going "mirror mirror on the wall" about it, would you say that that's the fault of family game night having winners, or is it there an extraneous root cause of that behavior that needs to be addressed instead?
Then on the other hand, Jacob Louis Veldhuyzen van Zanten appearing in loads of KLM promotional material is believed to have contributed to his mental state as his plane barreled down the Los Rodeos runway that fateful day in 1977, and this led to a change in airline culture towards celebrity pilots and the effective end of actual pilots being used in airlines' advertising... Or so I swear I once heard, at least.
...I don't really know where I'm going with this. Family game night and the deadliest aviation disaster in history really have little in common, and neither have much in common with a popularity contest on an obscure communist link aggregation site.
In any case what I can say is that it's probably not the end of the world: I've seen contests like this in other online communities over the years and it's never caused any sort of trouble in practice that I've seen.
However it not causing trouble in practice, so far, that I've seen, doesn't necessarily mean that it actually is completely benign.
It is kind of hard, I like many people on here. Some are close friends. But I just try not to take it seriously and move on.
Lmao didn't know we had this
Was I rlly gone already last year that I missed the first? Zamn
Carter dies
Obama comes back
Welcome back mr president
It's not official I just thought it was funny last year and then it became very wholesome so I did it again this year
Nominating myself for best lurker who posts some comments every two months who is too afraid to make an actual post myself after being bullied on r/chapotraphouse but in a deserved way because I only made posts when drunk.
I nominate @femboy@hexbear.net and @twink * because uhm. Let me be queer
/* I remember they deleted their acc cuz of the volcel bit and I was so dissapointed they took the username to the grave with them
I'm the best overall poster